[News] Fact or fiction? Israeli maps and AI do not save Palestinian lives

[Anti-Imperialist News]

 Fact or fiction? Israeli maps and AI do not save Palestinian lives

*Israel’s narrative of ‘evacuation warnings’ and ‘precision strikes’ serves
as a cover for its AI-assisted genocide in Gaza.*

   - Marc Owen Jones
   <https://www.aljazeera.com/author/marc_owen_jones_200519080923295>
   Dr Marc Owen Jones is Assistant Professor of Middle East Studies and
   Digital Humanities at Hamad bin Khalifa University.

Published On 4 Dec 2023
<https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Faje.io%2Fp6wuc7>
<https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Fact%20or%20fiction%3F%20Israeli%20maps%20and%20AI%20do%20not%20save%20Palestinian%20lives&source=sharethiscom&related=sharethis&via=AJEnglish&url=https%3A%2F%2Faje.io%2Fp6wuc7>
[image: smoke billows into the air]
An Israeli bombardment of Gaza is seen in this picture taken from southern
Israel on December 2, 2023 [Jack Guez/AFP]

On December 2, the Israeli army’s Arabic-language spokesperson Avichay
Adraee posted a map of Gaza, broken up into a grid of numbered blocks with
instructions that Palestinians living in certain areas evacuate to Rafah.
Leaflets containing a QR code linking to the map on the Israeli army’s
website were also dropped over Gaza.

This move came as Israeli fighter jets bombarded the south of the Strip –
previously designated as a “safe zone” – killing hundreds
<https://www.aljazeera.com/news/liveblog/2023/12/3/israel-gaza-war-live-israel-bombards-gaza-as-talks-break-down>
of Palestinians in 24 hours. The Israeli army proudly announced that it had
hit “400 targets”.

Meanwhile, media reports revealed that the Israeli army’s ability to
intensify what it calls “precision” air strikes has been boosted by an
artificial intelligence (AI) tool that generates “targets”.

The maps, the leaflets, the tweets, the claims of “precision” military
technology, all feed into the narrative that Israel’s “most moral army” is
taking care to protect civilians in Gaza. But all these are no more than a
propaganda ploy to cover up what really is happening on the ground – an
AI-assisted genocide.
A game of maps

Over the past two months of brutal war, Israel has constantly resorted to
the use of “evacuation” maps and warnings issued on social media, calling
on Palestinians to flee certain areas of Gaza.

Yet the mounting death toll – nearly 16,000 people and thousands more
missing and likely dead – offers no evidence that Israel is in fact
concerned about the wellbeing of Palestinian civilians.

What it is concerned is about the growing condemnations abroad of what
legal experts are calling genocide and increasing pressure from the United
States.

Just a few days ago, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken warned Israel it
has weeks, and not months, to finish its campaign in Gaza. His boss,
President Joe Biden, is acutely aware of the growing domestic discontent
with how he is handling the war, which could cost him votes in next year’s
presidential election.

This “evacuation messaging” the Israeli army has been undertaking is more
directed at Western audiences, seeking to assuage their fears about the
civilian death toll, than the Palestinians in Gaza. The fact that it is
delivered mostly on social media platforms indicates the intended audience
is not the people in the Strip.

The Israeli army has not only cut off electricity to Gaza but also targeted
and damaged its already temperamental mobile network, thus leaving most of
the people there with almost no access to the internet.

The leaflets that were dropped over the weekend are also not worth the
paper they were printed on. The QR code on them is of use only if there is
a working phone with a charged battery and internet access.

Discrepancies of different maps being shared by Israeli officials have also
resulted in additional confusion. Areas marked for targeting in orange did
not even correspond with the numbers of blocks officials were telling
people to evacuate from.

Consequently, the overall impact of the maps has been to create “fear,
panic and confusion”, as Melanie Ward, CEO of Medical Aid for Palestinians,
explained in a tweet.

Furthermore, the detailed mapping and dissection of Gaza are designed to
create the illusion of precision and precaution, but the evacuation orders
behind them demonstrate the opposite.

Gaza is 360 square kilometres and has a population of 2.3 million. The
average size of each of the 620 blocks on the map is 0.58 square
kilometres, which means approximately 3,700 residents per block.

Asking dozens of blocks equating to tens of thousands of people to move is
hardly “precision”. It is mass displacement masquerading as parsimonious
precaution.
Israel’s digital killing machine

Apart from using digital maps and QR codes to try and prove to its allies
that its army is not reckless, Israel is also boasting about its
“precision” military technologies.

Among them is an AI weapons system called “Habsora” (“The Gospel”) which
can quickly and automatically identify targets, much faster than older
methods.

If in previous bombing campaigns, the Israeli army would manually select 50
targets per day, today the new system provides 100.

According to one source quoted by the +972 magazine, this weapon has turned
the Israeli army into a “mass assassination factory”, focusing more on the
“quantity and not quality”.

The magazine reports that the Israeli soldiers using the AI targeting
system are aware of the number of civilians they will kill; it is displayed
in the category “collateral damage” in the target file.

The Israeli army has categorised thresholds of civilian deaths, ranging
from five to the hundreds. The directive “collateral damage five”, for
example, means the Israeli soldiers are authorised to kill a target that
will also kill 5 civilians.

On the higher end, “the Israeli military command knowingly approved the
killing of hundreds of Palestinian civilians in an attempt to assassinate a
single top Hamas military commander”, +972 magazine reports.

Given that Israel considers all 30,000 Hamas members in Gaza as potential
targets, this means that “wiping out” the movement would entail a massive
civilian death toll. If we use the lowest “collateral damage five”, the
most conservative estimate amounts to 150,000 civilians.

Of course, as Hamas leaders that are killed are inevitably replaced,
hundreds more Palestinians will be murdered as the AI system generates more
new targets. Since Hamas cannot be defeated militarily, the only logical
outcome of this will be the perpetual murder or removal of everyone in Gaza.

Another disturbing element of AI is that it reproduces biases it has been
trained on. Historically, Israel has shown little regard for civilian life
in its bombing. One has to wonder to what extent the secretive AI has
learned to associate any Palestinian with “Hamas terrorist” based on past
Israeli army behaviour. This might explain why it is able to generate so
many new “targets” for bombing.
The propaganda of precision

Israel likes to boast about its morality
<https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2023/10/16/the-myth-of-israels-most-moral>
and high-tech, precision strike capabilities, ironically as a means of
defending itself against claims of indiscriminately attacking civilians and
allegations of war crimes.

This characterisation of the Israeli army’s technological sophistication is
also used by the US to help justify its support for Israel. Blinken, for
example, has stated that “Israel has … one of the most sophisticated
militaries in the world. It is capable of neutralising the threat posed by
Hamas while minimising harm to innocent men, women and children.”

But the more the US and Israel promote the narrative of its technological
prowess, the more it gives an element of legal jeopardy. As international
law professor Michael Schmitt argues
<https://www.icrc.org/en/doc/assets/files/other/irrc_859_schmitt.pdf>, “the
greater the precision capabilities of an attacker, the more compelling the
characterisation of an attack striking civilians or civilian objects as
reckless”.

In other words, a high-tech army has more of an obligation to try and
“prove” that they are not being reckless. The more Israel and the US boast
of Israel’s technical prowess, the more people question why so many
civilians are being killed.

The only answer is that Israel has precision weapons, but is still
targeting people indiscriminately. Thus, sophisticated technology, rather
than serving its ostensible purpose of precision and precaution, is instead
weaponised as a tool of mass killing and destruction. In other words, what
we are seeing in Gaza is an AI-assisted genocide.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20231204/0b3c7d49/attachment.htm>