<div dir="ltr">
<div class="gmail-toolbar-container">
</div><div class="gmail-container" dir="ltr">
<div>
<font size="1"><a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/dossier-30-coronashock-in-latin-america/?fbclid=IwAR0-8QRpO3512k58rwr6nET9UeXfkMTKujTmytg63Q-4mse8IYK756Xf-zg">https://www.thetricontinental.org/dossier-30-coronashock-in-latin-america/?fbclid=IwAR0-8QRpO3512k58rwr6nET9UeXfkMTKujTmytg63Q-4mse8IYK756Xf-zg</a>
</font><h1 class="gmail-reader-title">Latin America Under CoronaShock: Social Crisis, Neoliberal Failure, and the People’s Alternatives</h1>
<div class="gmail-credits gmail-reader-credits">July 7, 2020</div><br><p>
<span><a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/es/dossier-30-coronashock-en-america-latina/"><span>Español</span></a></span> <span><a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/pt-pt/dossie-30-coronachoque-e-america-latina/"><span>Português</span></a></span></p><h4><strong>Dossier Nº30</strong></h4>
<div id="gmail-attachment_22731" class="gmail-wp-caption"><p><img src="https://www.thetricontinental.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/01_COVER_Fotografo-Carlos-Fiengo-La-Paz-Bolivia-4.jpg" alt="Herb and spice vendor working (despite the pandemic). Santa Cruz Street, La Paz, Bolivia, 2020. Carlos Fiengo" style="margin-right: 0px;" width="461" height="307"></p><p id="gmail-caption-attachment-22731" class="gmail-wp-caption-text"><strong><span>Herb and spice vendor working (despite the pandemic). Santa Cruz Street, La Paz, Bolivia, 2020.</span></strong><br><span>Carlos Fiengo</span></p></div>
<p>The first cases of COVID-19 were detected in December 2019 in Wuhan
(China). In early March, the World Health Organization (WHO) declared
the rapidly expanding illness a pandemic. With more than ten million
people infected across the world as of late June, the effects of the
pandemic on the world system reach far beyond the realm of public
health; indeed, a reconfiguration of social life is underway. The crisis
spread by neoliberal capitalism is intensifying, as is the increasing
necessity for an urgent transformation of the system along an
alternative path (for more on this, read our dossier no. 28, <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/dossier-28-coronavirus/"><i>CoronaShock: A Virus and the World</i></a><i>,</i> and our CoronaShock <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/studies/">studies</a>).
In Latin America, the first cases of the disease were detected at the
end of February. Four months later, at the end of June, the number of
people infected in Latin America has reached for more than twenty-three
per cent of the global total and twenty-two of daily deaths as the rapid
spread of the virus has turned the region (particularly South America)
into the new global epicentre of the pandemic.</p>
<p>The pandemic has furthered – sometimes dramatically – a series of
economic and social processes that were already underway before the
virus emerged. Capitalism’s crisis of legitimacy and increasingly
authoritarian neoliberal reforms have put these policies and the US-led
imperialist offensive into question (for more on this, read our report
no. 6, <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/es/ba-research/amlatmar20/"><i>From 8M to the Coronavirus Crisis</i></a><i>)</i>.
The expansion of the virus has also shined a light on the dismantling
and privatisation of public healthcare – the result of decades of
neoliberalism – as well as on the increasing precariousness of labour
and the living conditions and quality of life of the people. The
pandemic has put on display the resounding failure of neoliberal
policies to effectively combat the health and social crises. Finally,
the current situation puts into question the effects, actions, and
challenges that these processes pose for people’s movements and the
alternatives that they are creating.</p>
<div id="gmail-attachment_22741" class="gmail-wp-caption"><p><img src="https://www.thetricontinental.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/02_Venezuela-Manifestac%CC%A7a%CC%83o-em-Caracas-depois-que-o-presidente-Donald-Trump-pedir-a-prisa%CC%83o-do-presidente-Nicola%CC%81s-Maduro-28-Marzo-PSUV-Fotos-Pu%CC%81blicas1-1.jpg" alt="Protest in Caracas, Venezuela after US President Donald Trump called for the imprisonment of President Nicolás Maduro, 28 March 2020 United Socialist Party of Venezuela / Fotos Públicas" style="margin-right: 0px;" width="346" height="461"></p><p id="gmail-caption-attachment-22741" class="gmail-wp-caption-text"><strong><span>Protest
in Caracas, Venezuela after US President Donald Trump called for the
imprisonment of President Nicolás Maduro, 28 March 2020</span></strong><br><span>United Socialist Party of Venezuela / Fotos Públicas</span></p></div>
<h2><span><b>This Crisis is Not Natural</b></span></h2>
<p>Numbers of those infected and killed by the virus began to sharply
increase in May 2020. These numbers, threatening to serve as the straw
that causes the collapse of health systems throughout the region,
clearly show the disproportionately impact of the crisis on the poor and
the working class. This is especially true in Brazil, Chile, Peru,
Panama, the Dominican Republic, Ecuador, and Bolivia, where the number
of those infected has (drastically, in some cases) surpassed 2,000 cases
per million residents. At the end of May, Brazil tragically became one
of the first places in the world to reach such a high level of
infections; by the end of June, it became the country with the
second-highest number of deaths and infections, after the United States.
Meanwhile, migration from the Dominican Republic to Haiti has
accelerated the rapid spread of infections and is edging towards a
humanitarian tragedy.</p>
<p>This is not about a natural curse; the pandemic was not biologically
predetermined. Its emergence – as is the case with all of the pandemics
that we have experienced throughout the twenty-first century –<b> </b>is
linked to the processes of the industrial production of food and the
destruction of native forests and jungles, which is characteristic of
neoliberal capitalism. In addition, the transformation of the pandemic
into a health and humanitarian crisis is linked to public policies and
the approach of governments as well as other social, institutional, and
historic resources that the people count on.</p>
<p>In the case of Latin America, COVID-19 emerged at a time when people
were already questioning the wave of neoliberal policies that has been
developing in the region since 2015, from structural adjustment to
privatisation and other regressive reforms. Following the defeat of a
wave of progressive governments in much of the region throughout the
2000s, in the last few years public health budgets were cut across most
of these countries. These policies have resulted in the growth of
poverty, precarisation, and inequality, as well as the dismantling of
public health systems. In Argentina, for example, the Ministry of Health
was combined with the Ministry of Social Health and <a href="https://www.telesurenglish.net/news/Argentines-Protest-Changes-Cuts-to-Health-Ministry-in-Govt-Austerity-Package-20180906-0012.html">downgraded</a>
to a secretariat in 2018. This shift was part of the process of
structural adjustment imposed by the International Monetary Fund through
its agreement with former president Mauricio Macri. Such waves of
neoliberal policies have confronted Latin America since the 1970s, never
failing to trigger deleterious social consequences.</p>
<p>The current crisis, therefore, is not an isolated or anomalous event.
Rather, it rests on top of decades of disastrous neoliberal policies
and shines a light on neoliberalism’s failure and inability to combat
the underlying health crisis that it caused through its very own
framework. It was the conditions of neoliberalism that triggered the
crisis; not an inevitable series of external events. It is not a
coincidence that the countries that are suffering the most from the
impact of the virus are the countries whose governments are most closely
aligned with the neoliberal project – the same countries that have
ignored the recommendations of the WHO. The most dramatic case of this
has been in Brazil, where the government, led by President Jair
Bolsonaro, has underestimated the pandemic and created a permanent
campaign in favour of maintaining unrestricted economic activity.</p>
<p>On the other hand, the state of public health is in less dire straits
where progressive governments have respected the recommendations of the
WHO. Argentina, for example, is undergoing an extended quarantine and
bolstering its public health system, including developing tests through
its national public science system. Cuba, which has a public health
system that is well-known for its quality, has adopted policies of
selective physical distancing and testing and is implementing a model of
community medicine. Venezuela has among the lowest rates of infection
and deaths per number of residents – despite the extreme commercial,
financial, and media blockade and the permanent threat of the hybrid war
led by the United States. In the midst of the pandemic, this hybrid war
threatens to compound the impacts of the health crisis with economic
difficulties that could be used to justify external intervention.</p>
<p>Meanwhile, the pandemic has accelerated a deep global economic
recession. The current crisis has compounded the slow economic growth
that the region has experienced over the last seven years and which
increased even further under the harsh neoliberal offensive. Regional
and international organisations <a href="https://www.cepal.org/en/publications/45477-measuring-impact-covid-19-view-reactivation">anticipate</a>
the worst economic contraction at a regional level since 1930. In
April, the United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America and the
Caribbean (ECLAC) anticipated a 5.4 per cent decrease in the GDP in
2020; by June, an <a href="https://www.imf.org/es/Publications/WEO/Issues/2020/06/24/WEOUpdateJune2020">estimate</a>
from the International Monetary Fund predicted that it would fall by
9.4 per cent. The economic crash particularly impacts countries,
regions, and sectors that rely on the export of oil, gas, and minerals
(where the fall in international prices of natural resources has been
felt the most acutely); tourism and remittances from migrants; the flow
of global finance (the Brazilian economy has been among the most deeply
impacted by capital outflows); and participation in global commerce and
global production chains. In addition to the recession and capital
outflows, the people have been adversely <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/es/ba-research/katz-confluencia/">affected</a> by the devaluation of their currencies, and, in some countries, by bloated external debt.</p>
<p>This ominous economic reality has disastrous consequences for the
majority of the population. International organisations warn of a
substantial increase in unemployment; according to the Economic
Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC), in 2020,
unemployment will increase by at least 3.4 per percent – on top of the
8.1 per cent unemployment rate recorded in 2019 – placing the
unemployment rate at 11.5 per cent in the region. This means that
roughly 37.7 million people or more will be unemployed. Poverty levels
are also expected to <a href="https://www.cepal.org/en/publications/45544-social-challenge-times-covid-19">increase</a>
by an average of 4.4 per cent according to ECLAC, impacting 34.7 per
cent of the population. This increase in poverty will mean a step
backwards towards the reality that prevailed in the early part of the
twenty-first century before the wave of progressive governments. Along
the same lines, the United Nation’s World Food Programme has <a href="https://insight.wfp.org/covid-19-puts-14-million-people-at-risk-of-missing-meals-in-latin-america-and-the-caribbean-a54e42789153">warned</a> that roughly 14 million people across Latin America and the Caribbean may suffer from <a>hunger</a>
and food insecurity this year. This current economic landscape, managed
within a neoliberal policy framework, informs whether or not – and how
many – resources are allocated to confront the pandemic. More often than
not, protecting ‘the economy’ comes before protecting the people.</p>
<p>Throughout 2019, the almost non-existent economic growth at the
regional level, combined with neoliberal reforms, has opened Latin
America to conflicts and to the collapse of the credibility of its
governments. While the public health emergency reinforced presidential
authority in many cases, as time progressed, the gravity of the current
crisis and the profound impact of decades of neoliberal policies have
made neoliberalism’s growing crisis of legitimacy crystal <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/es/ba-research/amlatjun20/">clear</a>.</p>
<div id="gmail-attachment_22751" class="gmail-wp-caption"><p><img src="https://www.thetricontinental.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/03_Bol-Fotografo.-Carlos-Fiengo.-La-Paz-Bolivia-1-3.jpg" alt="Shoppers at the market pay to be disinfected. Rodríguez Market, La Paz, Bolivia, 2020. Carlos Fiengo" style="margin-right: 0px;" width="461" height="307"></p><p id="gmail-caption-attachment-22751" class="gmail-wp-caption-text"><strong><span>Shoppers at the market pay to be disinfected. Rodríguez Market, La Paz, Bolivia, 2020.</span></strong><br><span>Carlos Fiengo</span></p></div>
<h2><span><b>Neoliberalism’s Use of the Pandemic, Part I: Authoritarian Reinforcement </b></span></h2>
<p>The IMF has referred to the global economic crisis unleashed by the
pandemic as the ‘Great Lockdown’, drawing an analogy to the Great
Depression that began in 1929. This reference not only highlights the
similarities between the magnitude of both situations and their impact,
but also attributes the crisis to the restrictive public health
measures, particularly the implementation of physical distancing
policies commonly referred to as ‘quarantine’. There is nothing new in
the history of capitalism – from its very beginning to today – about
economic powers opposing quarantine. The expansion of plagues has long
been closely <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/es/ba-research/murillo-quarentenas/">linked</a> with commercial circuits, its transportation networks, and processes of capitalist globalisation.</p>
<p>In contrast, the strategies of isolation and physical distancing
recommended by the WHO, as well as by the general dynamic of the crisis
that the pandemic has provoked, have granted a new role to the state in
the areas of health, social, and economic policies. Serious questions
are being asked about the new role of the state under conditions of deep
inequalities produced by neoliberal policies. However, the new role of
the state does not necessarily imply a contradiction with the neoliberal
order; during the financial crisis of 2008, for example, the state
intervened to bail out banks and corporations.</p>
<p>The logic of quarantine and state intervention justified by the
crisis has been used – especially by neoliberal governments in the
region – to reinforce a politics that is increasingly repressive and
authoritarian. This shift was already underway in many of the countries
under siege by the neoliberal offensive – especially in the face of the
increasing scrutiny that this model and its advocates have faced from
the public, which has intensified over the last year.</p>
<p>This has also occurred in most countries throughout Central America.
There, the sparse presence of social and health policies stands in
contrast to the imposition of curfews and a state of emergency, the
reinforcement of militarisation, and increasing punishment of those who
disobey isolation measures, which in many cases has led to new
violations of human rights, especially in Guatemala, Honduras, and El
Salvador. Along the same lines, the assassination of leaders of social
movements and former guerrilleros in Colombia has increased since the
emergence of the pandemic. In Peru, the <a href="https://www.telesurenglish.net/news/peru-congress-approves-police-protection-law-20200331-0006.html">Police Protection Act</a>
(bill N° 31012), approved in 2019, has been put into effect, granting
impunity to security forces for repressive actions and brutality. In
Chile, the pandemic has pushed back the referendum to reform the
country’s constitution, giving a breath of air – at least for now – to a
government that has been under scrutiny by sustained protests. Now the
government is raising the possibility of going back on the call for the
referendum, instead strengthening the security apparatus with the
purchase of new equipment, putting the military back on the streets,
instituting a curfew, and continuing to use repression to disperse the
protests that are resurging in this new context.</p>
<p>Surely, the most dramatic example of this deepening of authoritarian
logic is the situation in Bolivia, where a coup in November 2019 removed
the government of the legitimate president, Evo Morales, refused to
recognise the electoral results, and imposed a self-proclaimed
‘transitional’ government led by Jeanine Áñez, a conservative senator
from the Department of the Beni. The de facto government led by Áñez –
marked initially by massacres in Sacaba and Senkata and by the return of
neoliberal policies – has postponed the elections that had been set for
3 May in the context of the pandemic; it has used the logic of the
quarantine to persecute its critics, attack the primarily indigenous
majority, and deepen its policies of dispossession and corruption.</p>
<p>Among other measures, in May Áñez enacted Supreme Decree 4231, which makes it criminally <a href="https://cepr.net/how-has-bolivias-de-facto-regime-taken-advantage-of-covid-19-to-consolidate-its-power-and-repress-political-rivals/">punishable</a>
to publish written, printed, or artistic information that generates
‘uncertainty among the population’. This is a serious violation of the
freedom of expression and the right to information. In addition, the
government has responded with repression to protests that are demanding
food, healthcare services, work, and the execution of the postponed
elections.</p>
<p>Yet another example of the continuous threats to the last glimmers of
democracy took place in May, when a group of military personnel led by
Carlos Orellana, the Commander in Chief of the Bolivian Armed Forces,
barged into the Plurinational Legislative Assembly with an ultimatum <a href="https://www.telesurenglish.net/news/bolivia-senate-rejects-armed-forces-ultimatum-and-threats-20200522-0004.html">demanding</a>
the ratification – with no changes – of the Armed Forces’ proposal for
promotions. The proposal had been sent by self-proclaimed president Áñez
in February. This is a new level of authoritarianism for a government
that is increasingly dabbling in corruption scandals. Now the government
has attempted to postpone the elections once again, now proposed to
take place in September – perhaps because Luis Arce, the candidate of
the Movement for Socialism (Evo Morales’s party) – is leading in the
pre-election polls.<b> </b></p>
<p>There is an increase in the power of the military in much of the
region. In Bolivia, the military has gained power since the coup. In
Brazil, the military has a substantial presence in Bolsonaro’s
government. In countries throughout the region, the military forces have
been empowered to control security mechanisms and public spaces and
have used the pretext of quarantine to exercise control over the
population. The application of authoritarianism and neoliberal policies
have become increasingly militaristic, using a range of tactics such as
lawfare (or judicial warfare) and the restriction of democratic life. In
other words, a neofascist beltway is emerging in the region.</p>
<div id="gmail-attachment_22761" class="gmail-wp-caption"><p><img src="https://www.thetricontinental.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/04_El-Salvador.-Distanciamento-social-e-ordem-na-entrega-de-Pacotes-Agri%CC%81colas.-29-de-Abril.-Foto-Casa-Presidencial.-Fotos-Pu%CC%81blicas-8.jpg" alt="Social distancing and order during the delivery of food baskets, El Salvador, 29 April 2020. Casa Presidencial / Fotos Públicas" style="margin-right: 0px;" width="461" height="307"></p><p id="gmail-caption-attachment-22761" class="gmail-wp-caption-text"><strong><span>Social distancing and order during the delivery of food baskets, El Salvador, 29 April 2020.</span></strong><br><span>Casa Presidencial / Fotos Públicas</span></p></div>
<h2><span><b>Neoliberalism’s Use of the Pandemic, Part II: Policies of Structural Adjustment </b></span></h2>
<p>In mid-April, a group of right-wing politicians from Spain and Latin
America – alongside the writer Mario Vargas Llosa, who has turned into a
spokesperson for neoliberalism in recent years – released a <a href="https://thespainjournal.com/the-international-foundation-for-freedom-headed-by-mario-vargas-llosa-has-written-this-manifesto-and-is-signed-by-more-than-150-personalities-from-23-countries-who-advocate-democracy-and-against-sta/">declaration</a>
titled ‘The Pandemic Should Not Be a Pretext for Authoritarianism’. In
this declaration, they react to the emergence of state interventionism,
socialism, and populism by accusing ‘many governments’ of taking
‘measures that indefinitely restrict basic freedoms and rights’. For
them, following the tradition of Hayek and Friedman, liberty is
considered only in an individualistic sense, linked to the protection of
economic freedom. They characterise any policy that restricts the free
market as being authoritarian, even if this policy is instituted by
democratic institutions and governments, and/or by the masses. This same
philosophy has been used to support and justify the dictatorship of
Augusto Pinochet in Chile (1973-1990). Along the same lines, Brazil’s
minister of foreign affairs, Ernesto Araújo, criticised the policies of
the WHO and denounced what he calls the ‘communavirus’.</p>
<p>Alongside these discourses and policies, many of the region’s
neoliberal governments have taken advantage of the pandemic to advance
neoliberal socioeconomic reforms – many of which were already part of
the programme underway before the emergence of the virus – or to promote
aid packages that benefit the economic powers. For example, in
Paraguay, the government of Mario Abdo <a href="https://nacla.org/news/2020/04/23/covid-19-change-paraguay">announced</a>
a ‘structural reform of the state’ whose objective is to shrink the
state apparatus, reduce public spending, privatise public sector
enterprises, and decrease salaries and pensions. In Colombia, the
government of Iván Duque approved Decree 444, which takes away economic
resources from local governments in the country in order to subsidise
banks and companies. Duque also managed to approve the Law of Economic
Emergency, which gives the government superpowers to advance neoliberal
labour reform and pension reform. However, he has not yet been able to
implement either. Along the same lines, the dictatorship in Bolivia
continues to dismantle the gains won by the government of Evo Morales
and has deregulated the economy, incurred a new cycle of external debt,
and approved transgenic agricultural reform.</p>
<p>Yet another tragic example of a neoliberal structural adjustment
policy that has been implemented in the era of the pandemic is the case
of Ecuador under President Lenín Moreno. Since the beginning of the
pandemic, Moreno’s administration has continued the policies of
structural adjustment that were imposed as part of its <a href="https://cepr.net/images/stories/reports/ecuador-imf-2019.pdf">agreement</a>
with the IMF (approved in early 2019) despite the massive discontent
and protests that it has faced. Between March and April 2020, in the
midst of the pandemic, Moreno’s administration made significant debt
payments in order to receive new IMF loans. To be able to access these
new loans, Moreno’s administration is required to adhere to even harsher
neoliberal policies. Finally, in May 2020, Moreno’s government obtained
parliamentary approval for two bills: the Organic Law for Humanitarian
Support to Combat the Crisis Derived from COVID-19 and the Organic Law
for the Ordering of Public Finances. These bills advance the state’s
structural adjustment policies, close or privatise public businesses and
offices, facilitate the payment of lower salaries, and worsen the
precarious conditions under which the working class lives and works. The
structural adjustment package imposed by the IMF, and that Moreno’s
administration agreed to, also includes substantial cuts to university
budgets, which provoked student protests; the budget cuts to
universities have been temporarily suspended by the supreme court as a
result. This austerity package has been criticized by large sections of
the population and by the political opposition, creating a situation
that could trigger a new crisis.</p>
<div id="gmail-attachment_22771" class="gmail-wp-caption"><p><img src="https://www.thetricontinental.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/05_Br-As-principais-ac%CC%A7o%CC%83es-de-solidariedade-desenvolvidas-pelo-MST-esta%CC%83o-voltadas-para-a-doac%CC%A7a%CC%83o-de-alimentos-em-diversos-formatos-como-cestas-ba%CC%81sicas-feiras-e-marmitas_Foto-MST-2.jpg" alt="The Landless Workers’ Movement’s (MST) main acts of solidarity are geared towards the distribution of food through various formats: food baskets, farmers’ markets, and lunch boxes. Paraná, Brazil, April 2020." style="margin-right: 0px;" width="461" height="308"></p><p id="gmail-caption-attachment-22771" class="gmail-wp-caption-text"><span><strong>The
Landless Workers’ Movement’s (MST) main acts of solidarity are geared
towards the distribution of food through various formats: food baskets,
farmers’ markets, and lunch boxes. Paraná, Brazil, April 2020.</strong> </span><br><span>MST</span></p></div>
<h2><span><b>Instability and Political Crisis in Brazil </b></span></h2>
<p>Brazil has become the regional epicentre of COVID-19 and one of the
centres of the pandemic on a global level. The failure of the federal
government to adopt sufficient measures to combat the pandemic has
created a catastrophic situation that is edging towards a humanitarian
tragedy. This inaction by the federal government is accompanied by
President Jair Bolsonaro’s approach of underestimating, or even denying
the problem, and placing concern for the economy before concern for the
people. The gross underreporting of cases, mainly due to the scarcity of
tests being carried out, does not allow us to have a true grasp of the
health crisis underway. The Imperial College of London estimates that
the <a href="https://www.brasildefato.com.br/2020/06/24/taxa-de-contagio-volta-a-crescer-e-brasil-registra-42-7-mil-novos-casos-de-covid-19">total number</a>
of active cases of COVID-19 as of the end of June is at least three
times higher than the official count (1.23 million active cases),
bringing the estimate of active cases in the country to at least 3.7
million.</p>
<p>This health crisis is the greatest expression – and one of the causes
– of the political and social instability that faces Bolsonaro’s
government. This government has increased its political isolation,
amplifying a tendency that was already in place. Bolsonaro has picked
fights with legislative and judicial powers and has intensified
conflicts with governors and mayors, breaking with his past allies and
pressuring them to open up the economy (as is the case with the
governors of the states of Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo, for example).
On top of this, Minister of Health Luiz Henrique Mandetta resigned – as
did his replacement – due to differences over the health policy pushed
forward by Bolsonaro. Minister of Justice Sérgio Moro resigned and
denounced the president while attempting to manipulate the federal
police to guarantee impunity for his relatives from a variety of
investigations that are underway. All of this has further isolated
Bolsonaro’s government. As a judge, Moro was a main force in pushing
forward the court case known as Lava Jato, which led to former president
Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s imprisonment and his exclusion from the
2018 elections. Moro’s resignation in particular both exemplified and
accelerated the declining support for Bolsonaro’s government by an
important section of the population – particularly the middle class
– that had supported him from the beginning.</p>
<p>While Bolsonaro still has the support of a resistant core that
rallies for him in the streets, carrying out caravans, actions, and
encampments, the president has sought higher approval among low-income
sectors. This effort has been based on two main discourses: the defence
of the use of Chloroquine to treat COVID-19 and a supposed concern about
employment. In the first case – contrary to scientific evidence
– Bolsonaro seeks to instil the idea that there is a quick solution to
the disease. In the second case, he uses a discourse that economic
activities should return to ‘normal’, which could garner support from
those who are in desperate situations and have seen their incomes
diminish or disappear. In addition, Bolsonaro has tried to take credit
for the economic aid created and approved by the National Congress
(despite having initially opposed it and then attempted to decrease the
amount of the aid package).</p>
<p>Bolsonaro has increasingly attempted to gain more support from the
armed forces, whose members have increasingly been appointed to
government positions. The most extreme example of this is their complete
control over the Ministry of Health following the resignation of two
former ministers of health in the middle of the pandemic. The position
of interim head of the ministry and 40 other strategic positions are
occupied by military personnel who lack training in the arena of health.
More than 2,800 members of the armed forces have been appointed to
administrative state roles under Bolsonaro’s administration.</p>
<p>Faced with efforts to remove Bolsonaro from the presidency, his
administration has established alliances with legislators from parties
that do not have any ideological commitment and who instead sell their
votes to whoever is willing to pay more. This is what is called <i>centrão</i>.
Leading the charge in these negotiations are military leaders who are
generally critical of this kind of alliance but who are now seeking it
out in exchange for positions in the civil government (some have been
appointed to high-level positions in Bolsonaro’s cabinet). <b> </b></p>
<p>It is important to note that the weakening of the government does not
necessarily mean that Bolsonaro will be ousted, though it does allow
society to see the correlation of political forces more clearly. A
political dispute is currently being played out within the establishment
between neofascists – symbolized by the current president – and the
traditional right wing, which is represented by other institutions (such
as the parliament and legal system) and some state governors. In this
context, Bolsonaro’s challenge is to avoid impeachment and to organise a
parliamentary alliance that guarantees him support from the heads of
the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate.</p>
<p>The effort to defeat Bolsonaro has taken on an unprecedented central
role and has created awareness among wide-ranging sectors of society:
the Left, institutions (such as the parliament, legal system, and
especially the federal supreme court), intellectuals, public figures,
civil society organisations, and political parties – even those that
represent the right wing. However, such advances bring up debates and
challenges within the Left, such as the difficulty of creating a
tactical alliance in defence of Bolsonaro’s impeachment among the most
diverse sectors of society. This is indicative of the difficulty of
bringing forward a left front that is capable of building a people’s
project in Brazil and engaging in a dialogue with society about an
adequate and uniting exit from the crisis.</p>
<p>Political organisations and people’s movements in Brazil have raised
two important initiatives along these lines. The first is the
construction of a <a href="http://frentebrasilpopular.org.br/acao/plano-popular-de-emergencia-5b24/">Popular Emergency Plan</a>
in defence of life, health, income, and employment. This platform, in
addition to denouncing the neoliberal and neofascist project that is
underway, is based on the understanding that it is impossible to
dissociate the social mobilisation that is confronting the pandemic from
a qualitative and programmatic government plan. However, the current
government – which is guided by private business interests and acts
against scientific evidence – limits the possibility of state action in
the fight against the crisis and makes it extremely difficult to
overcome the challenges that the country is faced with.</p>
<p>The second initiative of political organisations and people’s
movements in Brazil is the construction of a Politics of Solidarity in
Brazil’s major peripheries, which helps coordinate a platform of
people’s movements that encompasses their diverse initiatives. Based on
solidarity, the battle of ideas, and grassroots work, this process aims
to strengthen the organisation of the masses through a coordinated,
popular project and to strengthen the people’s struggle as a whole.
Solidarity in this context goes hand in hand with the struggle for
rights: the right to quarantine with physical distancing, guaranteed
income, and access to water, food, and health.</p>
<p>A fierce struggle is necessary to win these rights and to gain access
to public resources – and it is people’s organisations that channel
this resistance and seek to embody hope for the people. Fighting for
people’s rights in the context of the pandemic requires putting in the
work to support building this process at all levels – from the local
level to the national level – in a coordinated way. Either the working
class will organise, fight for its life, and prepare for a political
struggle, or it will witness the bourgeoisie pillage the country and
bury the corpses of thousands of predominantly working-class and poor
people.</p>
<div id="gmail-attachment_22781" class="gmail-wp-caption"><p><img src="https://www.thetricontinental.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/06_Ven_Ajedrez-en-tiempos-de-Covid_Diko%CC%81.-Caracas-2020-_-CacriPhotos-5.jpg" alt="Chess in the time of COVID. Venezuela 2020. Dikó / CacriPhotos" style="margin-right: 0px;" width="461" height="307"></p><p id="gmail-caption-attachment-22781" class="gmail-wp-caption-text"><strong><span>Chess in the time of COVID. Venezuela 2020.</span></strong><br><span>Dikó / CacriPhotos</span></p></div>
<h2><span><b>Images of Imperialist Intervention </b></span></h2>
<p>This alarming public health crisis has not stopped the US from
continuing its aggressive imperialist policies in the region. For many
years, Cuba and Venezuela have been the main targets of the US-led
hybrid war, with the goal of strengthening US domination over what it
considers to be its ‘backyard’ (for more on the hybrid war, read our
dossier no. 17, <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/dossier-17-venezuela-and-hybrid-wars-in-latin-america/"><i>Venezuela and Hybrid Wars in Latin America</i></a>). Today, we are in a key a moment of intense global <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/books-veins-of-the-south">dispute</a> between the US and other powers, such as China and Russia (Boron 2020).</p>
<p>In Cuba, the policy of Washington’s war hawks – sharpened by US
President Donald Trump – has been to tighten the sanctions, accompanied
by a succession of hostile actions in the diplomatic, political, and
economic arenas. Among these actions, it is worth highlighting the US
Department of State’s re-inclusion of Cuba in the <a href="http://state.gov/countries-certified-as-not-cooperating-fully-with-u-s-counterterrorism-efforts/">list</a>
of countries that is ‘not cooperating fully with U.S. counterterrorism
efforts in 2019’, making 2020 ‘the first year that Cuba has been
certified as not fully cooperating since 2015’. This selected group of
public enemies, accused of ‘not fully cooperating with U.S.
counterterrorism efforts’, is made up of Iran, Syria, North Korea,
Venezuela, and now Cuba since May 2020.</p>
<p>In a mix of clumsiness and desperation in the midst of the crisis,
the United States government opted to attack Cuba’s cooperation with
countries around the world to collaborate on public health measures and
combat the crisis. The US State Department openly deployed a pressure
campaign against the rest of the world so that other countries would not
ask for help from Cuba. Despite the fact that the core of the US
narrative was amplified by private mainstream media, their attempt
failed: the role of the solidarity brigades became well-known, and
images of white coats and Cuban flags arriving at airports in countries
in crisis spread throughout the world.</p>
<p>Even before the pandemic, members of Cuba’s Henry Reeve International
Medical Brigade were sent to twenty-four countries, including Haiti.
The first country in the Americas to expel European colonialism in 1804,
in recent years Haiti’s dependence on imperialist powers has increased,
forced by coups d’état, foreign military occupation, and humanitarian
intervention by non-profit organisations in the Global North. As a
result, Haiti – one of the most violent experiments of the neoliberal
war – has become the counterpoint of Cuba, robbed of its sovereignty,
existing in a state of general poverty, and faced with a lack of public
services and growing repression. In Haiti, as in other countries, Cuba’s
response of solidarity stands out in contrast with the aggressive
policies of the United States, which prefers instead to deploy troops
and further cement its warlike character.</p>
<p>In the case of Venezuela, the confrontation by the United States has
continued to escalate. With each new confrontation, the United States’
plot of siege is increasingly exposed. The foiled mercenary incursion in
May, ‘Operation Gideon’, is another watershed moment in a long sequence
of attacks that are ignored or justified by international mainstream
media. The operation is representative of the character of the
Venezuelan opposition: completely surrendered to imperialism. One aspect
that stands out is that the operation was established through a
contract that formally linked Washington’s puppet Juan Guaidó to Jordan
Goudreau, the head of the mercenary corporation Silvercorp and a former
member of the US Armed Forces who recently worked in a security
operation for a campaign event for US President Donald Trump. The
operation is illustrative of the outsourcing (real or simulated) of
military interventions, which the US has promoted since the Gulf War
(for more on this, read our CoronaShock study no. 2: ‘<a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/studies-2-sanctions-and-coronashock/"><i>CoronaShock and the Hybrid War Against Venezuela</i></a>’).</p>
<p>The Colombian state, currently in the hands of Iván Duque (former president Álvaro Úribe’s disciple and staunch <i>uribista</i>),
has a special role in the siege against the Venezuelan government. In
public settings, Colombia is one of the main forces in the Lima Group,
the diplomatic forum that brings together right-wing governments across
the continent, supposedly to promote the well-being of the Venezuelan
people. At a more clandestine level, Colombia allows for the
establishment of paramilitary training camps stationed to attack
Venezuela.</p>
<p>While this is happening, Colombia is struggling with a spiral of
political violence that has placed the leaders of social movements in
its crosshairs. The police-military machinery unceasingly produces
scandals, including spying on public figures – some in its own
government.</p>
<p>The United States has nine military bases in Colombia, as well as
others in the Caribbean, some of which belong to the North Atlantic
Treaty Organisation (NATO). One aspect of the intervention driven by
Southern Command is true army propaganda. For example, much-touted naval
bases were put in place – supposedly to intercept boats carrying
illegal drugs – after the US attorney general accused Nicolás Maduro and
other <i>chavista </i>leaders of narco-trafficking and put a bounty on their heads.</p>
<p>The fleet that Southern Command deployed in the Caribbean appeared in
the news when the United States let it be known that it could be used
to stop the Iranian oil tankers that were on their way to Venezuela.
Despite this, the oil tankers arrived in Venezuela, breaking the US
embargo. The image of Iranian tankers in the Caribbean, escorted by the
National Bolivarian Armed Forces’ Sukhoi planes, is symbolic of the
shattering of US power. It shed light on the absurdity of the threats of
Trump’s administration, which has accumulated quite a number of
failures in recent months. However, the military threat remains and
should not be downplayed.</p>
<p>It is noteworthy that the US government is promoting conflict at a
time when the country’s death count continues to skyrocket (having
reached over 120,000 as of late June, the highest in the world). This
reality has unleashed such chaos that even the US’ well-oiled propaganda
machine has not succeeded in hiding the effects of the pandemic, nor
the blunders of the Trump administration. This stands in sharp contrast
to the political action of other states, such as China and its rapid and
comprehensive response to the pandemic, and Cuba. Just ninety miles
south of the US, this small rebellious island has been able to combat
the pandemic despite the US embargo while simultaneously aiding other
people across the world with its medical solidarity brigades. Meanwhile,
the US’ unilateralism has reached a record level, also demonstrated by
its fight with the WHO. It seems that the pandemic is <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/books-veins-of-the-south">accelerating</a> the global hegemonic transition (Merino 2020).</p>
<p>On top of this, the streets in the US are on fire once more, a result
of deeply embedded structural racism and police violence. The people’s
response to the murder of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, and others is
another indication of the level of tension that surges through the
United States; these uprisings chip away at the image of an all-powerful
empire that the country once brandished.</p>
<div id="gmail-attachment_22791" class="gmail-wp-caption"><p><img src="https://www.thetricontinental.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/07_ollas-arg-7.jpg" alt="Community kitchens combat hunger in poor areas. Villa Celina, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina, 2020. Nazareno Roviello / Union of Workers of the Popular Economy (UTEP)" style="margin-right: 0px;" width="461" height="306"></p><p id="gmail-caption-attachment-22791" class="gmail-wp-caption-text"><strong><span>Community kitchens combat hunger in poor areas. Villa Celina, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina, 2020.</span></strong><br><span>Nazareno Roviello / Union of Workers of the Popular Economy (UTEP)</span></p></div>
<h2><span><b>People’s Movements and the Challenges Ahead</b></span></h2>
<p>In October 2019, a new wave of struggles spread throughout much of
Latin America in response to the neoliberal offensive. Within just a few
months, the challenges and confines presented by the pandemic would
force the actions and demands of people’s movements in the region to
take on a different shape, each in their own way. But this change in the
conditions of struggle has not meant their disappearance. New forms of
organising have arisen through social media, with Twitter storms and
virtual meetings; <i>cacerolazos</i> (the banging of pots and pans in
protest, often from balconies and windows in the era of COVID-19);
street demonstrations adhering to social distancing with protestors
wearing masks; and, more recently, the return of strikes and the
blockading of streets and highways. This new face of people’s protests
has become more and more present in the context of the worsening health,
social, and political conditions facing the poor and the working class.</p>
<p>The effects of the pandemic and its use to further the capitalist
agenda have manifested through a significant increase in layoffs;
reductions in salaries; the increasing precariousness
of work, especially in the private and informal sectors; and a notable
advance in the digitalisation of work (such as the increasingly
precarious ‘uberisation’) that capitalists had already begun to promote
before the emergence of the virus. Faced with this daunting reality,
workers in the region have responded with various actions, including
delivery workers’ and other essential workers’ strikes on both a
regional and global level. It is worth paying particular attention to
the conflict and demands of health workers throughout the region (for
more on this read our dossier no. 29, <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/dossier-29-healthcare/"><i>Health Is a Political Choice</i></a>).</p>
<p>The situation is even worse in sectors with precarious or occasional
work that is insufficient for sustaining life. The absence of social
policies has had a disastrous impact, aggravating and triggering plagues
of hunger and illness (to read more about this on a global level, read
our twentieth newsletter (2020), <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/newsletterissue/20-2020-famine/"><i>Hunger Gnaws at the Edges of the World</i></a>). In this context, people’s movements have carried out heroic work, often in very difficult situations, organising <a href="https://indianexpress.com/article/india/kerala/keralas-43-lakh-strong-women-self-help-network-power-community-kitchens-during-coronavirus-lockdown-6334845/">canteens</a>
for the people; providing food and basic goods that are necessary for
public health; contributing to collective organisation; and demanding
effective solutions from governments. Among these efforts, it is worth
mentioning the distribution of food by organisations in poor
neighbourhoods in Chapare (Bolivia) that have been persecuted by the
dictatorship. In Brazil, more than more than 1,200 tonnes of food were
delivered to shantytowns in cities throughout the country by the
Landless Workers’ Movement (MST) and other people’s movements. In
Argentina, organisations linked to the popular economy have led such
efforts, demanding food and measures that guarantee assistance to poor
neighbourhoods that are suffering from the rapidly spreading virus.</p>
<p>In Guatemala, El Salvador, and Ecuador, women hang <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2020/may/22/guatemala-white-flags-hunger-coronavirus">white flags</a>
along the highway and families hang white flags from their homes to
symbolise widespread hunger and the demand for food. In Panama, the poor
are protesting by blockading the streets and organising <i>cacerolazos</i>.
In Santiago, Chile, residents of poor neighbourhoods who have protested
and constructed barricades are being repressed by the same government
that only offers them scraps. In El Alto, La Paz, and elsewhere in
Bolivia, workers and neighbours protest, denouncing the lack of work and
food. Similar events have unfolded in Bogotá (Colombia) and other large
urban centres in the region. The rejection of the neoliberal agenda in
Ecuador; <i>cacerolazos</i> and exploding fireworks in the streets of Bolivia demanding elections; and <i>panelaços</i> (<i>cacerolazos</i>) in Brazil alongside the chants <i>Fora Bolsonaro! </i>(‘Get
out, Bolsonaro!’) seem to indicate the reinvigoration of people’s
struggles under the new conditions raised by the pandemic.</p>
<p>The spread of the virus in poor neighbourhoods threatens to provoke a
social and health catastrophe. This reality is not limited to urban
areas and has been denounced by movements across the region, from the
Amazonian departments in Colombia (among the poorest regions in the
country) to Haiti. Organisations of indigenous peoples have also
denounced the dire situation looming over their homelands; as of late
May, there are at least <a href="https://www.telesurenglish.net/news/20000-Indigenous-in-the-Amazon-Infected-With-COVID-19-PAHO-20200520-0019.html">20,000</a> cases of infection in the Amazon basin according to the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO).</p>
<p>The pandemic has also exposed and aggravated the traumas of injustice
and the double exploitation, oppression, and violence against women and
against people across the LGBTQIA+ spectrum. Poor women in particular
have been impacted by the loss of income, the responsibility of domestic
caretaking, and the increase in violence, as seen by the growing
numbers of femicides. In Chile, the<i> Coordinadora Feminista 8M </i>has
played an important role, taking a lead in organising collective
feminist caretaking for families and populations in these areas;
shedding light on and demanding urgent attention towards the need for
the eradication of intrafamilial violence and the protection of women,
children, and adolescents; and demanding the right not to leave home to
work during the pandemic and the right to guaranteed income and other
emergency health measures.</p>
<p>Feminist women’s movements and other movements with a feminist
analysis have voiced loudly and clearly that caring for human life is
worth more than profits. The International People’s Assembly has <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/declaration-covid19/">called</a>
upon the people of the world to put the preservation of life before the
interests of capital and for an emancipatory exit to the contradiction
between health and the economy that continually emerges within the
capitalist framework. The ALBA movements’ platform in Latin America has
called for the condemnation of neoliberal governments, for the lifting
of sanctions, and for the rejection of imperialist aggressions. The
group also called to give life to a political programme and project from
below. Not only has the global reach of the virus-turned-pandemic
aggravated the social suffering caused by neoliberalism; it has also
made very clear the effects of capitalist globalisation and raised a
debate about the global disorder. The resistance of the people brings up
the necessity of building alternatives, which must strengthen and renew
internationalism.</p>
<div id="gmail-attachment_22801" class="gmail-wp-caption"><p><img src="https://www.thetricontinental.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/08_Br-MST-organiza-doac%CC%A7a%CC%83o-de-50-toneladas-de-alimentos-no-interior-do-Parana%CC%81_Foto-Wellington-Lenon-MST-9.jpg" alt="The MST organises the donation of fifty tons of food in the interior of Paraná, Brazil, April 2020. Wellington Lenon / MST" style="margin-right: 0px;" width="461" height="307"></p><p id="gmail-caption-attachment-22801" class="gmail-wp-caption-text"><strong><span>The MST organises the donation of fifty tons of food in the interior of Paraná, Brazil, April 2020.</span></strong><br><span>Wellington Lenon / MST</span></p></div>
<h2><span><b>The Past and the Present </b></span></h2>
<p>The expansion of the pandemic in Latin America has revealed the
precariousness of the system of public health and the eroded conditions
of life for the poor, the result of decades of neoliberal policies – as
shown by the failure of these policies to respond to the spread of the
disease. In the face of the crisis that is unfolding, the hegemonic
narrative often raises the urgency to return to the ‘normalcy’ of the
past. However, as we have shown, the past has in essence normalised the
economic, social, migration, environmental, and climate crisis that
characterises the development of neoliberalism. The future cannot simply
be reduced to going back to the past. The building of an effective exit
to the crisis must be centred on a profound transformation of its true
causes.</p>
<h3><span><b>Suggested Reading </b></span></h3>
<p>Boron, Atilio. ‘Notas sobre el imperialismo y la estrategia de seguridad de los Estados</p>
<p>Unidos’ [‘Notes on the current affairs of imperialism and on US new national security strategy’]. <i>Las
venas del Sur siguen abiertas. Debates sobre el imperialismo de nuestro
tiempo [The Veins of the South Are Still Open: Debates around the
imperialism of our time’], </i>edited by López, Emiliano, LeftWord, 2020.</p>
<p>Katz, Claudio. ‘Confluencia del virus en América Latina’ [‘The Confluence of the</p>
<p>Virus in Latin America’]. <i>Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research</i>, 14 May 2020. <a href="https://www.thetricontinental.org/es/ba-research/katz-confluencia/">https://www.thetricontinental.org/es/ba-research/katz-confluencia/</a></p>
<p>Merino, Gabriel. ‘La reconfiguración imperial de Estados Unidos y las fisuras</p>
<p>internas frente al ascenso de China’ [‘The Imperial Reconfiguration of the United States Against the Rise of China’]. <i>Las venas del Sur siguen abiertas. Debates sobre el imperialismo de nuestro tiempo</i>. <i>[The Veins of the South Are Still Open: Debates around the imperialism of our time’], </i>edited by López, Emiliano, LeftWord<b>, </b>2020.</p>
<p><em>This dossier was produced by the Observatory on Latin America and
the Caribbean (OBSAL) and the Buenos Aires and São Paulo offices of
Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research with the collaboration of
researchers and activists in the region. Among others, we would like to
thank Ana Maldonado of the Frente Francisco de Miranda de Venezuela.</em></p>
<div id="gmail-attachment_22811" class="gmail-wp-caption"><p><img src="https://www.thetricontinental.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/09_Ven_Mango-pla%CC%81tano-y-aguacate_Diko%CC%81.-Caracas-2020-_-CacriPhotos-6.jpg" alt="Mangoes, plantains, and avocados. Caracas, Venezuela, 2020. Dikó / CacriPhotos" style="margin-right: 0px;" width="461" height="307"></p><p id="gmail-caption-attachment-22811" class="gmail-wp-caption-text"><strong><span>Mangoes, plantains, and avocados. Caracas, Venezuela, 2020.</span></strong><br><span>Dikó / CacriPhotos</span></p></div>
</div><div class="gmail-content"><div class="gmail-moz-reader-content gmail-reader-show-element"><div id="gmail-readability-page-1" class="gmail-page"><div><div><div>
</div>
</div>
</div></div></div>
</div>
<div>
</div>
</div>
</div>