[News] A Dialogue Across Civilisations, for Now
Anti-Imperialist News
news at freedomarchives.org
Thu Apr 23 10:51:05 EDT 2026
A Dialogue Across Civilisations, for Now: The Seventeenth Newsletter (2026)
View this email in your browser
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=8feafdaf1e&e=d206d0a40d>
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=3a1fd48bb5&e=d206d0a40d>
A Dialogue Across Civilisations, for Now: The Seventeenth Newsletter (2026)
The way Iran has been able to stand up to the West has become a source
of admiration across the formerly colonised world. Where does that
confidence come from?
Abdel Hamid Baalbaki (Lebanon), /War/, 1977.
Dear friends,
Greetings from the desk of Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=f76b66a5c5&e=d206d0a40d>.
During some of the worst days of the illegal US-Israeli war on Iran, I
was talking to friends who were in the civilian areas being bombed. Some
of them are scholars, others poets and artists, some work in the
government, others in institutions of different kinds. All of them,
regardless of their views of the government, stood defiant. Not one
person felt that their world was under threat. They remained steadfast,
their courage emanating from an immense belief in the resilience of
Iranian civilisation.
Marxist and national liberation thought have had a very complex history
with the concept of ‘civilisation’. Classical Marxism rejected it, since
it could flatten social division under a blanket of cultural homogeneity
and therefore negate the necessity of class struggle. But as Marxism
became a crucial framework in the great anticolonial struggles of the
post-World Anti-Fascist War
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=c91b9e493b&e=d206d0a40d>
era, the idea of civilisation returned with a different meaning.
Civilisation came to be understood as a valuable terrain in the cultural
struggle against imperialism. It could become an instrument of national
continuity and political legitimacy rather than simply an ideological
mask for class domination. Yet this reclamation of civilisation had to
be carried out from the standpoint of an emancipatory project willing to
break with certain reactionary inheritances within that civilisation itself.
In the case of China, for instance, Chinese Marxism – best synthesised
by Mao Zedong – insisted on a break from the worst inheritances of
pre-revolutionary China, such as Confucian hierarchy and sexism, at the
same time as it adopted, through class struggle and ideological
transformation, the very idea of ‘Chinese civilisation’ as a bulwark
against imperialism and for the development of national patriotism.
Kusbudiyanto (Indonesia), /Bird Market/, 2026.
The Iranian Revolution (1978–1979) was made by a range of political
forces, including Marxists, many of whom were subsequently persecuted
and killed by the newly created Islamic Republic. Despite their
subjugation, many Marxist ideas entered the ideological framework of the
Islamic Republic, whether through the work of a range of thinkers with
their own histories with Marxism such as Ehsan Tabari (1917–1989), Jalal
Al-e Ahmad (1923–1969), Ali Shariati (1933–1977), Bijan Jazani
(1938–1975), or Khosrow Golsorkhi (1944–1974). I wish I could write more
about these thinkers, but that would take an entire book. The most
compelling was Golsorkhi, who was killed in his prime. He told a rattled
judge at his trial:
I begin my words with a saying of Mowla [Imam] Hossein, a great
martyr for the peoples of the Middle East. I, who am a
Marxist-Leninist, first sought social justice in the school of
Islam, and from there arrived at socialism. I will not bargain for
my life in this court, nor even for my lifespan. I am an
insignificant drop from the struggles and deprivation of the
fighting peoples of Iran… Yes, I will not bargain for my life, for I
am the child of a fighting and courageous people. I began my words
with Islam. True Islam in Iran has always repaid its debt to Iran’s
liberation movements. The Seyyed Abdollah Behbahanis, the Sheikh
Mohammad Khiyabanis, are true embodiments of these movements. And
today too, true Islam repays its debt to Iran’s national liberation
movements. When Marx says, ‘In a class society, wealth accumulates
on one side and poverty, hunger, and misery on the other, while
those who produce wealth are themselves deprived’, and Mowla [Imam]
Ali says, ‘No palace is erected unless thousands are impoverished’,
there is a profound similarity. Thus, one can name Mowla [Imam] Ali
as the first socialist in history, and likewise the Salman Farsis
and Abu Dharr Ghaffaris.
By the time of the revolution, the Iranian left – divided among the
Fedayeen guerrillas, the communist Tudeh Party, and the
Islamist-revolutionary Mujahideen – had come to understand that they
could not overthrow the Shah without the religious forces. But they
underestimated the power of the clerics over Iranian society, including
over the working class. It was this miscalculation that transformed the
Iranian Revolution into the Islamic Republic within a year. Yet rather
than form an ordinary theocracy, post-revolutionary Iran drew on a much
older civilisational inheritance, one that dates back to the rule of
Cyrus the Great (559–530 BCE) and the Achaemenid Empire (c. 550–330 BCE)
– roughly two thousand years before the arrival of Shi’ism as the state
religion in Iran during the Safavid Empire (1501–1736). It is this older
civilisational inheritance that plays a foundational role in Iranian
society, enabling it to absorb internal differences and to summon a
deeper historical legitimacy at times of terrible crisis as the basis
for the defence of sovereignty. In 1971, the Shah held a massive event
at Persepolis to celebrate 2,500 years of continuous civilisation since
Cyrus the Great. Later, during Iraq’s war of aggression on Iran from
1980 to 1988, when Saddam Hussein tried to cast the conflict as a war of
Arabs against Persians, the Islamic Republic rejected that framework and
insisted that this was rather a ‘defence of the homeland’ (دفاع از وطن,
/defa’ az vatan/), drawing on the idea of an unconquered and uncolonised
land that must be defended at all costs by its people.
Ibrahim El-Salahi (Sudan), /Vision of the Tomb/, 1965.
It is difficult for those who do not come from colonised societies to
understand the power of such statements as ‘defence of the homeland’ and
of the idea of civilisational inheritance. The damage caused to so many
social formations by colonialism is vast. Colonialism steals wealth and
reinvests it elsewhere for the development of other peoples; it
denigrates the colonised peoples’ cultures and often denies them their
own language and their own sense of a historical mission. That is why so
many people in the Global South marvel that Iran has been able to stand
up to the United States and win the current conflict in strategic terms.
For those who share that history of obliteration, to witness the kind of
dignity displayed by societies such as China or Iran, where there is
less need to fashion cultural pride out of hallucinations (through the
creation of imagined pasts) or by vilifying others (whether minorities
or foreigners), is nothing short of inspiring. The lack of total
colonial destruction of culture in such places allows for their own
history to be reclaimed and reconstructed without being totally caught
up in false reversals of the West (often equal parts rejection and
mimicry). It is the kind of confidence that faces the destructive power
of the United States with dignity and has the courage to send back Lego
memes of Trump and his associates that are not about empty mockery but
about genuine disdain.
Eng Hwee Chu (Malaysia), /Beyond the Border/, 2014.
In December 1997, the Organisation of the Islamic Conference (OIC)
released
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=a8d0504a4a&e=d206d0a40d>
the Tehran Declaration, which advanced the idea of a ‘Dialogue of
Civilisations’. This was a direct response to Samuel Huntington’s 1993
essay and 1996 book /The Clash of Civilisations and the Remaking of
World Order./ In that initial essay
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=333512cca6&e=d206d0a40d>,
published in /Foreign Affairs/, Huntington predicted that ‘Conflict
between civilisations will be the latest phase in the evolution of
conflict in the modern world’. For Huntington, history had moved from
the clash of ideologies (communism versus capitalism) to the clash of
civilisations (which he defined in religious-cultural terms as ‘Western,
Confucian, Japanese, Islamic, Hindu, Slavic-Orthodox, Latin American,
and possibly African civilisation’). Huntington warned that the new
fault lines would be along these axes. The OIC cautioned that this way
of seeing the world might produce the very conflict it claimed to
describe rather than prevent it, and that it would be better to hold a
dialogue of civilisations rather than await the conflict between them.
The Tehran Declaration found traction within the United Nations (UN) but
not in the halls of Western capitals, where the rhetoric of the War on
Terror – which predated 2001 – escalated out of control. Fear of Islam
became routine, and it was quickly associated with fear of migrants, a
dual fear that continues to paralyse Europe and the Americas. In 1998,
the UN proclaimed 2001 the Year of Dialogue Among Civilisations, and at
the 31^st General Conference of the UN Educational, Scientific, and
Cultural Organisation, held in Paris from 15 October to 3 November 2001,
it selected the Iranian philosopher and diplomat Ahmad Jalali as its
president and invited Iran’s president, Seyyed Mohammad Khatami, to
address the body. The conference took place little more than a month
after the attacks on the US in September and during the US invasion of
Afghanistan as part of its Global War on Terror. Khatami’s address
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=2b220a0fcf&e=d206d0a40d>
remains powerful, asking the world not to yield to ‘false political
polarisations and divisions’. Terrorism ‘is the result of the sinister
union between blind intolerance and brute force, with the goal of
serving an illusion which, despite all its propaganda, is nothing but
the projection of the harmful contents of the unconscious’.
Gerard Sekoto (South Africa), /Mother and Baby/, 1943–1945.
When a terrorist attack happens, the worst thing, Khatami said, is to
respond with revenge. ‘Revenge is like salt water which, though it looks
like water, increases the thirst rather than satisfying it, thus
entangling the world in perpetual outbreaks of violence, hatred, and
revenge’. Rather than revenge, Khatami insisted, dialogue ‘is the
principal need of the international community’.
A call for dialogue is important and necessary because the alternative
is driving us toward annihilation – both through the system of
capitalism that deepens inequality and drives planetary destruction and
through the system of imperialism that devours societies with war. But
neither civilisation nor dialogue will by themselves drive history
toward human emancipation. For that, in time, the class struggle will
have to intensify, human needs will have to overcome material
inequalities and power relations, and the global system will have to be
transformed to meet our complex destinies rather than turn us against
one another.
José Clemente Orozco (Mexico), /Katharsis/, 1934–1935.
Carlos Gutiérrez Cruz (1897–1930) developed his poetic sensibility amid
the literary currents of post-revolutionary Mexico, including the
patriotic group Contemporáneos (Contemporaries), but later broke with
them as he became more radical. In 1923, he published /Cómo piensa la
plebe, folleto de propaganda libertaria en haikais/ (How the Plebs
Think: A Pamphlet of Liberation Propaganda in Haikais), which turned the
haikai form associated in Mexico with José Juan Tablada (1871–1945) into
a vehicle for communist poetry. Gutiérrez Cruz understood that there was
no sense in defending the nation if the masses of workers got nothing
from it. The point bears repeating here: a civilisation cannot be
defended as an abstraction. If it is to mean anything, it must be
defended as the living record of those who make history. As he put it in
one of his haikais:
/Labriego, la tierra da ciento por uno
//y tú ganas uno por ciento/.
Peasant, the land yields a hundred from one
and you earn one from a hundred.
Warmly,
Vijay
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=b9a8b6dd50&e=d206d0a40d>
Website <www.tricontinental.org>
Facebook
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=2c04bc49e2&e=d206d0a40d>
Twitter
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=629166e9bc&e=d206d0a40d>
Instagram
<https://thetricontinental.us11.list-manage.com/track/click?u=6a79324d3b4acfde1e7e546c6&id=9bdbe794db&e=d206d0a40d>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20260423/baae652d/attachment-0001.htm>
More information about the News
mailing list