[News] Judea vs ‘Fantasy Israel: Ilan Pappe on the Collapse of Israeli Pillars and Opportunities for Palestine

[Anti-Imperialist News]

palestinechronicle.com
<https://www.palestinechronicle.com/judea-vs-fantasy-israel-ilan-pappe-on-the-collapse-of-israeli-pillars-and-opportunities-for-palestine/>
Judea vs ‘Fantasy Israel: Ilan Pappe on the Collapse of Israeli Pillars and
Opportunities for PalestineJuly 31, 2023
------------------------------
Israel's so-called Flag March. (Photo: Nettadi, via Wikimedia Commons)

*By Ilan Pappe <https://www.palestinechronicle.com/writers/ilan-pappe>*

The future liberated and de-Zionised Palestine may look now as a fantasy,
but unlike Fantasy Israel, it has the best chance to galvanize locally,
regionally and globally every person with a modicum of decency.

Israel’s legitimacy, in fact, its very viability, rests on two main pillars.

First, the material pillar, which includes its military strength, high-tech
capabilities, and a solid economic system.

The above factors enable the state to build a strong network of alliances
with countries that would like to benefit from what Israel has to offer:
arms, securitization, spyware, high-tech knowledge, and modernized systems
of agricultural production.

In return, Israel does not just ask for money but also for support against
its eroded international image.

Second, the moral pillar. This aspect was particularly important in the
early days of the Zionist project and statehood.

Israel sold to the world a twofold narrative: One, that Israel’s creation
was the only panacea for antisemitism, and two, that Israel was built in a
place that religiously and culturally belonged to the Jewish people.

The presence of an indigenous population, the Palestinian people, was
initially denied altogether; then, it was dwarfed. And when the existence
of the Palestinians was finally acknowledged, it was presented as an
unfortunate coincidence.

Then, Israel, the self-declared ‘only democracy in the Middle East’,
branded itself a generous peacemaker who is willing to resolve the problem
by offering ‘concessions’ over its supposed right to the whole of
historical Palestine.
Collapse of ‘Morality’

It is hard to pinpoint exactly when the moral pillar upon which Israel was
sustained began eroding, to the extent that it is now crumbling before our
very eyes.

Some would say that the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982 started this
process of erosion, while others look at the First Palestinian Intifada in
1987 as the transformative moment. Either way, Israel’s image within world
public opinion has been changing for decades.

But what is often ignored is that, had it not been for Palestinian
resistance and resilience, the legitimacy and morality of the Jewish state
would have not been put to a test, where it is now being constantly
examined against international law, common sense, and ethical behavior.

I would argue that as early as 1948 – when Israel was declared a state atop
the ruins of historic Palestine –  the facts on the ground became known to
more and more people around the world. This has been a direct outcome of
the efforts made by the Palestinians and their ever-growing solidarity
networks.

Israel’s image – whether internally or internationally – as a democratic
state and a member of the ‘civilized nations’ didn’t seem to match the new
information. Increasingly, the so-called Israeli democracy was exposed as
an apartheid regime, abusing Palestinian civil and human rights on a daily
basis.

Still, the exposure of the true nature of Israel, and widespread public
rejection of the Israeli narrative, did not seem to register among ruling
political elites and governments around the world, whose attitude towards
Israel remained largely unchanged.

On the contrary, governments in the global north are the ones leading the
charge against the various solidarity movements with the Palestinians. They
seem determined to suppress the freedom of speech of their own societies by
legislating against civil initiatives which call for boycotting,
sanctioning and divesting from Tel Aviv.

The global south is not much better, where governments and rulers ignore
the demand of their societies to take a firm stand against Israel. This
includes Arab regimes, who are queuing to normalize their diplomatic ties
with Tel Aviv.

Until the latest November 2022 elections in Israel, it seemed that
international silence and/or complicity had protected Israel from
translating the shift in public opinion into concrete actions. The evidence
for this was that the brave and truly impressive work of movements such as
the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions Movement (BDS) has not influenced the
reality on the ground even a bit.

Until November 2022, I assumed that the inability to translate public
opinion into tangible politics was a result of the cynicism of our
political systems all over the world. Now, however, I truly believe that
only a change in the way politics from above are conducted will translate
the incredible solidarity with the Palestinians into a formative power on
the ground.

When Israel offered Germany missiles worth 4 billion euros and offered The
Netherlands another kind of missile worth 300 million euros (to protect
them from what, exactly?), political commentators in Israel argued that
such weapons would serve as the best antidote against what they called the
campaign to delegitimize Israel.

The Israeli media was actually proud to announce that arms allow the
country to buy silence from Europe so that any words of condemnation of the
atrocities Israeli soldiers and settlers commit in Palestine are not
translated into action.
‘Fantasy Israel’ vs Judea

Yet, there is more. A certain Jewish electorate inside Israel even deceived
itself – in fact, they still do – in believing that the West supports
Israel because it adheres to a Western “value system” based on democracy
and liberalism.

I call this construct ‘Fantasy Israel’.

In November 2022, Fantasy Israel collapsed for all intents and purposes.

The Israeli Jewish electorate, which won the election, never had much
admiration for Western “value systems” of democracy and liberalism.

On the contrary, it wishes to live in a more theocratic, nationalist,
racist and even fascist Jewish state; one that stretches all over
historical Palestine, including the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

The Israelis call this alternative idea of the state, ‘Judea’, which is now
at war with Fantasy Israel.

The people of Judea do not care about international legitimacy. Their
leaders and gurus are highly impressed by Israel’s new allies in the world,
be they the leaders of the far-right parties in the West or far-right
movements in countries like India.

These nationalist and fascist leaders seem to admire the state of Judea and
are willing to provide it with an international network of support. This
has already translated into policy in countries where the extreme right is
very powerful, such as Italy, Hungary, Poland, Greece, Sweden, Spain and,
if Trump’s re-wins, then also the United States.

On the surface, it looked like a very gloomy scenario had unfolded in
November 2022.

This, however, is not entirely true.

The failure of Fantasy Israel has exposed an intriguing nexus between the
moral and material pillars.

It transpired that the neo-liberal, capitalist system has no reason to
invest in the state of Judea if indeed it replaces Fantasy Israel. The
international financial corporations and the international high-tech
industry regard states such as Judea as unstable and risky destinations for
foreign investment.

In fact, they are already pulling their funds and investments away from
Israel. The BDS movement would have to work very hard to convince unions
and churches around the world to divest from Israel billions of dollars in
order to match the funds that have already been taken outside Israel since
November 2022.

This type of divestment is not morally driven. In the past, Israel has
served as an attractive destination for international financial investment
regardless of its ruthless oppression of the Palestinians.

But it seems that the image of Fantasy Israel, and in particular the notion
that its judicial system was able to protect neoliberal and capitalist
investments, persuaded foreign investors to pour money into Israel with the
anticipation of good dividends in return.

Now, the prospects of the state of Judea replacing Fantasy Israel is
seriously affecting the economic viability of the Jewish state. Therefore,
the ability of Israel to use its industry or money to influence other
countries’ policies towards the Jewish State is more limited.
Time for Mobilization

The collapse of Fantasy Israel has also exposed cracks in the social
cohesion, and in the readiness of many Israelis to devote as much time and
energy to military service as they did in the past.

Moreover, the attack on the Israeli judicial system and the erosion of its
alleged independence will expose Israeli soldiers and pilots to possible
indictments as war criminals abroad by individual countries or by the
International Court of Justice (ICC). Indeed, international law cannot
intervene in domestic issues if the local judicial systems are considered
independent and solid.

This is a rare moment in history that opens opportunities for those
struggling for liberation and justice in Palestine.

In a meeting in Tehran, Iran advised the Palestinian movement Hamas and the
Lebanese movement Hezbollah to refrain from any action and allow an
implosion to take part from within Israel.

I disagree, though I don’t mean that there is, or ever was, a military
possibility to liberate Palestine. However, this is a time to energize the
popular Palestinian resistance and unite both the Palestinians and their
supporters around an agreed vision and program. This mobilization is rooted
in the Palestinian national struggle for democracy and self-determination
ever since 1918.

The future liberated and de-Zionised Palestine may look now as a fantasy,
but unlike Fantasy Israel, it has the best chance to galvanize locally,
regionally and globally every person with a modicum of decency. It would
also provide a safe place for anyone living in historical Palestine at the
present or for whoever was expelled from there – Palestinian refugees
around the world.


*- Ilan Pappé is a professor at the University of Exeter. He was formerly a
senior lecturer in political science at the University of Haifa. He is the
author of The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine, The Modern Middle East, A
History of Modern Palestine: One Land, Two Peoples, and Ten Myths about
Israel. Pappé is described as one of Israel’s 'New Historians' who, since
the release of pertinent British and Israeli government documents in the
early 1980s, have been rewriting the history of Israel’s creation in 1948.
He contributed this article to The Palestine Chronicle.*
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20230731/25c287f2/attachment.htm>