[Pnews] The Bell Tolls, or Should, for Ana Belén Montes

Prisoner News ppnews at freedomarchives.org
Mon Jul 17 10:43:02 EDT 2017


  The Bell Tolls, or Should, for Ana Belén Montes

July 17, 2017  by Susan Babbitt 

At the World Social Forum at Puerto Alegre, Brazil, the late Nobel Prize 
Winner, José Saramago told the following story: In a village near 
Florence, Italy, in 800 A.D., church bells were rung whenever someone 
died. One day the bells rang and everyone returned from the fields. They 
looked to see who had died, but all were present. They asked the 
bell-ringer, “Who has died?” He said: “Justice has died”. [i] <#_edn1>

What is expected of democracy and the Universal Declaration of Rights, 
Saramago pointed out, is “flowery, empty legalistic rhetoric” falling 
far short of the “rational, sensitive dignity we once assumed to be the 
supreme aspiration of hu/mankind”./ /Just as in ancient times, the 
village church bell marked death, the bell must toll, loudly and 
persistently, the death of justice./

“Justice” that takes no issue with the single “economic power… managed 
by multinational corporations in line with strategies of domination that 
have nothing to do with the common good to which, by definition, 
democracy aspires” is not justice. It cannot be. It doesn’t apply to 
people, or to most.

It can’t recognize them. Saramago’s bell is metaphorical: It is 
well-known to philosophers and psychologists that we don’t learn when we 
think we already know. If you tell me why I shouldn’t step off the roof, 
I don’t listen. I don’t need to. To learn, I need to know that I don’t 
know – I need questions.

Knowledge isn’t power: If we can’t imagine what it explains, or might, 
or we don’t care, it’s useless.

Here’s another point about reason: We think according to expectations, 
arising from practises, that is, from how we live. Saramago refers to 
“some sort of verbal and mental automatism” arising from liberal 
institutions, that is, from liberal practises, including ways of 
thinking. It means we don’t see certain “raw, naked facts.” We don’t 
expect them and therefore don’t see them, no matter the evidence.

Ana Belén Montes saw the facts. [ii] <#_edn2> She cared. To see what we 
don’t expect, we have to care. We have to imagine what might be 
explained by those facts.

She’s been imprisoned since 2001. If she were in China, Russia or 
Venezuela, we’d know her. Sixty years old, with cancer, she’s in a Texas 
prison for women with psychiatric disorders (although she suffers no 
such disorder), prohibited from visitors (except a few family members), 
phone calls, letters, and news.

Her crime is that she opposed, and still opposes, her government’s 
foreign policy.

Employed by the Defense Intelligence Agency, she knew facts, now 
declassified, about US aggression toward Cuba. She had the courage to 
believe them. She gave them to the Cuban government. She gained nothing. 
She hurt no one, stole nothing and committed no violence – except to lies.

She believed in justice, the “rational, sensitive dignity” kind. She 
thought Cuba should not be forced, through assassination, biological 
warfare, intimidation and destabilization, to submit to US interests.

In Havana recently, a taxi driver told me, “I have one question: Why are 
they so afraid of a small, poor country? What do they think will happen 
if they just let us develop?”

A lot will happen. It has to do, again, with how understanding occurs. 
We think within social limits. We see and give importance only to the 
facts that matter, given our interests. But sometimes we encounter an 
example that makes us care in ways we did not previously. We may even be 
moved, emotionally. /Then/ we consider evidence we would not/could not 
have considered otherwise. It was there all along.

A Cuban friend working in tourism said that since US citizens began 
arriving in Cuba in greater numbers, she has not met a single one who 
was not positively surprised. “It is not what I expected”, they say.

If only they would seek out the explanations. But this takes 
imagination, caring, and courage.

Eduardo Galeano tells the following story in /El Libro de los Abrazos/: 
A friend was taking his small boy to see the sea for the first time. As 
they approached, the sea was just an intense smell. When finally it was 
in front of them, in its immensity, the boy was quiet, speechless before 
unexpected beauty. Eventually, able to speak, he said simply, “Papá, 
help me to see”.

We are lied to about democracy. This is well-known. But we are also lied 
to about lies. The truth is that we don’t see facts just by looking. We 
don’t even see what is in front of us just by looking. We need help to 
see what is not expected.

Galeano says art helps us to see. It can help us to see what we don’t 
see. It raises questions. People can do that for us too. Ana Belén 
Montes is one. She has believed, and still believes, truths that are 
available. She has possessed, and evidently still possesses, the moral 
imagination to know such truths matter.

After 16 years in isolation, she said, “I live totally isolated. I am 
subject to extreme psychological pressure … but I will resist until the 

She went on: “I say to you what I’ve said to Cubans and to those sharing 
my solidarity with Cuba, that what matters is that the Cuban revolution 
exists … that there will always be the Cuban revolution. Cubans must 
care for their revolution. I tried to do that”.

Cuba is an example. But to see what it is an example of – dignity, 
humanity – we may need help. Ana Belén Montes should be known, and 
released, for the sake of justice. But she should also be known in a 
time of lies, even /about /lies, for the sake of truth. As Galeano 
suggests, we need help even to see beauty, if unimagined. So much more 
so for justice, unimagined and urgent.

/Please sign petition here. 

/For more information, write to the Canadian Network on Cuba 
(cnc at canadiannetworkoncuba.ca <mailto:cnc at canadiannetworkoncuba.ca>) or 
in Cuba, Cuba X Ana Belén Montes (cincoheroes at listas.cujae.edu.cu 
<mailto:cincoheroes at listas.cujae.edu.cu>)./


[i] <#_ednref1> Saramago, José, (2002, March 9), “From justice to 
democracy by way of the bells (Speech at the World Social Forum. Puerto 
Alegre, Brazil).

[ii] <#_ednref2> E.g. http://www.prolibertad.org/ana-belen-montes

/*Susan Babbitt* is author of Humanism and Embodiment (Bloomsbury 2014)./

Freedom Archives 522 Valencia Street San Francisco, CA 94110 415 
863.9977 www.freedomarchives.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/ppnews_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20170717/ad522a47/attachment.html>

More information about the PPnews mailing list