[News] Suspended for Pro-Palestine Speech: My statement on Yale Law School’s embrace of AI-generated smears

Thu Mar 13 16:13:22 EDT 2025

mondoweiss.net
<https://mondoweiss.net/2025/03/suspended-for-pro-palestine-speech-my-statement-on-yale-law-schools-embrace-of-ai-generated-smears/>
Suspended for Pro-Palestine Speech: My statement on Yale Law School’s
embrace of AI-generated smears
Helyeh Doutaghi
March 13, 2025
------------------------------
[image: Yale_Law_School_Courtyard-1024x768.jpg]

Editor’s Note: The following statement was originally published on Helyeh
Doutaghi’s account <https://x.com/Helyeh_Doutaghi> on the X platform on
March 12, 2025. Last week, Doutaghi was placed on administrative leave by
Yale Law School
<https://www.nytimes.com/2025/03/12/us/yale-suspends-scholar-terrorism.html?unlocked_article_code=1.3k4.Qe2K.3B3RTYXJmFRs&smid=url-share>
following an AI-generated article falsely accusing her of being a
“terrorist” over connections to Palestine advocacy organizations.

My name is Helyeh Doutaghi. I am a scholar of international law and
geopolitical economy. My research engages with Third World Approaches to
International Law (TWAIL), postcolonial critiques of law, and the global
political economy of sanctions. I have specifically examined the mechanisms
and consequences of economic warfare on Iran, as well as the forms of
knowledge produced in International Humanitarian Law (IHL) to obscure and
shield U.S. military operations from accountability. On October 1, 2023, I
was appointed Deputy Director of the Law and Political Economy (LPE)
Project and joined the team. I also held the position of Associate Research
Scholar at Yale Law School (YLS), a non-tenured faculty role without
teaching responsibilities.

On the morning of March 3rd, I was notified of an online report about me.
An obscure AI-powered right-wing Zionist platform called “Jewish Onliner
<https://jewishonliner.org/p/member-of-us-designated-terror-group>”
published a report falsely accusing me of being a “terrorist”. Rather than
defend me, the Yale Law School moved within less than 24 hours of learning
about the report to place me on leave.

I was given only a few hours’ notice by the administration to attend an
interrogation based on far-right AI-generated allegations against me, while
enduring a flood <https://x.com/eyakoby/status/1896653646462664815?s=46> of
online harassment, death threats, and abuse by Zionist trolls, exacerbating
ongoing unprecedented distress and complications both at work and at home.
I endured all of this while fasting, and my request for religious
accommodations during Ramadan was dismissed. Just a few hours later, YLS
placed me on leave, revoked my IT access—including email—and banned me from
campus. I was afforded no due process and no reasonable time to consult
with my attorney.

Rather than investigate the source of these allegations first, the nation’s
“top law school” accepted them at face value, and shifted the burden of
proof from the accuser to the accused, treating me, prima facie, as guilty
until proven otherwise. Whether Yale Law School’s attorneys knowingly
relied on AI-fabricated claims
<https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/security-aviation/2025-01-29/ty-article/.premium/pro-israel-bot-goes-rogue-calls-idf-soldiers-white-colonizers-in-apartheid-israel/00000194-ae81-def2-afdc-eeab470d0000>or
simply chose willful ignorance remains unanswered.

To conduct the interrogation, Yale Law School retained David Ring
<https://www.wiggin.com/person/david-a-ring/> from the law firm Wiggin and
Dana —an attorney whose public profile includes “Israel” listed as a
“service” he provides and whose portfolio boasts advising “the world’s
largest aerospace and defense companies.” Twice appointed by the U.S. State
Department as a Special Compliance Officer, his career is deeply embedded
in the very industries that sustain genocide and war crimes in Palestine.
When I raised my concerns about the potential conflict of interests posed
by his participation in this process, YLS dismissed them, stating there was
“no concern with his ability to conduct a fair interview.” It is
reprehensible that YLS would appoint a counsel who profits from the
machinery of Palestinian death to “interview” an employee about their
public anti-genocide and pro-Palestine positions.

Yale has engaged in bad faith throughout this “process.” This became evident
 from the administration’s insistence on an immediate interrogation with an
unreasonable timeline, from the type of attorney hired to “interview” me,
from the fact that this outside counsel refused to answer questions about
procedural protections, and from the denial of my request for a brief
religious accommodation. YLS’s singular concern with maintaining the
approval of the Zionist backers who bankroll their complicity in genocide
led the organization to pressure me into an interrogation that I had every
reason to believe was designed not to uncover the truth, but to justify a
predetermined outcome. For further details from my lawyer see his note at
the end of this statement.

What is clear is that YLS actions constitute a blatant act of retaliation
against Palestinian solidarity—a violation of my constitutional rights,
free speech, academic freedom, and fundamental due process rights. I am
being targeted for one reason alone: for speaking the truth about the
genocide of the Palestinian people that Yale University is complicit in.

The Endowment Justice Coalition (EJC) has exposed
<https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2023/12/01/weiner-bista-yale-corporation-divest-from-weapons/>
Yale’s
deep financial ties to weapons manufacturers, using publicly available tax
filings. The university’s asset managers include JLL Partners, linked to
General Dynamics and Lockheed Martin, and Farallon Capital, which invests
in HowMet Aerospace, a company that produces key components for US F-35
fighter jets used by Israel in committing genocide.

As a movement scholar who stands unequivocally against imperialism and the
U.S.-Zionist genocide, my presence—particularly as a Muslim-Iranian woman
at an elite university that is deeply entangled in the material and
ideological structures of genocide—is intolerable to the forces of fascism
that are ruling this country.

The attacks against me, including defamatory smears amplified by fascist
trolls, are emblematic of a broader official policy of this authoritarian
regime to weaponize AI to target students, faculty, and organizers who dare
to speak out against genocide, systemic starvation, and the ethnic
cleansing of Palestinians.

The attacks against me, including defamatory smears amplified by fascist
trolls, are emblematic of a broader official policy of this authoritarian
regime to weaponize AI to target students, faculty, and organizers who dare
to speak out against genocide, systemic starvation, and the ethnic
cleansing of Palestinians. This crackdown, now formalized under the
recently announced “Catch and Revoke
<https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/06/foreign-student-visas-pro-palestinian-ai>”
initiative, marks a dangerous escalation in state repression—one explicitly
designed to foster an atmosphere of fear across university campuses. It
should cause profound concern to all defenders of free speech that those
infamous words, “Are you now or have you ever been a member of…” are once
again becoming a common refrain. We are entering an era of Zionist
McCarthyism—a time when dissent is invariably met with crackdown, careers
are destroyed for speaking the truth, and the mere act of standing in
solidarity with Palestine liberation is treated as a crime. Just as
McCarthyism sought to crush anti-imperialist resistance through fear and
repression, this new iteration aims to silence, intimidate, and purge those
who challenge Zionist settler-colonialism and U.S. imperialism.

This is not a display of strength; it is the last refuge of a crumbling
order—an empire in decline, resorting to brute repression to stifle and
crush those who expose its unraveling hegemony.

We are entering an era of Zionist McCarthyism—a time when dissent is
invariably met with crackdown, careers are destroyed for speaking the
truth, and the mere act of standing in solidarity with Palestine liberation
is treated as a crime. Just as McCarthyism sought to crush anti-imperialist
resistance through fear and repression, this new iteration aims to silence,
intimidate, and purge those who challenge Zionist settler-colonialism and
U.S. imperialism.

Knowledge must be in the service of the oppressed. If what we learn and
teach does not compel and empower us to use our pens and voices to
challenge systems of oppression, then it is meaningless—an intellectual
exercise stripped of purpose. Western academic institutions cultivate a
cowardly class of intellectual collaborators who write critically about
oppression yet uphold it through their silence when their privileges are
threatened. Columbia University’s complicity in the latest wave of
repression against its students exemplifies this.

This is how fascism wins: not just through brute force, but through
remaining reactive in the face of oppression, and through the complicity of
those who claim to stand for justice yet choose to stay silent when fascism
strikes. The past 17 months have proved that many within the Western “left”
are unwilling to make the kinds of sacrifices required to end the genocide.
In academia and outside, they profit—both personally and
professionally—from the very structures of genocide and imperialism that
they claim to oppose. Their comfort is purchased at the expense of the
oppressed. A clear choice now confronts the Western left: either rise to
the challenge to fight back the tide of repression, or continue in silence
at the service of genocide.

But I will not be silenced. I am proud to have used my voice and my pen to
support the struggle for Palestinian liberation. They may strip me of my
rights and privileges, but my commitment to a free Palestine and to the
complete dismantling of U.S. imperialism across the world is not contingent
on institutional recognition or material stability. It is rooted in the
collective struggle of the oppressed but powerful, in the ongoing
anti-colonial struggles in our region, and in the certainty that liberation
will come—not through the benevolence of empire under ‘Democrat’ or
‘Republican’  parties that are unified in the genocide of our people, but
through its political defeat.

This is not a display of strength; it is the last refuge of a crumbling
order—an empire in decline, resorting to brute repression to stifle and
crush those who expose its unraveling hegemony.

Living under a fascist dictatorship in the U.S. can feel suffocating,
creating the illusion that we are isolated and outnumbered. But the reality
is the opposite—we stand with the vast majority of the world, from
Palestine to Lebanon, Iran, Yemen, Venezuela, Cuba, Nicaragua, and beyond.
Ours is the struggle of the oppressed but powerful, the wretched of the
Earth.

The relentless campaign to crush Palestinian solidarity through mass
arrests, intimidation, harassment, and censorship has failed. That failure
is why the state now turns to brute force, as seen in the latest escalation
at Columbia, where protestors have been brutally beaten, and Columbia
student Mahmoud Khalil—now a political prisoner—has been forcibly abducted
by the state in collaboration with the university. I stand in full
solidarity with Mahmoud Khalil. This is a flagrant violation of the most
basic constitutional rights, marking yet another step in the United States’
descent into lawless tyranny.

The Israeli settler colonial regime is suffering a profound crisis. The
defeat of its propaganda machine—so vital to its survival—has been
accelerated by its defeat on the ground in Gaza. The empire cannot sustain
itself without intellectual and institutional support, and thus, the
suppression I, and many others in the U.S. academia and beyond, have been
subjected to is not incidental; it is structural. The U.S. government,
reconfigured into a fascist security apparatus, is not merely suppressing
dissent—it is preparing for war, both abroad and at home. Elite
institutions and universities, tasked with reproducing this system and
training the next generation to defend and sustain it, have transformed
into surveillance mechanisms, ensuring that voices of resistance are
eradicated to enable the atrocities committed abroad. But the university is
not just a site of repression—it is a site of struggle. We must recognize
it as such and rise to reclaim power over these institutions or, where
necessary, dismantle and disrupt them. The time for passive critique has
long passed; we must act collectively to expose, challenge, and resist the
role of Western academia in upholding empire and genocide.
*Call to Action*

Yale Law School must be held accountable. I call for an immediate and
effective boycott of Yale Law School, and a collective demand for Yale’s
full disclosure and divestment from genocide. Furthermore, Yale must take
concrete and effective measures to rectify the harm it has inflicted upon
me, and be held responsible for the damages it has caused; and make a
statement publicly restoring my reputation.

Not a single professor at Yale has stood up to publicly oppose what Yale
has done to me so far. Across the country, academics and university
administrators–with some honorable exceptions–have played a cowardly and
collaborationist role in facilitating the attack on democratic rights.
Those who are too concerned with their salaries and careers to stand up
against the unprecedented attack on free speech are complicit in their own
subjugation and the erosion of the community’s collective strength. I call
on every professor, scholar, researcher, student, and member of the
community to stand up and speak out publicly against Yale Law School
operating as an extension of the fascist state apparatus.

I will not be intimidated. I will not retreat. I remain steadfast in my
commitment to the liberation of our peoples from US imperialism, to
justice, to truth, and to the unbreakable solidarity that binds us in the
struggle for a *Free Palestine.*

Onwards, whatever it takes,
Helyeh Doutaghi

*My lawyer, Eric Lee, issues the following statement:*

I was retained by Dr. Doutaghi in the late morning of March 4. At roughly
2:30 pm that afternoon, I received an email from Yale’s office of general
counsel linking to the “Jewish Onliner” article and indicating that Dr.
Doutaghi was being investigated as a result of that article. I was then
contacted by Yale’s outside counsel who insisted that Dr. Doutaghi agree to
an interview that same afternoon. I asked for a discussion with outside
counsel and we spoke at 4 pm. I inquired as to what procedures would be in
place for the interview and explained that due to previously planned
meetings I would not be able to participate in an interview that same
afternoon. Outside counsel asked me to send an email proposing next steps,
which I did at 5:30, roughly one hour after our phone call ended. In that
email I indicated that we were requesting a brief religious accommodation
due to the fact that Dr. Doutaghi had been fasting for Ramadan while
enduring intense harassment and violence online, and would be better
prepared to discuss next steps the following day after Dr. Doutaghi
received a good night’s sleep. At the same time I sent this email, I
received an email from Yale’s office of general counsel indicating Dr.
Doutaghi was placed on administrative leave for allegedly failing to
respond to the interview request.

After a Google search of “Jewish Onliner,” we learned that in January 2025,
the Israeli newspaper *Haaretz* had investigated and exposed “Jewish
Onliner” as a type of AI-generated bot that spreads misinformation to
counter pro-Palestinian speech online. *Haaretz *also indicated that the
bot may have ties to the Israeli government and military. In light of this
information, I wrote Yale on March 5 asking (1) whether they were aware of
the illegitimacy of the source, (2) if not, whether they had taken any
steps to determine the legitimacy of the source before rushing to judgment
against Dr. Doutaghi, and (3) whether the rush to force Dr. Doutaghi into
an immediate interview was aimed at preventing us from having time to
investigate the legitimacy of the source. Yale declined to answer these
questions.

Yale is bending the knee to Trump’s effort to suppress free speech, crush
academic freedom and establish a dictatorship. Whether he succeeds will
depend entirely on the response of the population. We urge everyone to
stand up and come to the defense of Dr. Doutaghi and the democratic
principles of free speech and due process which are fundamental to us all.
We repeat our demand that Yale reinstate Dr. Doutaghi, give her access to
campus and email, and take public action to restore her credibility and
reputation.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20250313/85d7e5d1/attachment-0001.htm>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: Yale_Law_School_Courtyard-1024x768.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 220557 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20250313/85d7e5d1/attachment-0001.jpg>