[Ppnews] Angola death case hinges on 63 ruling
Political Prisoner News
ppnews at freedomarchives.org
Mon Aug 4 18:08:56 EDT 2008
Inside Report for August 1, 2008
Angola death case hinges on '63 ruling
* By BILL LODGE
* Advocate staff writer
* Published: Aug 1, 2008 - Page: 7B - UPDATED: 12:05 a.m.
In 1972, corrections officer Brent Miller was stabbed to death at the
Louisiana State Penitentiary at Angola.
For the next 36 years, inmate Albert Woodfox was held in solitary
confinement, a period during which he twice was convicted for the
murder of the 23-year-old officer.
Woodfox, sent to Angola on an armed robbery conviction, was released
from solitary earlier this year and sent to the prison's maximum
security unit, where he remains.
In July, U.S. District Judge James J. Brady overturned his
conviction. The state Attorney General's Office said it will appeal
Surely, Woodfox loyalists celebrated Brady's decision, which was
based on a recommendation from U.S. Magistrate Christine Noland.
Surely, people convinced of Woodfox's guilt in the slaying grumbled
and griped because Brady agreed with Noland's conclusion that the
inmate's defense attorneys provided ineffective assistance in his
second murder trial.
Paul R. Baier, a professor at LSU's Paul M. Hebert Law Center, was in
Baier sees the judges' actions as a means to force the legal system
to work in accordance with the U.S. Supreme Court's 1963 decision in
Brady v. Maryland. In that case, another guy named Brady was
convicted of murder and sentenced to death.
But the Brady in that murder case had asked prosecutors prior to
trial for copies of any statements made by his co-defendant in the
case. And the prosecutors withheld the statement in which the
co-defendant admitted he had actually committed the murder.
The high court threw out Brady's death sentence. Justices said "The
suppression by the prosecution of evidence favorable to an accused
upon request violates due process where the evidence is material
either to guilt or to punishment." They added: "Society wins not only
when the guilty are convicted but when criminal trials are fair; our
system of the administration of justice suffers when any accused is
In the Woodfox case, Noland said Woodfox's defense attorneys should
have objected to the testimony of several prosecution witnesses in
1998, during his second trial. That included the transcribed
testimony of an inmate eyewitness from the original trial in 1973.
Hezekiah Brown, serving a life sentence for aggravated rape, first
told prison officials he was not at the scene of Miller's slaying.
But that initial statement was withheld from Woodfox, Noland said, as
was the fact that officials promised to help Brown win release from
his life term.
Brown, who was pardoned in 1986, testified at Woodfox's first trial
and said Woodfox took part in Miller's slaying. Brown died before
Woodfox's second trial in 1998. But Brown's 1973 testimony was read
to the second jury.
After Judge Brady overturned Woodfox's conviction, one of the
inmate's current attorneys, Nicholas J. Trenticosta, of New Orleans,
said Noland had concluded in her recommendation: "This guy is
That's not exactly what Noland said.
She noted that "without Brown's testimony, the prosecution had
essentially no evidence directly linking Woodfox to the crime."
And the original jury never heard about Brown's conflicting statements.
LSU's Baier said the 1963 Supreme Court decision in Brady v. Maryland
remains important because it "requires the state to tell the defense
counsel about exculpatory information (that can benefit a defendant)."
Baier said many problems could have been avoided in 1973 if Woodfox
had been told of Brown's initial statements and the promises made to
him by prison officials. Baier didn't hesitate to add: "I think Judge
Noland and Judge Brady are doing fine work."
Bill Lodge covers federal court for The Advocate. He can be reachedat
blodge at theadvocate.com.
522 Valencia Street
San Francisco, CA 94110
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the PPnews