[News] This seemingly endless and ugly game of the peace process is now finally over
Anti-Imperialist News
news at freedomarchives.org
Mon Jan 24 11:54:31 EST 2011
This seemingly endless and ugly game of the peace process is now finally over
The peace process is a sham. Palestinians must
reject their officials and rebuild their movement.
Sunday 23 January 2011 20.02 GMT
It's over. Given the shocking nature, extent and
detail of these ghastly revelations from behind
the closed doors of the Middle East peace
process, the seemingly endless and ugly game is
now, finally, over. Not one of the villains on
the Palestinian side can survive it. With any
luck the sheer horror of this account of how the
US and Britain covertly facilitated and even
implemented Israeli military expansion while
creating an oligarchy to manage it might
overcome the entrenched interests and venality
that have kept the
<http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/middle-east-peace-talks>peace
process going. A small group of men who have
polluted the Palestinian public sphere with their
private activities are now exposed.
For us Palestinians, these detailed accounts of
the secretly negotiated surrender of every one of
our core rights under international law (of
return for millions of Palestinian refugees, on
annexing Arab Jerusalem, on settlements) are not
a surprise. It is something that we all knew in
spite of official protests to the contrary
because we feel their destructive effects every
day. The same is true of the outrageous role of
the US and Britain in creating a security
bantustan, and the ruin of our civic and
political space. We already knew, because we feel its fatal effects.
For the overwhelming majority of Palestinians,
official Palestinian policy over these past
decades has been the antithesis of a legitimate,
or representative, or even coherent strategy to
obtain our long-denied freedom. But this sober
appreciation of our current state of affairs,
accompanied by the mass protests and civil
society campaigns by Palestinian citizens, has
been insufficient, until now, to rid us of it.
The release into the public domain of these
documents is such a landmark because it destroys
the final traces of credibility of the peace
process. Everything to do with it relied upon a
single axiom: that each new initiative or set of
negotiations with the Israelis, every policy or
programme (even the creation of undemocratic
institutions under military occupation), could be
presented as carried out in good faith under
harsh conditions: necessary for peace, and in the
service of our national cause. Officials from all
sides played a double game vis-à-vis the
Palestinians. It is now on record that they have
betrayed, lied and cheated us of basic rights,
while simultaneously claiming they deserved the
trust of the Palestinian people.
This claim of representative capacity and
worse, the assertion they were representing the
interests of Palestinians in their struggle for
freedom had become increasingly thin over the
last decade and a half. The claim they were
acting in good faith is absolutely shattered by
the publication of these documents today, and the
information to be revealed over this coming week.
Whatever one's political leanings, no one, not
the Americans, the British, the UN, and
especially not these Palestinian officials, can
claim that the whole racket is anything other
than a brutal process of subjugating an entire people.
Why has this gone on for so long and at such high
cost? And why haven't the Palestinians been able
to create the democratic representation so
urgently needed to advance their cause? Israel,
along with those who share its worldview, would
assert that the problem lies with the
Palestinians themselves, being part of an Arab
political culture that can only breed either
authoritarian governments or terrorists. Yet what
these documents reveal is the extent of
undemocratic, authoritarian, colonial and,
frankly, terrifying coercion the US, Britain and
other western governments have been imposing upon
Palestinians through this unaccountable leadership.
The unconstrained power of America, the global
superpower that has (now on record and in
sickening detail) taken one party's side in this
conflict, can be seen on every page. Everyone is
implicated, from the president to the secretary
of state, from the military generals who have
created the security forces to implement these
policies to the embassy staff involved in the
daily execution of them. It also shows this
policy is an absolute failure, bringing ruination
upon the Palestinians and increasing belligerency
from the completely unfettered, aggressive and
erratic Israel, currently practising a form of
apartheid towards the Palestinians it rules through force.
This uneven balance of power can only be
successfully addressed in the same way every
national liberation movement has addressed it in
the past: through the unassailable strength of a
popular mandate. Ho Chi Minh sitting down with
the French, or Nelson Mandela negotiating with
the apartheid regime embodied this popular
legitimacy, and indeed drew their principles and
negotiating positions from it. The Palestinian
leadership's weak and incompetent posturing is
the opposite of dignified and honourable national
representation, and proves useless to boot.
On the positive side, had such deals eventually
come to light, Palestinians would have rejected
them comprehensively. But the worst betrayal has
been what this hypocrisy has bequeathed to the
young generation of Palestinians. These officials
have led a new generation to believe that
participating in public governance is base and
self-seeking, that joining any political party is
the least useful method to advance principals and create change.
Through their harmful example, they have
alienated young Palestinians from their own
history of resistance to colonial and military
rule, so they now believe that tens of thousands
of brilliant, imaginative and extraordinarily
brave Palestinians never existed or, worse,
fought and died for nothing. It cuts them off
from any useful mobilising methods and techniques
that they might draw upon today the democratic
and collective mechanisms that are needed more
than ever. They have given young people the idea
that there is no virtue in collective
organisation, the mechanism by which popular
democratic change is made and preserved.
The increasingly popular view that the
Palestinian revolution was a failure from its
inception, always corrupt, driven from above and
never from below, is false but it has gained
credibility through the actions of the current
regime. Its behaviour has nearly erased the
record of the contribution made by tens of
thousands of ordinary Palestinian citizens who,
through the sheer force of their devotion to
public life, fought for principles and created
real and democratic self-representation under the
worst of conditions. It is our most valuable
freedom, and one well worth fighting for: the
release of these devastating documents paves the way for its restoration.
Seemingly endless and ugly game of the peace
process is now finally over | Karma Nabulsi
This article was published on
<http://www.guardian.co.uk/>guardian.co.uk at
20.02 GMT on Sunday 23 January 2011. A version
appeared on p24 of the
<http://www.guardian.co.uk/theguardian/2011/jan/24/mainsection>Main
section section of
<http://www.guardian.co.uk/theguardian>the
Guardian on
<http://www.guardian.co.uk/theguardian/2011/jan/24>Monday
24 January 2011. It was last modified at 11.35
GMT on Monday 24 January 2011. It was first
published at 20.00 GMT on Sunday 23 January 2011.
Freedom Archives
522 Valencia Street
San Francisco, CA 94110
415 863-9977
www.Freedomarchives.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20110124/5e6dfb7d/attachment.htm>
More information about the News
mailing list