[Ppnews] Three Years in Guantanamo for a Joke

Political Prisoner News PPnews at freedomarchives.org
Fri Nov 4 08:36:00 EST 2005

News & Views for Anarchists & Activists:

Writers jailed in 2002 for political satire
After three years at Guantanamo, Afghan writers found to be no threat to
United States
October 31, 2005

PESHAWAR, Pakistan -- Badr Zaman Badr and his brother Abdurrahim Muslim
Dost relish writing a good joke that jabs a corrupt politician or distills
the sufferings of fellow Afghans. Badr admires the political satires in
"The Canterbury Tales" and "Gulliver's Travels," and Dost wrote some wicked
lampoons in the 1990s, accusing Afghan mullahs of growing rich while
preaching and organizing jihad. So in 2002, when the U.S. military shackled
the writers and flew them to Guantanamo among prisoners whom Defense
Secretary Donald Rumsfeld declared "the worst of the worst" violent
terrorists, the brothers found life imitating farce.

For months, grim interrogators grilled them over a satirical article Dost
had written in 1998, when the Clinton administration offered a $5-million
reward for Osama bin Laden. Dost responded that Afghans put up 5 million
Afghanis -- equivalent to $113 -- for the arrest of President Bill Clinton.

"It was a lampoon . . . of the poor Afghan economy" under the Taliban, Badr
recalled. The article carefully instructed Afghans how to identify Clinton
if they stumbled upon him. "It said he was clean-shaven, had light-colored
eyes and he had been seen involved in a scandal with Monica Lewinsky," Badr

The interrogators, some flown down from Washington, didn't get the joke, he
said. "Again and again, they were asking questions about this article. We
had to explain that this was a satire." He paused. "It was really pathetic."

It took the brothers three years to convince the Americans that they posed
no threat to Clinton or the United States, and to get released -- a
struggle that underscores the enormous odds weighing against innocent
foreign Muslims caught in America's military prisons.

In recent months, scores of Afghans interviewed by Newsday -- including a
dozen former U.S. prisoners, plus human rights officials and senior Afghan
security officials -- said the United States is detaining enough innocent
Afghans in its war against the Taliban and al-Qaida that it is seriously
undermining popular support for its presence in Afghanistan.

As Badr and Dost fought for their freedom, they had enormous advantages
over Guantanamo's 500-plus other captives.

The brothers are university-educated, and Badr, who holds a master's degree
in English literature, was one of few prisoners able to speak fluently to
the interrogators in their own language. And since both men are writers,
much of their lives and political ideas are on public record here in books
and articles they have published.

A Pentagon spokesman, Lt. Cmdr. Flex Plexico, declared this summer that
"there was no mistake" in the brothers' detention because it "was directly
related to their combat activities [or support] as determined by an
appropriate Department of Defense official." U.S. officials declined to
discuss the case, so no full picture is available of why it took so long
for the pair to be cleared.

The Pentagon's prison network overseas is assigned to help prevent attacks
on the United States like those of Sept. 11, 2001, so "you cannot equate it
to a justice system," said Army Col. Samuel Rob, who was serving this
summer as the chief lawyer for U.S. forces in Afghanistan. Still, he added,
innocent victims of the system are "a small percentage, I'd say."

The military is slow to clear innocent prisoners, largely because of its
fear of letting even one real terrorist get away, said Rob.

"What if this is a truly bad individual, the next World Trade Center
bomber, and you let him go? What do you say to the families?" asked Rob.

Rob and the Defense Department say the prison system performs
satisfactorily in freeing innocents and letting military investigators
focus on prisoners who really are part of terrorist networks. Badr and
others -- including some former military intelligence soldiers who served
in Guantanamo and Afghanistan -- emphatically disagree.

The United States for years called Badr and his brother "enemy combatants,"
but the men say they never saw a battlefield. And for an America that seeks
a democratized Afghanistan, they seem, potentially, allies. Americans "have
freedom to criticize your government, and this is very good," said Badr.
Also, "we know that America's laws say a person is innocent until he is
proven to be guilty," although "for us it is the reverse."

Badr and Dost are Pashtuns, members of the ethnic group that spawned the
Taliban. But the family library where they receive their guests is crammed
with poetry, histories and religious treatises -- mind-broadening stuff
that the Taliban were more inclined to burn than read. For years, the
brothers' library has served as a salon for Pashtun intellectuals and
activists of many hues, including some who also have been arrested in the
U.S.-funded dragnet for suspected Islamic militants.

Like millions of Afghans, they fled to Pakistan during the Soviet
occupation of their country in the 1980s and joined one of the many
anti-Soviet factions that got quiet support from Pakistan's military
intelligence service. Their small group was called Jamiat-i-Dawatul Quran
wa Sunna, and Dost became editor of its magazine. Even then, "we were not
fighters," said Badr. "We took part in the war only as writers."

After the Soviet withdrawal in 1989, the men split with Jamiat, partly over
its promotion of the extremist Wahhabi sect of Islam. Dost wrote lampoons
against the group's leader, a cleric named Sami Ullah, portraying him as a
corrupt pawn of its sponsor, Pakistan, working against Afghan interests.

In November 2001, as U.S. forces attacked Afghanistan, the mullah's
brother, Roh Ullah, "called us and said if we didn't stop criticizing the
party he would have us put in jail," said Badr. Ten days later, men from
Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence Directorate hauled the brothers off
to grimy cells.

Another Ullah brother, Hayat Ullah, insisted in an interview that their
family had not instigated the arrests. Dost is a political rival, but "a
very simple man," Hayat Ullah said. "We have many powerful rivals. If I
were going to get ISI to pick up an enemy, why would I choose an ordinary
person like him?"

Pakistan-U.S. transfer

But two Pakistani analysts with sources in ISI said the Ullah family has
been accused in several cases of using its links to the agency to have
rivals arrested. And Roh Ullah himself is now imprisoned at Guantanamo.

In the midnight chill of Feb. 9, 2002, ISI officers led Badr and Dost,
blindfolded and handcuffed, onto the tarmac of Peshawar International
Airport. When they heard airplanes, "we knew they were handing us to the
Americans," Badr said.

Beneath the blindfold, he stole glimpses of smiling Pakistani officers,
grim U.S. soldiers and a cargo plane. "It was a big festival atmosphere, as
though the Pakistanis were handing over Osama bin Laden to the United
States," Badr said.

Shouting and shoving, American troops forced the brothers to the asphalt
and bound their hands behind them with plastic ties. "They chained our
feet," Badr said. "Dogs were barking at us. They pulled a sack down over my
head. It was very difficult to breathe . . . and I saw the flash of
cameras. They were taking pictures of us."

Flown to U.S. prisons at Bagram and Kandahar air bases in Afghanistan, the
brothers eventually learned from their interrogators that the ISI had
denounced them to the U.S. as dangerous supporters of the Taliban and
al-Qaida who had threatened President Clinton.

In the three-plus years that the brothers spent in U.S. prisons abroad,
violent abuse and torture were widely reported.

Eight of 12 men interviewed after their release in recent months from U.S.
prisons in Afghanistan told Newsday they had been beaten or had seen or
heard other prisoners being beaten.

The brothers escaped the worst abuse, partly because of Badr's fluent
English. At times, prisoners "who didn't speak English got kicked by the
MPs because they didn't understand what the soldiers wanted," he said. And
both men said that while many prisoners clammed up under questioning, they
were talkative and able to demonstrate cooperation.

"Fortunately, we were not tortured," Badr said, "but we heard torture." At
Bagram, "We heard guards shouting at people to make them stand up all night
without sleeping." At Kandahar, prisoners caught talking in their cells
"were punished by being forced to kneel on the ground with their hands on
their head and not moving for three or four hours in hot weather.

Some became unconscious," he said. The U.S. military last year investigated
abuse at its prisons in Afghanistan but the Pentagon ordered the report

Routine interrogations

Badr and Dost were humiliated routinely. When being moved between prisons
or in groups, they often were thrown to the ground, like that night at
Peshawar airport. "They put our faces in the dust," Badr said.

Like virtually all ex-prisoners interviewed, he said he felt deliberately
shamed by soldiers when they photographed him naked or gave him regular
rectal exams.

The brothers were flown to Guantanamo in May 2002 as soon as Camp Delta,
the permanent prison there, was opened. For more than two years, they sat
in separate cells, waiting days between interrogation sessions to explain
and re-explain their lives and writings.

In his 35 months in U.S. captivity, Badr said, he had about 150
interrogation sessions with 25 different lead interrogators from several
U.S. agencies. "And that satire was the biggest cause of their suspicion,"
he said.

When one team of interrogators "began to accept that this was satire," the
whole process would begin anew with interrogators from another agency. In
all, Badr said he was told that four U.S. agencies -- including the CIA,
FBI and Defense Department -- would have to give their assent before the
men could be released. And their names would be circulated to 40 other
countries to ensure they were not wanted anywhere else.

The Americans' investigations seemed to take forever to confirm even where
they had lived and studied. "I would tell him [the interrogator] something
simple and ... two or two-and-a-half months later, he would come back and
say, 'We checked, and you were right about that,'" Badr said.

Another problem was that "Many of the interpreters were not good," said
Badr. He recalled an elderly man, arrested by U.S. forces for shooting his
rifle at a helicopter, who explained that he had been trapping hawks and
fired in anger at one that flew away. But the interpreter mistook the
Persian word "booz" (hawk) for "baz" (goat). "The interrogator became very
angry," Badr said. "He thought the old man was making a fool of him by
claiming to be shooting at goats flying in the air."

Angered by ordeal

Rob conceded that "obviously, we could use more translators," but said the
pace at which prisoners are processed -- and innocents released -- is adequate.

That idea angers Badr. "They detained us for three and a half years," he
said. "Then they said to us, 'all right, you're innocent, so go away.'"

Of that anger, Rob said, "that's understandable. Especially if he's the
breadwinner for his family and there's no one . . ." The sentence hung

The brothers' anger is deepened by the abusiveness of many U.S. soldiers,
whom Badr compared to "Yahoos," the thuggish characters of Jonathan Swift's
"Gulliver's Travels." And they are upset that U.S. officials confiscated
all of their prison writings.

Still, Badr sounds neither bitter nor an enemy of America. "I am curious to
meet ordinary Americans," he said. "I appreciated my interrogators in
Guantanamo. . . . Many of them were misguided, for example about my
religion. . . . But I can say that they were civilized people."


Books back former prisoners' claims
October 31, 2005

PESHAWAR, Pakistan -- Former U.S. soldiers at the Pentagon's military
prisons overseas have given evidence that a great many of the captives in
"the global war on terror" are innocent.

In the past year, a former Army interpreter at Guantanamo and an
interrogator at U.S. prisons in Afghanistan have published books on their
experiences that in many ways buttress the accounts of ex-prisoners such as
Afghan writers Badr Zaman Badr and Abdurrahim Muslim Dost.

In 2002, America's prisons in Afghanistan were crammed with ordinary people
like Badr and Dost who were sometimes literally sold to U.S. forces for the
bounties that Washington was offering, according to Chris Mackey, the
former interrogator. In his book, "The Interrogators," Mackey (a pseudonym)
said his Army intelligence unit struggled to evaluate "a steady stream of
detainees from Pakistan and other governments or Afghan warlords pocketing
a nice wad of cash for every prisoner they turned over."

Even when U.S. Special Forces in Afghanistan made the arrests, they
"couldn't distinguish the good [people] from the bad . . . so they dropped
them all on our doorstep to let us sort them out," he said. "They were
bringing back a lot of fighters, but they also were bringing back a lot of

At Guantanamo in 2003, the bulk of prisoners were either innocent or
irrelevant to the U.S. investigation into terrorist activities, according
to Sgt. Erik Saar, who supervised interpreters in interrogations there. "We
did have some bad guys, and some talkers" who were giving useful
intelligence information, Saar wrote in his book, "Inside the Wire." "But
from what I saw, there weren't many more than a few dozen such characters
at Guantanamo."

Even a prisoner who has convinced his interrogators that he is no threat to
the United States may not be freed. That decision is made at the Pentagon.
But "once the file's in Washington, the decisions are all political," Saar
quoted a military interrogator as saying. Bureaucrats ask, "Would releasing
too many [prisoners] make the Gitmo operation look bad?" Saar wrote.

The Freedom Archives
522 Valencia Street
San Francisco, CA 94110
(415) 863-9977
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/ppnews_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20051104/b392c8a8/attachment.html>

More information about the PPnews mailing list