[News] The Long Haitian Revolution

Anti-Imperialist News news at freedomarchives.org
Mon Oct 4 21:15:49 EDT 2021

<https://monthlyreview.org/2021/10/01/the-long-haitian-revolution/> Monthly
Review | The Long Haitian Revolution
*by* Pierre Labossiere <https://monthlyreview.org/author/pierrelabossiere/>,
Margaret Prescod <https://monthlyreview.org/author/margaretprescod/> and Camila
Valle <https://monthlyreview.org/author/camilavalle/>
 October 1, 2021

Dear Reader, we make this and other articles available for free online to
serve those unable to afford or access the print edition of *Monthly Review*.
If you read the magazine online and can afford a print subscription, we
hope you will consider purchasing one. Please visit the MR store for
subscription options <https://monthlyreview.org/press/subscriptions/>.
Thank you very much.

New this week!

[image: Battle for Palm Tree Hill]

"Battle of San Domingo," also known as the "Battle for Palm Tree Hill."
Credit: January Suchodolski
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/en:January_Suchodolski>, Public Domain, Link

Pierre Labossiere is cofounder of the Haiti Action Committee and is on the
board of the Haiti Emergency Relief Fund. Margaret Prescod is part of the
Haiti working group of the Global Women’s Strike and cofounder of Black
Women for Wages for Housework. She is the host of “Sojourner Truth,” on
Pacifica Radio, which regularly covers Haiti. Camila Valle is an editor,
translator, and writer in New York. She is assistant editor of *Monthly

They would like to thank Selma James for helping to coordinate the

“When history is written as it ought to be written, it is the moderation
and long patience of the masses at which men will wonder, not their

—C. L. R. James, *The Black Jacobins*

“The Haitian movement, though the most pivotal to the abolition of slavery
in the Americas, is the most neglected—we all owe a great debt to Haitians
and must pay it.”

—Margaret Prescod, introduction to Selma James’s *Our Time Is Now*

On July 7, 2021, the illegitimate president of Haiti Jovenel Moïse, who had
led Haiti since 2017, was assassinated in an attack on his home in the
outskirts of Port-au-Prince. Before his death, despite his term officially
ending on February 7, 2021, Moïse was holding onto power, with support from
death squads on the ground as well as the Joe Biden administration (a
continuation of the Donald Trump administration policy) and United Nations.
For months, Haitians came out in large protests demanding Moïse step down.
At the same time, the Biden administration continued and continues to
deport Haitians at alarming rates.

Ariel Henry was sworn in as the acting president of Haiti on July 20, 2021,
having been chosen as the next prime minister by Moïse shortly before his
assassination. The Core Group—made up of ambassadors from the United
States, France, Canada, Germany, Brazil, Spain, the European Union, and
representatives from the United Nations and Organization of American
States—have put out a statement throwing their support behind Henry.

Haitian authorities arrested the head of Moïse’s security team as part of
its probe into the assassination and issued an arrest warrant for Supreme
Court Justice Windelle Coq Thélot. Colombian mercenaries have also been
linked to the assassination, with the Pentagon confirming that four of the
accused mercenaries had received U.S. military training at Fort Benning in
Georgia. Formerly known as the School of the Americas (dubbed by critics
the “School of the Assassins”), the Western Hemisphere Institute for
Security Cooperation at Fort Benning has been used for decades to train
Latin American soldiers in combat, counterinsurgency, and counternarcotics.
Since then, the judge presiding over the investigation of the assassination
quit because one of the court clerks was also found dead.

On August 14, 2021, a devastating 7.2 magnitude earthquake hit Haiti. At
the time of writing, the death toll has risen to around 2,200, more than
12,000 people have been injured, and over 7,000 homes have been destroyed.
Many hospitals have also been damaged, with ones still operating reporting
overcapacity of patients and shortages of medical supplies. Two days after
the quake, Tropical Storm Grace swept into Haiti, bringing heavy rain and

Camila Valle: Thank you both for joining me to talk about what is happening
in Haiti. A lot has transpired: Jovenel Moïse’s refusal to step down, his
subsequent assassination, Ariel Henry’s swearing in as the new prime
minister, the death squads on the ground, the earthquake, the tropical
storm, and of course the subjection of Haiti to imperialist entities
(mainly the United States, United Nations, and Organization of American
States [OAS]). Before we get into all this, could you talk about the
historical roots of the current conjuncture?

Pierre Labossiere: The first thing to say is that the current situation has
roots in the historical struggle of the people of Haiti, a people whose
foremothers and forefathers were kidnapped from Africa and brought to this
land to work as beasts of burden, to make fortunes for people who kept them
as enslaved labor. They fought against slavery and successfully defeated it
in 1791, founding the independent nation of Haiti on January 1, 1804. But
the struggles for our liberation have not stopped, because Haiti was this
odd country founded by enslaved people. It established itself as a free
nation dedicated to the abolition of slavery; it declared itself a
sanctuary country for oppressed people, particularly enslaved Africans and
Indigenous people. They could come to Haiti to be recognized as citizens
and their freedom defended. This is the background.

But the slavocracy, the slave empires—we are talking France, Britain,
Spain, later the emerging nation of the United States, which had Africans
working as enslaved labor—wanted to destroy this example of freedom and
successful revolution. Since that time, Haiti has been in the throes of
this struggle, which has impacted the people inside Haiti. What these
nations did was foment and put in power people and governments that would
become enemies of the mass Haitian population, as they tried to establish
the old colonial system of exploitation of the majority for the enrichment
of the few. So the people of Haiti have continuously struggled against this
colonial view and system of exploitation. We are seeing a continuation of
this today.

There was a turning point in 1915, when the U.S. government invaded Haiti.
At the time, the people’s struggle in Haiti was about to take power,
because peasants’ land had been taken and was being given to foreign
entities, particularly from the United States, and the people of Haiti
said, “No, we are not going to tolerate that.” There was a massive uprising
and the U.S. Marines came in, on the side of the Haitian elite and their
foreign allies, to “restore” the country and prevent the people’s movement
from taking power. Since then, the United States has become the dominant
decider in Haiti’s daily affairs, and we have been struggling against this
U.S. domination, our primary domination. In recent times, François “Papa
Doc” Duvalier and his son Jean-Claude “Baby Doc” Duvalier were the most
brutal expressions of this class struggle, this class warfare being
organized against the people in order to maintain the old colonial system
of exploitation intact.

In 1986, people rebelled, successfully overthrowing Duvalier, but the
United States has since continued to try to bring back the Duvalierist
forces and keep them in power. After Duvalier fled, we had four years of
the Duvalierist military-dominated government, which was extremely brutal
in its repression. In 1990, the people elected Jean-Bertrand Aristide, the
parish priest who was a leader of the new movement for liberation. He was
the first democratically elected president of Haiti and lasted only seven
months in power. On September 30, 1991, there was a coup organized by the
United States and carried out by the Haitian military. Over five thousand
people were massacred, there was massive resistance by the population with
international solidarity, and President Aristide returned two years later
to complete his term in office. René Préval was elected in 1996, in the
first free transition of power from one elected government to another, but
the United States continued to undermine the democratic process.

I have to note that, in 1987, even at the height of the military
dictatorship, the people of Haiti successfully drafted a new constitution
based on popular participation and voted overwhelmingly for it, enshrining
the many gains of the democratic movement. Of course, the constitution was
never respected by the military, the Duvalierists, or the United States. In
2000, there were democratic elections and President Aristide was elected
for his second term in a landslide victory. But the United States mobilized
its forces and massively undermined the march for democracy, the
implementation of democratic rule in Haiti. In 2004, the U.S. government
under George W. Bush carried out the second coup (George H. W. Bush was
responsible for the first in 1991), leading to the killing of close to ten
thousand people by right-wing forces—the old Haitian military forces that
President Aristide had disbanded, coupled with various mercenaries and
killers from Haiti, including the death squad Front for the Advancement and
Progress of Haiti, similar to the Tonton Macoutes, the henchmen of Papa Doc
and Baby Doc Duvalier. They actually were not able to carry out the coup
d’état, so the special forces of the United States, France, and Canada came
in and overthrew and kidnapped President Aristide. But the Haitian people
never accepted this coup d’état and resistance has continued to this day.

Since then, Haiti has been under occupation by the United States, France,
and Canada, but using the United Nations as a cover to make it acceptable
and palatable to the rest of the world. UN forces have really been carrying
out U.S. foreign policy; they have massacred people in poor neighborhoods
and various communities throughout Haiti, because they have kept up the
demonstrations against the rotten system of exploitation, demanding their
democratic rights and that the people they elected be returned to office.
So they are being massacred.

The Tonton Macoutes, which the governments of Papa Doc and Baby Doc had set
up, are brutal death squads that have continuously been on the scene, even
under different names. One name was the Front for the Advancement and
Progress of Haiti, during the first coup. Now they are known as “gangs,”
but this is just a way to throw people off. When people hear “gangs,” they
think these are forces opposed to the government, but this is not true.
These are government-paid groups of killers, death squads that are working
with the government. In October, even the office of the secretary general
of the United Nations, António Guterres, made a statement praising Jimmy
“Barbecue” Cherizier, who is a brutal killer, one of the most notorious
death squad leaders. He actually formed the federation of the so-called
gangs of the death squads, G9 Family and Allies. That federation was
organized by the Haitian government, which paid them millions of dollars
under the cover of so-called disarmament. It was really a way to provide
them with money and more ammunition so they could kill people, create a
campaign of terror throughout Haiti, and operate these massacres today.
Before, at the beginning of the coup of 2004–05, UN troops carried out a
number of massacres—I can think of at least four off the top of my head.
Now, it is not really UN troops or the Haitian police. It has been passed
onto the G9 Family and Allies and the death squads, in what has been
presented to the world as gang warfare. But everybody in Haiti knows that
is not true.

Margaret Prescod: I’m Bajan [from Barbados], and Haiti has always been
important to us in the Caribbean region. The Haitian Revolution happened
decades before the Emancipation Proclamation in the United States, and
there was great fear that what happened in Haiti would happen in other
slaveholding countries in the Americas. Indeed, in Barbados for example,
the great Bussa’s Rebellion of 1816 was definitely inspired by the Haitian
Revolution. If you look throughout history, practically all of those
islands of the Caribbean, from Granada to St. Vincent, had uprisings—some
greater, some smaller, but all very much inspired by the Haitian
Revolution. Some of the people who took part in and helped organize what is
considered to be the largest slave revolt in the United States, the 1811
revolt in Louisiana, were Haitians brought over by their slave masters when
they fled Haiti after the revolution. The Haitians who were brought over
immediately started mobilizing and organizing with other enslaved people in
the United States, which was quite remarkable given the differences in
language and so on. I say this also because the huge expansion of the
United States as a result of the Louisiana Purchase was really due to the
Haitian Revolution forcing France to leave the territory.

In that same period, Haiti offered enormous assistance to Simón Bolívar,
the liberator of Latin America, who twice had to flee for his life. He fled
to Haiti post-revolution, where he was given refuge, and Haitians sent him
back with fighters, weapons, and resources. Today, there is even a place in
Caracas where Haitians died fighting for the liberation of Latin America.
It was a huge international event. And this is part of the price Haitians
have paid ever since. Some of this story is told in C. L. R. James’s *The
Black Jacobins*.

Folks know that if you really want to kill people and brutalize people, you
first dehumanize them, and there has been such a dehumanization of Haitians
in particular. It is the thread of the devaluation of Black lives, going
back to slavery and the creation of race in a lot of ways. When I go to
Haiti, I see the level of poverty, the level of dehumanization of people,
the stark class divide between the Haitian majority—the grassroots people,
a lot of them dark-skinned Black people—and the elite. One of the most
recent times I visited Haiti, I was there with a television program trying
to get the story after the Lasalin massacre, orchestrated by Barbecue.
Barbecue Cherizier is now being put forward as some kind of revolutionary.
What ordinary Haitians described to me, the way the killings were carried
out, the way these death squads operate—it is sheer *inhumanity*. It was
not just killing people, but burning them alive, chopping them up. They
took me to the body of a pregnant woman who was burned alive, it was still
there. It is just a level of brutality that is tied to the absolute
dehumanization of the Haitian people. It sends a clear message: either you
toe the line, you do what we want, what is in the best interests of the
powers that be, or this could happen to you too. Haitians are used as
examples to other peoples; the threat that if you dare rise up, this is
what can happen to you.

CV: You have both touched on the evolution of the imperialism Haiti has
suffered as endless retribution for its revolution. There are, perhaps,
more overt expressions of this, such as coups against democratically
elected leaders, dictatorships, and occupations, but there is also a more
“palatable” kind of imperialism Haiti is subjected to by global
institutions and organizations that are dominated by the West, the United
States in particular, that give a facade of “neutrality.” You have the
United Nations, World Bank, International Monetary Fund, the NGOs, and so
on, that play an occupying and policing role, that murder and rape, that
impose debt and austerity, and that even bring in things like the cholera
epidemic. For example, Haiti is often talked about as a main target of “aid
tourism” or as a “republic of NGOs.” Could you say more about this?

PL: I must start with the question of debt. Haiti was forced to pay France
the equivalent of $21.7 billion in exchange for the recognition of Haiti’s
independence. Haiti was one of the first nations to arrive in the
postcolonial period and it was immediately saddled with debt and paying
reparations. The connection is very clear. It basically set the stage for
the question: How come all the former colonies are the ones that all of a
sudden owe all this money to their former colonizers? It should be the
other way around! Back in 2003, President Aristide called for restitution
and reparation. Restitution referred to the restoration of the money it had
been established that Haiti had paid, plus reparations for the crimes of
slavery, even though the French government passed a law recognizing the
slave trade and slavery as crimes against humanity. France essentially
participated in the 2004 coup so they wouldn’t have to pay.

After the revolution, Haiti was a tiny little island in the Caribbean,
completely surrounded by the empires of the time, which enslaved Africans
just like Haiti had under French colonialism. France threatened to bombard
Haiti if it didn’t pay the money back. There was an immediate threat also
of the re-enslavement of our people. France was aided in this by the United
States, which at the time was a young emerging nation but very much engaged
in the slave trade, as well as Britain, Spain, and other European
countries. Haiti was forced to pay the money, first to France, and then to
the United States when it took over in 1915. We started paying the debt to
the United States, with the payments only ending in 1947.

The Haitian government, after the revolution, during which it was under
direct compulsion to varying degrees from the great powers, leading up to
the twentieth century U.S. invasion and occupation, was very similar to the
present-day lackey governments of foreign powers. The great powers managed
successfully to use the local elite to set up a lackey government that went
against the wishes of the people, who wanted to fight, to resist. That
really started the impoverishment. Money that should have been invested in
building the country’s infrastructure, building schools, roads, irrigation
canals, supporting our local economy, supporting the development of the
country, was all going to France instead. Actually, a lot of the
modernization of Paris is linked to the money Haiti had been paying France.
Mind you, this money was not being paid by the Haitian elite or the
companies operating in Haiti exploiting our people. It was paid by the
labor of the Haitian peasantry, which is still overwhelmingly taxed to the
point where they work but do not benefit from the services their tax money
is supposed to provide. So what you have is the elite, local and foreign,
that is not really paying taxes, and all of this wealth that is being
produced by and taken away from the Haitian peasantry. It is a transfer of
wealth and power very reminiscent of the kind of expropriation during
slavery, the same type of system where the labor of the people was being
extorted and going into the pockets of foreign powers.

Now, the NGOs are a continued exploitation of our people. What we have in
return for all this expropriated wealth is a number of NGOs invading Haiti,
using the misery of our people—in the form of writing beautiful things
abroad, taking photos of starving children, and the like—to ask for money
to line their pockets and not presenting the reality of the situation. So
much so that when the people of Haiti are standing up and fighting for
their liberation, there is complete silence. It is always “all the people
are hungry, they are poor, they don’t have access to medical care,” but
never is the connection made between the exploitation of our people and the
misery to which we are subjected. Never is our resistance front and center.

MP: Haiti is a clear example of what has been called the *NGO industrial
complex*. Haiti has more NGOs per capita than any other country in the
world, yet it remains the most impoverished in the Western hemisphere. NGOs
are also often sexually violent. A few years ago, reports came out of Oxfam
workers raping women and girls in Haiti. It goes back to Haitian people
being seen as lesser than, and a number of NGOs go in with savior complexes
and that kind of missionary attitude of superiority. They treat the people
they are supposedly trying to help in a particular way. Then, of course,
the NGOs also have a particular lifestyle—where they live, the type of
vehicle they drive, and so on—that is far beyond the reach of an average
Haitian person. So you have a whole sector of the population funded by this
NGO money, almost like a particular expat community, that is really outside
of the day-to-day reality of Haitian people. You also saw this after the
2010 earthquake, where you had the largest and major NGOs flooding the
country, collecting massive amounts of money, because I think people in the
United States were shocked when that earthquake happened. A lot of people
had no idea about Haiti before that, so they donated millions and millions
of dollars. What happened to that money? A good question to ask the NGOs.
The Red Cross raised half a billion dollars and only built six homes. Just

As Pierre pointed out, there has been continued resistance since 2000. I
have been in Haiti at various periods from 2000 up to COVID basically, and
you could really see that there was a movement in the streets. In the
United States, the left can get very confused about what is going on in
Haiti. People like to say that it is complex. Well, it is a complex
situation because you have the powers that be, the United States and its
Core Group, running so many operations on the ground, and you have
Haitians, who perhaps are the Haitians who can afford to travel and have
connections and so on, running around to the World Social Forum and places
like that, giving the impression that they are the voice of Haiti and the
movement. But if you scratch the surface of some of these people, you would
see that they were involved, if not directly then indirectly, in the coup
against President Aristide. They tend to surface at particular moments in
the struggle of the Haitian people. They come across with the right
rhetoric or revolutionary language, but people on the ground know very well
who they are and really do not trust them. Rather than supporting the
demands coming from the Haitian grassroots people themselves, they handpick
which demands to support or not, they hand pick their leaders. But they
create a lot of chaos and confusion. To me, this is another level of
imperialism, what I am calling the *solidarity industrial complex*, which
you see really developing, bypassing the Haitian grassroots, propping up a
selective group of people. Selected by whom? Who knows, they meet in the
U.S. embassy privately, they have all kinds of deals and money.

The latest outrage is the outspoken support of Barbecue by a prominent
left-wing journalist who is frequently presented as an expert on Haiti. He
is putting forward that Barbecue is a revolutionary. In Haiti, I took
testimony after testimony of people talking about Barbecue’s connection
with the police (he is an ex-cop himself), about his orchestrating these
death squads, these massacres, and now he is being rehabilitated as some
kind of revolutionary. You see, this is the kind of COINTELPRO operation
that really is insidious, and I do not say that lightly. I do not believe
it is innocent or uncoordinated in some way, because everybody knows—the
Biden administration, the United Nations, and the OAS, which played a slimy
role with Moïse—in contrast to the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) countries
who were opposing what the head of OAS was doing with regard to Haiti. A
well-meaning person could read that and say, “Oh, wow, look at this. You’ve
got this new revolutionary with all this revolutionary rhetoric.” The man
is a mass murderer. It is extremely dangerous.

PL: This appears to me to be well coordinated, because the evidence is
overwhelming. Barbecue has been named first and foremost by his victims,
but also upon investigation by none other than the United Nations and the
U.S. Department of the Treasury, even under Trump. For this same man to
have so-called left-wing journalists praise him as a revolutionary is just
outrageous. It shows the racism of a certain sector of progressive media;
to them, Haitian lives do not matter. Haitian people take great note, they
know who has been killing them and who sides with them.

CV: How do President Aristide and the Lavalas movement fit in this context?

MP: An important question. The Fanmi Lavalas movement and party, associated
with Aristide, did not follow the traditional left sectarian party line.
Aristide was a liberation theologist, he was a man of the people. Lavalas
was not connected to a particular left grouping, it was really a mass
movement of the people, which means many have had a hard time trying to
categorize it, putting it in a particular bag, you know? I say this because
there seems to be a lot of confusion around Haiti, even from people who may
be very clear, for example, when it comes to Venezuela and how the United
States went after the late Hugo Chávez. They are much less clear when it
comes to Haiti. Why is that? It is worth thinking about.

PL: This is, again, about the devaluation of Black lives. I am not just
quoting some cliche here, I mean it deeply. The Lavalas movement and
political organization is a continuation of the struggle of our ancestors,
as expressed through their various organizations over the last two
centuries. Lavalas is the continuing expression, the continuing completion,
of the Haitian Revolution. Our enslaved foremothers and forefathers had a
political vision. They had a vision of society that should be organized in
an egalitarian way, and it was reflected after independence in the kind of
society that we organized. However, there is this racist view that is
continually being proposed: that Black people did not have a history before
slavery, as if we did not produce or invent anything. This is very
pervasive in the left movement, not just the right, so that, when it comes
to Haiti, unless you are pro-this or pro-that, unless you are categorizable
from the outside, as Margaret was saying, then you do not count according
to an established left. Well, in Haiti, our people rose up because the
conditions of exploitation that were crushing their humanity forced them to
rise up and say, “No. We are human beings and we are not tolerating this.
We used to live a certain way in Africa and we want to rebuild society
based on that.” It is not just me saying this. This is part of the oral
tradition and the way that people have organized their societies

It is a dismissal of Black resistance and organization. For example, people
will often say that Haiti is an informal economy. What the hell is that? We
are talking about an economy that over centuries has provided for the lives
of millions of people—*and very well*. What is informal about that? What
they consider formal is actually what they are trying to impose on the
majority of Haiti, not responding to or meeting the needs of the population
in terms of nutrition, shelter, health care, culture, or any of that. For
the past eighteen years, the occupation, which is imposing on us this new
economic system, has created the worst conditions in Haiti ever. Complete
inequality, the enormous gap between the haves and the have-nots,
destruction of the local economy and national production of food, and so
on. Whereas, during the brief ten-year democratic interlude in Haiti, with
Lavalas and President Aristide, who represent the vision of society of our
ancestors, we have built more schools and hospitals than during the
entirety of the first two centuries of independence. I would not say that
everything was rosy, but there was a march toward improving conditions, a
mobilization of society to change old structures and create new ones.
Margaret mentioned *The Black Jacobins*. I love *The Black Jacobins*
because it really presents our history as human beings struggling to be
free, to liberate ourselves. Today is a continuation of that struggle.

MP: I just want to say something about the often repeated “Haiti must have
elections as soon as possible.” Everybody on the ground, even CARICOM,
knows that elections are not possible given the current situation. There
had been a grouping of those who were opposing Moïse, including the
Lavalas, with their own demands. One was a demand for an interim period to
get things organized in a certain way so that elections would be possible.

PL: Absolutely. The Creole name for the proposal is *Sali Piblik*, public
safety, and you will see it written all over Haiti in different
neighborhoods. “Let’s have elections, let’s have elections”—that is the
United Nations, and by that I also mean the United States, as the United
Nations does their bidding. When they use the word *elections*, they make
people think that there is participation. The system of elections they have
imposed on Haiti, keeping in mind the dominance of the United States over
Haiti, is the system of elections under Jim Crow, whereby the mass
population is excluded from the voting process. Their voices are excluded.
In Haiti, it is no longer one person, one vote. They have carved it out so
as to exclude mass participation. Only a handful of people vote. In spite
of this, they make sure to use computer systems to preselect and populate
the vote. Everything is already in the bag and all they want is people to
show up, while they set up artificial voting lines so that journalists can
walk by, snap a photo, and show the world.

Margaret and I witnessed the 2016 elections in Haiti and we saw how many
people were excluded from voting. Information on this came out later. They
know that this is the way to fool the world one more time. There was an
election, but those in office do not represent the majority of the
population. The function of these elected officials is to sign off on
things, to agree to loans, to authorize the theft of the resources of the
country because they have the legal authority to do so. Who then has to pay
back these loans at usurious interest rates? The people of Haiti, as usual,
who did not elect the people in charge. Those people were imposed, yet we
are the ones who have to then pay those loans back to the World Bank and
International Monetary Fund. It is another level of exploitation in the
continuing system against our people. People are saying, “Enough, we are
sick of it.” They wanted Moïse to step down immediately, as he was imposed
by the United States, United Nations, and OAS on behalf of the imperialist

We the Haitian people will pick the credible, honest, competent Haitians
who can form a government to represent different sectors, rebuild the
institutions that have been destroyed by the eighteen-year occupation and
the Moïse dictatorship, start responding to the needs of the population in
terms of clean drinking water, hospitals, schools. For example, many of our
teachers are not being paid; Haiti has tons of money, but there is no money
for education because it is all going into the pockets of the NGOs,
foreigners, and local elite. The proposal is to start this phase of
cleaning up so that, after three years of this transition period, elections
can be organized and the people can freely vote for the representatives of
their choice. One person, one vote. That is what Sali Piblik is about.

CV: We have been talking about this throughout, but it would be useful to
break down the significance and legacy of Aristide charting an independent
course for Haiti. He prioritized food security, health, education,
agricultural cooperatives, a higher minimum wage, reparations from France,
democracy within the country, independence from foreign entities, and so
on. What has been the impact of Aristide and the Lavalas movement?

PL: In 2000, President Aristide and Fanmi Lavalas published a book.
Everybody except Haitians knew that Haiti was a rich country with many
resources. They kept telling us that we were a very poor country, that we
had nothing, and there was no real pride in Haiti except that we defeated
the French. But we had no idea. The Lavalas movement really made it a point
to make Haitians aware of our history of resistance and exploitation, and
how we ended up where we are today. They also had a program called Investir
Dans L’Humain, investing in people. It spelled out Haiti’s various
resources and how they could be used in the development of the country,
meaning to improve living conditions so that people can have a good life as
befits them as human beings, with dignity.

For example, President Aristide and his government invested a lot into
creating an equitable system of justice. He disbanded the Haitian military
in 1995 (it was only remobilized by Moïse), which was no small or easy
thing. The Haitian military used to take 40 percent of the national budget.
It was created by the United States in the wake of the 1915 invasion to be
at war with the population, creating coup d’états, repressing people,
carrying out torture and massacres. President Aristide disbanded it,
created a civilian police force, and invested that 40 percent in social
services and the local economy. He decommissioned Haiti’s equivalent of the
Pentagon and donated the building to the women’s movement, which created
the Ministry for Women’s Affairs to deal with the problems that the
majority of women in our society face. He invested in schools, hospitals,
local food production, and the like, reenvisioning Haitian society in a way
that benefited the population, and Haitians were really responding to it.
For the first time, Haitians stopped going abroad and were coming back home
to invest in the country. Ever since the U.S. occupation of 1915, Haitians
have fled Haiti because of the war, both by the U.S. and Haitian militaries
against the Haitian population. People were fleeing to Cuba, the Dominican
Republic, and some of the other islands. The conditions to build the
country were being created by Aristide and the Lavalas movement.

Another very important thing is that, for the first time, we as Haitians
were celebrating Creole, our national language, which is spoken by
basically 100 percent of the Haitian population. French was the only
official language, but was only spoken by probably 10 to 15 percent of the
population. Haitians were made to feel like foreigners in their own land.
You would go to court, for example, and everything was in French, so people
would not understand what was being discussed about their own lives, the
decisions that were being made about their lives. President Aristide was
the first to take the oath of office in Creole. This was major. The impact
of it in Haiti has been phenomenal. When he went to the United Nations, his
addresses were in Creole. They had to go get him an interpreter! He
established this kind of respect and made Haitians proud. While he was in
office, people were very proud to say they were from Haiti.

Finally, President Aristide established that Haiti was indeed part of
Africa and part of the Caribbean. He was very active in CARICOM and in
forging greater collaboration between the nations of Africa, Haiti, and
CARICOM. There is much to say about what was accomplished during President
Aristide’s tenure of office and the Lavalas government.

MP: Pierre, I’m really glad you mentioned women. I’m part of the Haiti
working group of the Global Women’s Strike. We do what we can to support
women and their projects on the ground, whether it is food production or
helping take care of people. We know very well how COVID has exposed how
dependent society is on people who take care of you, the caregivers who are
overwhelmingly women. Women have played a central role in the deep
resistance in Haiti, going back to the days of the Haitian Revolution and
since, ensuring that the children eat even if the adults do not, providing
shelter, comfort. I went to Lasalin following the massacre there, and the
women were showing me the houses that had been built by President Aristide
and were being attacked by these paramilitary death squads. They talked
about the hospital that had opened and then was shut down. The workload
that the women carry, everything they do, not only to maintain their
families, but also to maintain the resistance, really cannot be

The university of the Aristide Foundation was also set up and attended by
the children of market women, *tap taps* drivers, agricultural workers, and
so on. It was their main opportunity to go to a university where they would
not be looked down on. It began as a school of medicine, but was shut down
and its campus used as a military base by the United States after the
second coup. When President Aristide returned, he said his focus would be
education. He and the former first lady, Mildred Trouillot, came back in
early 2011 and, by that September, the campus was reopened. I’ve been to
several of the graduations and there are just thousands of very happy
Haitians, so proud of their children who have graduated as doctors,
lawyers, nurses, therapists. They now have an agronomy department and are
building a teaching hospital. They are also working to establish
relationships with people in the academy here in the United States and the
Caribbean, as well as to bring visiting professors and doing all kinds of
things virtually due to COVID. It has been a very bright spot given all the
bad news coming out of Haiti. At the last graduation I attended, there was
a key opposition-media television person who was totally blown away by what
he saw and even admitted in a news report that, despite whatever criticisms
he had come to prove, the university was a huge accomplishment. It is
something of which every Haitian really should be proud. To me, this is a
continuation of the kind of work by Aristide and the Lavalas movement that
Pierre described. Despite the World Bank, International Monetary Fund, and
the rest of them cutting off money to the Aristide administration, the
Lavalas were able to accomplish what for a few hundred years did not
happen. It speaks to their dedication, understanding, and simpatico
relationships with the Haitian people.

PL: The Aristide Foundation for Democracy, another institution that
President Aristide established, was founded with the grassroots women’s
movement on March 8, International Women’s Day, with the women in the

CV: We have spoken at length about the historical threads running through
Haiti and the present moment. Let us turn to the specificities of the
current situation, perhaps starting with the assassination of Moïse itself.
Haitian authorities have arrested the head of Moïse’s security team as part
of its probe into the assassination and issued an arrest warrant for
Supreme Court Justice Windelle Coq Thélot. Colombian mercenaries have also
been linked to the assassination, with the Pentagon confirming that four of
the accused mercenaries had received U.S. military training at the School
of the Americas. Since then, the judge presiding over the investigation of
the assassination quit because one of the court clerks was also found
murdered. What do you say about the assassination, who may be behind it,
and where things stand now?

PL: The reality of the situation is that it’s confusing. People in Haiti
are looking at it as more of a question of infighting among a group of
partners in crime, or co-opted individuals, with Moïse at the head. It’s
understood as a settling of scores at the top, which has nothing to do with
the overwhelming majority of the population that this little clique has
been oppressing for the longest time. That’s how people are seeing it.
There is no honor among thieves. These twists and turns do not surprise us.
The fact that the judge fled, that the court clerk was found dead, these
kinds of things have been going on. We have had blatant assassinations,
massacres against communities, and no real legal pursuit in a justice
system that is so corrupt.

The only regret is that the Haitian people hoped they would be the ones to
topple Moïse and actually hold him accountable for his crimes against
humanity and the money he stole while in office, so we could recuperate
that wealth as a people. This is despite the Haitian oligarchy and media
outside of Haiti trying to pass him off as a folk hero. Of course, there
are supporters of Moïse, but they are in the minority.

Regarding who exactly is behind the assassination, to quote one of the
grassroots people I was speaking with, “Look, this guy eats from so many
different troughs, that when he gets food poisoning, you know, it’s hard to
say from which one.” There are public accusations, made by several people,
including a former senator, that Moïse was very involved in the
drug-trafficking trade. They have even been saying for several years that
he had an airstrip on his banana plantation. So that is one possible
connection. Another is that Moïse had been feuding recently with some
members of the oligarchy, taking over their businesses and creating his own
under his and his wife’s name, calling it JOMAR [a portmanteau of their
first names]. And when you step on these people’s toes, they deal with you
in a particular way. So, it is hard to say. Everything is possible. The
point is that it was not the people storming the Bastille.

Moïse was so well protected. The grounds were all patrolled. There were
snipers on top of the house. Somebody described the several roadblocks that
were in place before you could get to the house—at least four. So, for
people to be able to go through all of that unchallenged, and then to kill
so brazenly, there is definitely something going on.

When the head of the bar association, who was Moïse’s neighbor, was
assassinated, and a group of attorneys wanted to put some flowers in front
of his home, they couldn’t get through the first roadblock. Now we are
talking about not just ordinary people, but *attorneys* going to put
flowers as tribute in front of the home of the slain head of the bar
association. There was tear gas, bullets were flying, and it was stopped
very quickly. So, people are saying: How could these guys have gotten in so
easily, entered Moïse’s home, even his bedroom, and murdered him? It was a
very sophisticated attack, highly planned, with very big people involved at
all levels.

CV: What about the role of the United States? It is hard to believe the
assassination could happen like that without any U.S. knowledge, even if
they supported Moïse along the way.

PL: Yes, people in Haiti are saying that nothing like this happens without
the knowledge of the United States. The United States is just so dominant
and, of course, Haiti is still under occupation by the United Nations, but
it is really a U.S. occupation *through* the United Nations. For example,
according to several reports, the Colombian mercenaries you mentioned
earlier had been in Haiti for months before the assassination, working with
the Haitian police, and with the full knowledge of the Haitian government,
Colombia, and the United States. These are not people who just happened to
drop by. On top of this, around three weeks before Moïse was assassinated,
a group—a so-called gang, but really one of the government-financed and
-promoted death squads—took over a very rich neighborhood called Laboule,
where the house of former president Préval’s widow is located. In no time,
it was reported that the Colombian mercenaries had cleaned out that
neighborhood. Everything together, it just does not sit well at all. This
whole *whodunit* is like this, we know it’s them taking care of business at
the top. It’s wolves fighting over the lamb, which is us, the Haitian

CV: And then there’s Ariel Henry, who was sworn in as the acting prime
minister of Haiti, handpicked by Moïse, and fully backed by the Core Group.

PL: Precisely. It has also been reported that Henry has the support of
Barbecue. Henry is not somebody who just came out of nowhere. He was part
of the first coup d’état against President Aristide in 2004 and actually
headed the illegally constituted group that they call the Council of the
Wise—there is no such provision in the Haitian constitution for anything
like this. This was a U.S.-constructed thing to try to give a veneer of
legitimacy to the coup. Henry is a player within that whole group. He was
also director general of the Ministry of Health and then the ministry’s
chief of staff under Préval. He is no angel. Make no mistake—this is the
exact same regime as that of Moise, just with a different face.

CV: Henry also worked with the United States in their atrocious response to
the 2010 earthquake. Could we talk about the earthquake that just happened
on August 14? Haiti was hit by a devastating 7.2 magnitude earthquake, and
then by a tropical storm. Thousands of people have died, been injured, and
are now homeless. Even people whose homes are still standing are sleeping
in the streets for fear of the aftershocks. Hospitals have been severely
damaged, and then there’s always the problem of aid never getting to the
people who need it. The earthquake and the storm are natural disasters, but
there are real social factors behind why the people of Haiti are so
vulnerable when dealing with climate events such as these. Could you speak
to this, as well as how this fits in with all the other things happening?

PL: The earthquake is another example of the devastation of Haiti. Again,
when Haitians ruled Haiti, with President Aristide for example, it was the
Haitian population making decisions about the tax money; the resources of
the country; building schools, hospitals, clean sources of drinking water;
providing for the local agriculture and food production; all those things
that were going to improve people’s lives. There was also in place a
protection agency for the civilian population in case of natural disasters.
They were made up of young people who were extremely well trained, many
with the help of Cuba, in disaster preparedness and what to do in the
aftermath. There were a series of places, in various communities, where
people knew how to predict climate events and prevent devastation, and
could help prepare the population as needed. It was all in place. But then,
with the U.S. coup, they chased all of them out, called them Lavalas, and
destroyed this infrastructure that was established for the civilian

Now, every year, we know that we are going to have a hurricane. When
Haitians were ruling Haiti, we were prepared for that. “Okay, we know it’s
coming, it’s not the end of the world; where Haiti is, that is what’s bound
to happen.” But there was all the equipment in place. There was
infrastructure to deal with it, so people knew how and where to take
shelter, what to do before, during, and after, like they do in Cuba and
other places. All of that was destroyed. What we have now is that, every
year in Haiti, any strong wind becomes a catastrophe. There are other
countries in the region that, yes, are affected by this kind of climate
(they are natural disasters after all), but it’s always much, much, much
worse in Haiti, because of the lack of preparedness, the population being
so exposed, and nothing in place for how to deal with the aftermath. This
has been consistent since the coup of 2004.

MP: I have been increasingly concerned about where the relief money is
going, just as with the 2010 earthquake, when, as we talked about, you had
the major NGOs like the Red Cross raising all this money that never reached
the people who needed it. This time around, people are much more aware, and
I think there are people who genuinely want to avoid that, and want to make
sure that the resources and money directly benefit the Haitian people
affected. However, some of the left progressive organizations in the United
States, even some of the militant Black organizations, are circulating
lists of organizations that people should donate to. And some of the
organizations on the different lists are problematic.

They are people who can talk a good talk on the international front, have
this kind of militant rhetoric, but on the ground, it’s another story. Many
of them are ambitious politically, meaning they want to run for office and
are cutting various deals, and some were even involved in the coup against
President Aristide. I worry that they are using the goodwill of people who
want to donate to Haiti, in order to collect money basically to build up
their own organizations. Many of these organizations are against the mass
movement on the ground in Haiti, they are against Lavalas. One just has to
be careful.

When people ask me where to donate, I tell them that the only organization
I trust, given the situation on the ground, is the Haiti Emergency Relief
Fund, which gives everything they collect to the Haitian people. I know
sometimes people want these extensive lists, but if you do that, you really
do have to vet them, you have to know who is who, who is doing what where.
There are some organizations, for example, that really don’t even do relief
work but are putting out calls for donations anyway. I mentioned this
already, but I am referring to this as the solidarity industrial complex, a
kind of imperialist type of solidarity. There’s a real danger of people who
genuinely want to help, but who don’t really know the situation on the
ground, and rather than talking to various people, trying to get a sense of
who is who, trying to be accountable, they quickly make these lists and
pronounce that they are fundraising for Haiti. Well, it often ends up a
smaller version of what the large NGOs are doing with the aid, and they end
up undermining the mass movement on the ground. I tell them, you know, all
of us are responsible for the points of references we choose. Wilmette
Brown, who cofounded Black Women for Wages for Housework, said that, and I
absolutely believe it. It was one of the many brilliant things she said.

Somebody contacted me about donations, and said something like, “Oh, I was
thinking of donating to such and such group, but then I found out that
they’re not Black-led.” Their criteria for donations is that a group be
Black-led. Excuse me, the Duvaliers were Black, Moïse was Black, Barbecue
is Black! That can’t be the only criteria for who you listen to as your
point of reference. When you’re living in the belly of the beast and
dealing with structural and other forms of racism on a day-to-day basis,
there can be a tendency to go in that direction, which is a little bit
separatist, to say, “Well, I’m going to relate to the Black organizations.”
I absolutely believe in autonomy. I mean, I helped found Black Women for
Wages for Housework! But it just can’t be the only criteria. I grew up in
Barbados, which is around 95 percent Black, and everyone knew that the
enemy can have a Black face, it’s very clear. I think it is something that
we, who come from predominantly Black societies, have to keep reminding
people in the United States, Europe, Western nations more generally, that
just because somebody is Black and they talk a good talk doesn’t mean you
can bypass accountability and be exempt from trying to find out more about
that person or organization.

CV: To close, I just want to touch on the future. What is in store, what is
the hope?

PL: The people of Haiti will continue to mobilize. They are not giving up
on their hopes and their dreams. They are not giving up on the plan, which
is *investir dans l’humain*, to invest in people; the plan that was being
implemented by Lavalas. To use the resources of the country, to use the tax
money that the Haitian people contribute to the national treasury, so as to
actually benefit the majority population; to build schools, hospitals,
clean sources of drinking water; to improve the working conditions, so that
our peasantry and every single person in Haiti can live with dignity in a
safe and flourishing environment. Not only that, but also fun activities
for the people! To take our country back from all those death squads
imposing a reign of terror on the population.

Because of the death squads, whether you are in the city or in the country,
you often have to flee or take your chances with the sharks. If you are a
farmer and stay, you lose your land, and then on top of that are forced to
come back and work on that land, practically unpaid, for the very people
who took it. The land grabs, which are violations of the rule of law, are
not happening by chance. It’s part of a policy that has been implemented
under the nearly eighteen-year occupation, decided on at a meeting in
Ottawa, Canada, in early 2003.

The people of Haiti are saying, “No, we are going to fight, we are going to
put a stop to this, and we are going to overturn and change that system.”

CV: I also want to add that, as we well know, the United States keeps
deporting Haitians, keeps occupying Haiti, and non-Haitians in the United
States have a responsibility to mobilize here, at the heart of empire,
against U.S. imperialism and in solidarity with Haiti and the Haitian
people. As Margaret has said, we owe a great debt to the Black Jacobins,
not only of 1804, but also of today.

PL: Thank you for saying that, I agree with you wholeheartedly. The Biden
administration knows very well what’s going on. That is why Haitians will
tell you that it’s the laboratory at work, referring to the entire system.
What they mean is that there is nothing that goes on in Haiti without the
knowledge of those who control the aid, the Core Group, or the “Core Gang”
as Haitians call them. That is not to say that they are omnipotent or what
have you, but they have such penetration in the country that anything
harmful for the people of Haiti is part of the policy they are
implementing. Our task is to overturn that, and this is an appeal for
solidarity, as you said. We Haitians are very familiar with everything that
has been happening. But to an outside audience, they may think that we are
making it up, or exaggerating. We are not. Everything has been documented
and recorded, and it is very clear. We need to let the world community
know, and we hope that people struggle with us in solidarity.
2021 <https://monthlyreview.org/category/2021/>, Volume 73, Number 5
(October 2021)
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20211004/3fb289df/attachment-0001.html>

More information about the News mailing list