<div dir="ltr">
<div class="gmail-container gmail-content-width3">
<div class="gmail-header gmail-reader-header gmail-reader-show-element" dir="ltr">
<font size="1"><a href="https://venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/14848">https://venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/14848</a>
</font><h1 class="gmail-reader-title">Class and Quarantine in Venezuela: A Conversation with Anacaona Marin of El Panal Commune</h1>
<div class="gmail-credits gmail-reader-credits">By Cira Pascual Marquina – April 17, 2020<br></div></div><hr><div class="gmail-content">
<div class="gmail-moz-reader-content gmail-line-height4 gmail-reader-show-element" dir="ltr"><div id="gmail-readability-page-1" class="gmail-page"><div>
<div><p><em>Anacaona Marin is one of the key spokespeople
of El Panal – a commune with some 13,000 people in the 23 de Enero
barrio in Caracas – and a member of the Alexis Vive Patriotic Force. A
year ago <a href="https://venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/14435">we interviewed her</a>
about communal organization and Chavez’s legacy. Now, in the era of
coronavirus lockdown, we talked candidly about the harsh conditions that
working-class people are facing today and grassroots responses to the
crisis. </em></p>
<p><strong>What is your interpretation of the COVID-19 pandemic and its impact on the Venezuelan pueblo?</strong></p>
<p>These are times that call for reflection but also for action. As part
of the popular movement, we cannot be merely passive spectators when we
face a pandemic or, for that matter, when the pueblo faces any crisis…
Che said: “We must act as we think.”</p>
<p>When faced with situations such as pandemics, invasions, or natural
disasters, all subjects seem to coincide: Anybody can become a victim.
However, you just have to scratch the surface to see something else:
Although the virus itself is blind to social class, the social
distancing measures have hugely different effects for the rich and for
the poor.</p>
<p>It’s urgent that social leaders, organizations, and the government
recognize this. We must acknowledge that there are economic and
historical features of this crisis. We must understand how it affects
the working class, people from the barrios – all those folks who have no
savings, who live from one day to the next.</p>
<p>It is necessary to incorporate a class perspective into the reading
of the current situation and to understand the current pandemic not just
as a biological phenomenon: The root of it all is in a model that we
must overcome.</p>
<p>Beyond the issue of how to protect ourselves, our loved ones and our
society, and beyond containing the pandemic, we have to understand
certain structural issues: How do poor people experience the lockdown
and why?</p>
<p>We have nothing against artists, singers or public figures who make
videos sharing their lockdown tips. And we respect good-hearted
recommendations on what to read or what movie to watch on Netflix while
at home. However, let’s visualize this: A poor man in his barrio home
turns on his small TV and sees the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MepdOlwdvY4">Oreja de Van Gogh</a>
song or the image of a “normal” person opening the freezer at home and
choosing her favorite ice cream flavor. Meanwhile, in the rancho [a
poor, self-built barrio house], the kids are saying, “Dad, I’m hungry!”
With an empty refrigerator and out of work, how is this person supposed
to carry out social distancing? Can he really stay at home? Why is the
lockdown always represented in the media as something experienced by
privileged people?</p>
<p>Reflecting on this world that is divided into classes is an urgent
task for the popular movement right now. We have to think about how
people are really living this crisis depending on their social class,
particular conditions, and their locality. The debate about how the
current situation affects the poor must be brought to the forefront. We
have to reflect on how we live in our collective conditions.</p>
<p>We applaud the government’s initiative to keep school canteens open
as soup kitchens for those in need. We also celebrate the participation
of communal councils and communes in this process. Here, in our barrio,
we have a social map of the community and we are able to determine who
is most vulnerable and what are the families at greatest risk.</p>
<p>However, this is not going to get people out of poverty. To contain
the virus, new mechanisms that allow for real physical distancing must
be generated, and we also have to make sure that people won’t be poorer
at the end of the lockdown.</p>
<div><div><div><div id="gmail-file-13243--6">
<div>
<p><a href="https://venezuelanalysis.com/files/images/%5Bsite-date-yyyy%5D/%5Bsite-date-mm%5D/1panal.png" title="Soup kitchen under El Panal Commune control. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)"><img src="https://venezuelanalysis.com/files/styles/full_content/public/images/%5Bsite-date-yyyy%5D/%5Bsite-date-mm%5D/1panal.png?itok=mrj7342q" alt="Soup kitchen under El Panal Commune control. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)" title="" width="1200" height="447"></a></p><div>
<p>Soup kitchen under El Panal Commune control. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)</p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div></div></div>
<p><strong>Social distancing and stay-at-home policies can have a
classist bias. Technically, they are policies that protect all, but the
truth is that the working class can’t necessarily carry them out. Poor
people, under normal circumstances, face difficulties and even death
every day. Since they don’t have enough to eat, lack the medicines they
need and have security problems, they are understandably willing to take
risks now. Why isn’t this ever discussed in the public sphere?</strong></p>
<p>We are in favor of the national government’s policies for containment
in general. It acted quickly and that is good. However, as an
organization that takes our share of responsibility for what happens
here, we have a big question hanging over our heads: If people aren’t
able to go out and work, how are they going to eat? At the risk of
repeating myself, a public debate regarding this facet of the crisis has
to happen, and it has to happen now.</p>
<p>It is hard to tell your kids – and I am a mother, so I have some
experience – “No, today there is nothing to eat because we cannot go
out.” It is our obligation as revolutionaries and participants in the
Bolivarian Process to make people’s real situation visible.</p>
<p>We shouldn't just echo the romantic attitude toward the lockdown. It
is also very important that this reflection goes beyond the idealistic
representation of the pueblo. The television shows them making facemasks
and coordinating access to soup kitchens… all that is good, but the
reality has many other elements.</p>
<p>There are so many ways that communities are organizing, and the media
should represent that too! To give you a few examples: we attempt to
locate the most vulnerable people in our community; our organization has
developed local protection protocols; there is grassroots supervision
of commerce to limit speculation; and we organize producer-to-consumer <a href="https://venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/13862">pueblo a pueblo</a>
food markets, thus providing low-cost produce to people. As part of the
pueblo, we are active subjects and should be represented as such.</p>
<p>The pueblo is not passive… ¡Solo el pueblo salva al pueblo! [Only the people can save the people!].</p>
<div><div><div><div id="gmail-file-13244--6">
<div>
<p><a href="https://venezuelanalysis.com/files/images/%5Bsite-date-yyyy%5D/%5Bsite-date-mm%5D/2panal.png" title="Food shopping, 23 de Enero, Caracas. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)"><img src="https://venezuelanalysis.com/files/styles/full_content/public/images/%5Bsite-date-yyyy%5D/%5Bsite-date-mm%5D/2panal.png?itok=IY-7vb4l" alt="Food shopping, 23 de Enero, Caracas. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)" title="" width="1200" height="445"></a></p><div>
<p>Food shopping, 23 de Enero, Caracas. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)</p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div></div></div>
<p><strong>Communal production is one of El Panel’s strategic goals. In the current situation, how is production holding up?</strong></p>
<p>In our organization, studying is very important, and we are now going
back to reading People’s War, People’s Army by Vietnamese General Vo
Nguyen Giap. There he talks about the importance of continuing
production in the midst of the war. One of his main concerns was how to
make sure that rice production continued under war conditions.</p>
<p>For us, it is a real challenge to maintain our plans for strategic
production while we are in pandemic prevention mode, but we are doing
it. The situation is like a war in many ways: Most roads are blocked and
there is a huge gasoline shortage, but we are very committed to
maintaining our production. In our bakery we are facing an additional
problem: We are not receiving flour through the regular state channels,
as many other bakeries do. However, our textile factory, our periurban
projects and our work in the campo are all going forward. This includes
raising goats right here in 23 de Enero...</p>
<p>It is not easy, but we are determined to continue producing.</p>
<div><div><div><div id="gmail-file-13245--6">
<div>
<p><a href="https://venezuelanalysis.com/files/images/%5Bsite-date-yyyy%5D/%5Bsite-date-mm%5D/3panal.png" title="Periurban productive projects in El Panal Commune. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)"><img src="https://venezuelanalysis.com/files/styles/full_content/public/images/%5Bsite-date-yyyy%5D/%5Bsite-date-mm%5D/3panal.png?itok=BcGE1hCE" alt="Periurban productive projects in El Panal Commune. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)" title="" width="1200" height="446"></a></p><div>
<p>Periurban productive projects in El Panal Commune. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)</p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div></div></div>
<p><strong>Can you explain something about the soup kitchens and the textile factory here in the El Panal commune?</strong></p>
<p>In the El Panal Commune, there are five soup kitchens that provide
lunch in addition to the self-managed meal projects in the afternoon.
Some one-thousand people benefit daily from these meals, which are
delivered door-to-door.</p>
<p>The preparation and cooking happen not only with the participation of
the madres procesadoras [mothers who prepare food], who are paid by the
Ministry of Education, but also with the help of our volunteers. After
the food has been prepared, the volunteers deliver the meals
house-to-house. In that way, the community participates in bringing food
to the most vulnerable families.</p>
<p>We also have a textile factory called Abejitas del Panal, where we
have shifted to producing facemasks. More than 1200 have been freely
provided to the most vulnerable people, but also to CDIs [Integral
Diagnostics Centers, part of <a href="https://venezuelanalysis.com/tag/barrio-adentro">Mision Barrio Adentro</a>], and sister organizations that have requested them.</p>
<p>Community supervision is one of the features of all communes, and El
Panal has stood out in this sense. Some years ago the commune
appropriated an idle state food packing plant and put it to work for the
community. Additionally, just a few days back the organization took
charge of an institutional soup kitchen in the neighborhood. Why did you
take this step?</p>
<p>It happened just over two weeks ago, in the early days of the
pandemic crisis. We observed some irregularities and decided to do a
popular inspection. When we went in, we found more than a ton of rice
and more than a ton of cornflower lying around. Obviously, we couldn’t
allow that food to go bad or get lost in the midst of this crisis, so we
took control.</p>
<p>Now we, as El Panal Commune, manage the soup kitchen. We supply some
of the produce while the Ministry of Education continues to deliver the
staple ingredients. Even though we took control of this soup kitchen,
the relationship with the institution has been very cordial – we have
good coordination, communication and a spirit of cooperation.</p>
<p>Earlier you suggested there the usual way of depicting the organized
communities as mere receptors of food or places where people make
handmade facemasks was highly problematic. In fact, a true portrait of
the pueblo now should be different: more about empowerment and politics.</p>
<p>As a militant of this revolution, I view the public media’s depiction
of popular initiatives with some concern. The normal way of
representing popular power these days is limited to showing that some
grassroots organizations are hard at work making facemasks or
distributing food.</p>
<p>While many organizations are doing this, and it’s good to make it
visible, communal councils, communes, and grassroots organizations are
doing so much more! There are projects in the areas of production,
distribution, self-defense, and also there are important processes of
debate and reflection.</p>
<p>In our organization, we are quite committed to reflection. We have to
think about how to come out of this with our people’s physical
integrity intact. To do so, we also have to raise our voices to express
their urgent needs.</p>
<div><div><div><div id="gmail-file-13248--6">
<div>
<p><a href="https://venezuelanalysis.com/files/images/%5Bsite-date-yyyy%5D/%5Bsite-date-mm%5D/4panal.png" title="Abejitas del Panal, part of El Panal Commune, hard at work producing facemasks. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)"><img src="https://venezuelanalysis.com/files/styles/full_content/public/images/%5Bsite-date-yyyy%5D/%5Bsite-date-mm%5D/4panal.png?itok=qR6cQCvh" alt="Abejitas del Panal, part of El Panal Commune, hard at work producing facemasks. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)" title="" width="1200" height="445"></a></p><div>
<p>Abejitas del Panal, part of El Panal Commune, hard at work producing facemasks. (Javier Gomez/Venezuelanalysis)</p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div></div></div>
<p><strong>Working-class Venezuelans were already suffering from the
effects of the crisis and the US sanctions before COVID-19 hit us… And
I’m not talking about the coronavirus patients, I’m talking about the
millions of barrio dwellers that survive from one day to the next and
are now basically without resources. Those people may be grateful that
they received a facemask or a meal from the soup kitchen, but the real
question here is how can people survive without working? As I said
earlier, we commend the government for acting rapidly when the first
coronavirus cases appeared in Venezuela, but the situation of the pueblo
has to be addressed.</strong></p>
<p>Again, we are asking for an analysis of the people’s situation from a
perspective that is not picturesque. What we want is a class-based
understanding of that situation.</p>
<p>A crisis could help us break the back of the capitalist system – it’s
the system that caused this pandemic. Let’s not be spectators in the
face of the pandemic. Let’s deal with it as revolutionaries, as
working-class subjects, and as active subjects!</p>
<p>US imperialism is going full force now against the Venezuelan
government, and therefore against the Venezuelan people. The White House
seems to be beating the war drums much more than normal these days. How
is El Panel preparing, should there be an invasion?</p>
<p>The defense of the Patria is one of the key tasks of any revolutionary organization.</p>
<p>We believe that there are a variety of scenarios on the table. One
would be the Panama scenario. Then there is the paramilitary scenario
with surgical strikes – in fact, for a while now, the popular movement
has been losing leaders at the hands of paramilitaries (and those
murders reflect a coordinated plan).</p>
<p>Because the threat is imminent, we need more organization and
preparation. Getting information about the territory we work in is one
of the keys to defense: We must know how many people we are: who’s who
and how each person can be deployed; who really has the capacity and the
will to struggle. We have to think about how to protect the commune and
defend the country.</p>
<p>We have a true commitment with the Patria: The blood of patriots runs
in our veins and the memory of those who liberated this continent is in
our collective being, but we cannot stay put and pretend that discourse
alone will protect us. We have to know our capacities and our
abilities. And we are working on that right now.</p>
<p>We are preparing for a people’s war on the model of Vietnam. War
would be an invasion, and whatever form it might take, it would be
all-encompassing. We understand that the enemy has a far greater
military capacity, but we also know – and I don’t say this with romantic
idealism – that with organization and preparation, and with the
accumulated experience of a pueblo that has been living in war-like
conditions for a few years now, we would be able to overcome the enemy.</p>
<p><strong>Of course, defending the Patria would also involve the civic-military union, wouldn’t it?</strong></p>
<p>Yes, the civic-military union is paramount. That is the Chavista
formula, and it plays a very important role in all invasion scenarios.
With this in mind, we hope that a more consolidated cooperation with the
military would take shape should the invasion scenario become a
reality.</p>
<p>In any case, our organization is ready to defend the Patria.</p>
<div><div><div><div id="gmail-file-13246--6">
<div>
<p><a href="https://venezuelanalysis.com/files/images/%5Bsite-date-yyyy%5D/%5Bsite-date-mm%5D/5panal.png" title="Left: Anacaona Marin / Top right: View of 23 de Enero, Caracas / Bottom right: Chavez mural at El Panal Commune sports court. (Archives)"><img src="https://venezuelanalysis.com/files/styles/full_content/public/images/%5Bsite-date-yyyy%5D/%5Bsite-date-mm%5D/5panal.png?itok=FQZMuJZK" alt="Left: Anacaona Marin / Top right: View of 23 de Enero, Caracas / Bottom right: Chavez mural at El Panal Commune sports court. (Archives)" title="" width="1200" height="447"></a></p><div>
<p>Left: Anacaona Marin / Top right: View of 23 de Enero,
Caracas / Bottom right: Chavez mural at El Panal Commune sports court.
(Archives)</p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div></div></div>
</div>
</div></div></div>
</div>
<div>
</div>
</div>
</div>