[News] The Israeli Victim Narrative About October 7 Is Based On Western Double-Standards

[Anti-Imperialist News]

english.almayadeen.net
<https://english.almayadeen.net/articles/analysis/the-israeli-victim-narrative-about-october-7-is-based-on-wes>
The Israeli Victim Narrative About October 7 Is Based On Western
Double-Standards
Robert Inlakesh - October 25, 2023
------------------------------

For all those condemning the Gazans for rising up, they first must look at
themselves in the mirror and ask what they did when the people were being
forced into using violence as the obvious last option available to them.
[image: fcfe16cd-7196-4468-8460-44a62fee97f0.png]

   - The Israeli regime itself is not the victim, it is the cause of the
   violence, while unarmed civilians are simply those who are caught in
   between. (illustrated by: Hady Dbouk, Al Mayadeen English)

The Israeli regime was not the victim on October 7. The Hamas offensive
bears no resemblance to the September 11 attacks of 2001 and the
Palestinian resistance has nothing in common with Daesh or other takfiri
terrorists. The only thing that was out of the ordinary for the conflict in
Palestine on October 7, was that for once the fight was taken to the
Israelis and instead of it being dead Palestinians, it was dead Israeli
soldiers and settlers.

In Western media, the Hamas offensive of October 7 is being depicted as the
single worst event in the history of the Palestine-Zionist conflict, an
attack comparable to the 9/11 bombings and hence a justification for the
complete annihilation of the Palestinian people as a result. This is
because they have been fed the narrative that Hamas fighters, belonging to
the movement's armed wing, the Qassam Brigades, stormed over a “border
fence” and launched a devastating attack on Israeli unarmed civilians.

According to Western media, the Hamas attack is where the war started, the
attack on Israelis was unique and therefore it justifies a racist
annihilation of the indigenous population of Palestine. Israel, with the
full backing of Western media and politicians, have managed to concoct a
narrative that mimics the post 9/11 narrative, one that depicts
Palestinians are barbaric Muslim extremists that rape white women and
behead babies. But, unfortunately for them, despite this working on older
portions of the population, the younger generations are not falling for it,
because they can see through the double-standards and racist rhetoric that
their parents fell for in the lead up to the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
The Attack Was Only Unique In One Way

Operation Al-Aqsa Flood, as declared by al-Qassam Brigades’ Commander
Mohammed Deif, was a retaliatory offensive that Hamas and the some dozen
Palestinian political factions had warned was coming if the Zionist regime
continued its attacks on worshippers at the Aqsa Mosque. In 2021, Hamas
also launched an offensive, named the Sword of Jerusalem, in response to
similar Israeli attacks against Palestinian worshippers during the Holy
month of Ramadan. The 11-day war in May of 2021 resulted in the murder of
at least 285 Palestinians, while 13 Israelis were also killed. Since then,
"Israel" continued, in 2022 and this year, to violently assault worshippers
at al-Aqsa Mosque, with extremists inside the Zionist Knesset also
discussing proposals to change the status quo at the third holiest site in
the Islamic faith.

In August of 2022, “Israel” launched an unprovoked attack on the
Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ) movement inside the Gaza Strip, killing 50
Palestinians - most of whom were civilians - while no Israelis were killed.
Then in May of this year, "Israel" launched another unprovoked attack that
targeted PIJ, along with civilians, which resulted in around 35
Palestinians being murdered. In the West Bank, Israeli forces have been
invading refugee camps and cities non-stop since the beginning of the year,
murdering hundreds of Palestinians. In early July the Israeli military
invaded the Jenin refugee camp, targeting medical workers, and journalists
and destroying the civilian infrastructure there while killing at least 18
Palestinians, before they ran away out of fear after suffering soldier
casualties.

To go through the record of massacres committed against the Palestinian
people would require a whole book to be written, however, for the sake of
time, consider the following examples: In 2008/9 the Israeli attack on Gaza
massacred around 1,417 Palestinians, during the 2014 war there were over
2,300 Palestinians murdered by "Israel’s" offensive, then, to throw in one
of many historical massacres, when "Israel" invaded Lebanon and later
occupied the south of it in 1982, the Zionist military’s offensive resulted
in roughly 20,000 dead Palestinians and Lebanese. All of these examples
noted are worse, statistically, than the offensive of Hamas on October 7,
2023. As for such death in a short period of time, this isn’t even
comparable, take the opening strikes launched on Gaza in 2008, which
targeted a police ceremony, killing over 251 non-combatants within seconds.

In 2018, beginning on March 30, the Palestinian people in Gaza launched one
of the largest non-violent protest movements in history along the Gaza
separation fence, calling for the lifting of the blockade. Israel responded
by killing 300 Palestinians over the course of the demonstrations that
lasted over a year, targeting men, women, children, the elderly,
journalists, medical workers, and people with disabilities. What was the
international response to this? To condemn Hamas and claim that “Israel has
the right to defend itself”. All of what is being mentioned only scratches
the surface of the horror inflicted upon the Palestinian people, not even
touching on the ethnic cleansing of 1947-9 and the countless wars of
aggression, coupled with the illegal occupation of Palestinian lands since.

To suggest that what happened on October 7, is somehow a “unique evil” is
to either say that you value Western/Jewish lives more than Arab lives, or
it comes from a place of pure ignorance.
An Attack On “Israel”

Often we hear of “Israel’s right to defend itself” and that “Israel’s
border was breached”, on October 7. To begin with, under international law,
the Zionist regime is an occupying power in the Eastern part of Al-Quds,
the Gaza Strip, and the West Bank, meaning that they have an obligation to
provide the means for civilians' human rights to be protected; they have
never lived up to the international standards. "Israel", being an occupying
power, also means that under the Fourth Geneva Convention, the people under
its occupation have the right to use violence in order to free themselves
from the rule of that occupying power. As the occupier, dubbed an Apartheid
regime by the world's top human rights organizations, the Israelis have no
right to defend the continuation of their military occupation, none.

Also, there is no border between “Israel” and Gaza, and there are armistice
lines where there is a militarized separation barrier, but there is no
border, this is an outright lie. Gaza is not a separate country. This
territory has been labeled by UN experts as unlivable since 2020 when 97%
of the water was already undrinkable for years prior to the beginning of
the war when the Zionist entity cut off the water.

Another thing we have to look at critically here is the true nature of the
Hamas-led offensive against the Israeli military and settlements
surrounding Gaza. Yes, the offensive initially targeted military sites and
resulted in the killing of at least 300+ Israeli soldiers, in addition to
other kinds of armed Israeli combatants, so when you see the Israeli death
toll, this must also be kept in mind. The second issue with the narrative
in Western media about the death toll is the immediate assumption of guilt
when allegations are made towards the Palestinian armed groups;
specifically the Qassam brigades of Hamas.

Often, Western media will cite the need for investigations into allegations
of war crimes committed in Gaza, but then it will instantly assume war
crimes were committed against unarmed Israelis. There must be one rule for
all, if we can’t decide what is going on in Gaza, then we certainly can’t
make a judgment on what happened on October 7 to the Israelis, especially
since the information from the Israeli side is heavily restricted. There is
no consideration to the fact that there were armed clashes between Israeli
forces and the Palestinian armed groups inside the settlements, which we
have video evidence documenting. These clashes, which we have film showing
unarmed Israelis in the middle of, could well have meant that Israeli armed
gunmen accidentally shot their own citizens, we also have testimonies of
Israelis who were held hostage and testified to having witnessed Israeli
forces killing unarmed hostages.

Until there are human rights reports and independent inquiries, we simply
cannot know exactly what happened on the Israeli side, especially
considering all of the unsubstantiated reports spread about rape and
beheaded babies. On top of this, it wasn’t just Hamas fighters that crossed
the separation fence, fighters from various smaller armed groups engaged in
the fighting, while even Palestinians who were from no group at all crossed
over. So telling who shot who and what unarmed civilians were killed, and
under which circumstances, is going to require further investigation, in
the cases where we do not have any video evidence. What happened to the
Israelis on that day, is a more complex picture than when the Zionists fire
missiles into civilian neighborhoods.

None of the above is written to justify any killing of unarmed people, but
it works to put what happened into perspective. They live in settlements,
on top of the villages that Zionist militias ethnically cleansed, the
descendants of those who were expelled by force are now making up the
majority of those Palestinian fighters from Gaza. Gaza’s armed groups are a
refugee resistance, many of whom joined the resistance forces following the
murder of family members at the hands of the Israeli military. They lost
their lands, their family members, their friends, their homes, their
livelihoods and there was not a single hope for anyone to help them, so
they decided to take matters into their own hands, to free their people, to
create a new life for the following generations. Hamas is a product of
Israeli occupation, violence and Apartheid. They are a national liberation
movement, they do not seek to kill disbelievers in their brand of religious
dogma in order to force the world to fall under their rule like Daesh
terrorists do, they simply want to reclaim their lands. This does not mean
you have to agree with their ideology or their violent tactics, but to
ignore why they exist, why they have support throughout the Arab and Muslim
World, and why they launched this attack, is simply choosing to remain
ignorant. The same was the case for the ANC in its fight against Apartheid
in South Africa, which most of the world now understands today.

The Palestinian people were led by secular-nationalist armed movements,
along with secular-Marxist movements, for the majority of the history of
the struggle against the Zionist entity. There is no equivalence to be made
between what was essentially a modern-day slave revolt, from Gaza, and a
senseless terrorist attack. In all successful revolts against colonial
rule, European invaders, settler-colonialism, and slave masters, there have
been unarmed people killed as a result of these uprisings, this is what
happens when you murder, dispossess, and humiliate an entire people just
because of their ethnicity/race. Eventually, the people who are persecuted
by violent racist oppressors, will rise up and attempt to break their
chains. For all those condemning the Gazans for rising up, they first must
look at themselves in the mirror and ask what they did when the people were
being forced into using violence as the obvious last option available to
them. The Israeli regime itself is not the victim, it is the cause of the
violence, while unarmed civilians are simply those who are caught in
between.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20231024/942c25ec/attachment-0001.htm>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: fcfe16cd-7196-4468-8460-44a62fee97f0.png
Type: image/png
Size: 417740 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20231024/942c25ec/attachment-0001.png>