[News] US Sent Latin Youth Undercover in Anti-Cuba Ploy

Anti-Imperialist News news at freedomarchives.org
Mon Aug 4 10:10:22 EDT 2014


By DESMOND BUTLER <http://bigstory.ap.org/content/desmond-butler>, JACK 
GILLUM <http://bigstory.ap.org/content/jack-gillum>, ALBERTO ARCE 
<http://bigstory.ap.org/content/alberto-arce> and ANDREA RODRIGUEZ 

--- Aug. 4, 2014 12:01 AM EDT

WASHINGTON (AP) --- Fernando Murillo was typical of the young Latin 
Americans deployed to Cuba by a U.S. agency to work undercover. He had 
little training in the dangers of clandestine operations --- or how to 
evade one of the world's most sophisticated counter-intelligence services.

Their assignment was to recruit young Cubans to anti-government 
activism, which they did under the guise of civic programs, including an 
HIV prevention workshop. Murillo was instructed to check in every 48 
hours and was provided with a set of security codes. "I have a 
headache," for instance, meant the Costa Rican thought the Cubans were 
watching him and the mission should be suspended.

Over at least two years, the U.S. Agency for International Development 
--- best known for overseeing billions of dollars in U.S. humanitarian 
aid --- sent nearly a dozen neophytes from Venezuela, Costa Rica and 
Peru to gin up opposition in Cuba. The danger was apparent to USAID, if 
not to the young operatives: A USAID contractor, American Alan Gross, 
had just been hauled away to a Cuban jail for smuggling in sensitive 
technology. He remains there still.

USAID hired Creative Associates International, a Washington-based 
company, as part of a civil society program against Cuba's communist 
government. The same company was central to the creation of a "Cuban 
Twitter" --- a messaging network revealed in April by The Associated 
Press, designed to reach hundreds of thousands of Cubans.

According to internal documents obtained by the AP and interviews in six 
countries, USAID's young operatives posed as tourists, visited college 
campuses and used a ruse that could undermine USAID's credibility in 
critical health work around the world: An HIV-prevention workshop one 
called the "perfect excuse" to recruit political activists, according to 
a report by Murillo's group. For all the risks, some travelers were paid 
as little as $5.41 an hour.

The travelers program was launched during a time when newly inaugurated 
President Barack Obama spoke about a "new beginning" with Cuba after 
decades of mistrust, raising questions about whether the White House had 
a coherent policy toward the island nation.

There's no evidence that the program advanced the mission to create a 
pro-democracy movement against the government of Raul Castro. Creative 
Associates declined to comment, referring questions to USAID.

USAID would not say how much the Costa Rica-based program cost. In 
response to questions from the AP, the agency issued a statement that 
said, "USAID and the Obama administration are committed to supporting 
the Cuban people's desire to freely determine their own future. USAID 
works with independent youth groups in Cuba on community service 
projects, public health, the arts and other opportunities to engage 
publicly, consistent with democracy programs worldwide."

In a statement late Sunday, USAID said the HIV workshop had a dual 
purpose: It "enabled support for Cuban civil society while providing a 
secondary benefit of addressing the desire Cubans expressed for 
information and training about HIV prevention."

But the AP investigation revealed an operation that often teetered on 
disaster. Cuban authorities questioned who was bankrolling the 
travelers. The young workers came dangerously close to blowing their 
mission to "identify potential social-change actors." And there was no 
safety net for the inexperienced travelers, who were doing work that was 
explicitly illegal in Cuba.

"Although there is never total certainty, trust that the authorities 
will not try to harm you physically, only frighten you," the workers' 
instructions read. "Remember that the Cuban government prefers to avoid 
negative media reports abroad, so a beaten foreigner is not convenient 
for them."

After Gross was arrested, USAID privately told contractors that they 
should consider suspending travel to Cuba, according to emails obtained 
by the AP.

"We value your safety," one senior USAID official said in an email, less 
than a week after Gross was seized.

"The guidance applies to ALL travelers to the island, not just American 
citizens," another official wrote.

And yet four months later, in April 2010, Murillo was sent to Havana.



Murillo, then 29, was the charismatic head of a human-rights group in 
Costa Rica called Fundacion Operacion Gaya Internacional, which had been 
contracted by Creative Associates to turn Cuba's apathetic young people 
into effective political actors.

He headed to Santa Clara, a city three hours from Havana, where Murillo 
connected with a cultural group that called itself "Revolution," a 
modest outfit of artists devoted to electronic music and video.

Murillo wasn't there long before a state security officer, Carlos Pozo, 
took notice --- a problem Murillo reported to Creative Associates, 
records show.

If the idea was to hold a series of seminars to recruit new 
"volunteers," Murillo needed a theme that would both draw in potential 
recruits and still be sanctioned by the state.

An HIV-prevention workshop was just the thing.

Months later, in November 2010, the workshop drew 60 people. Pozo also 
participated --- evidence, Murillo said, that his scheme was working.

The workshop was supposed to offer straightforward sex education for HIV 
prevention, such as the proper way to use a condom.

"Cubans expressed a desire for information and training about HIV 
prevention, and the workshop helped to address their needs," USAID said 
in response to written questions.

*But the ulterior motive, documents show, was to use the workshop as a 
recruiting ground for young people by showing them how to organize 

*This was a strategy that the travelers hoped to spread across the 
island: The newly organized young people would tackle a community or 
social problem, win a "small victory" and ultimately realize that they 
could be the masters of their own destiny.*

Reached in San Jose, Costa Rica, Murillo said he could not speak about 
the details of his Cuba trips because he had signed a nondisclosure 
agreement. He said he wasn't trying to do anything beyond teach people 
how to use condoms properly.

"I never said to a Cuban that he had to do something against the 
government. If that was the mission of others, I don't know," Murillo 
said. "I never told a Cuban what he had to do."

Nevertheless, Murillo's six-page report back to Creative Associates 
mentioned HIV only once, to note that it was "the perfect excuse for the 
treatment of the underlying theme." Elsewhere, the report revealed 
another objective: "to generate a network of volunteers for social 

Manuel Barbosa, a founder of Revolution, said in a recent interview in 
Santa Clara the Costa Ricans never told him that they were working for 

He said he has no anti-government leanings, in fact, his grandfather was 
a "martyr of the revolution."

Staging a workshop as a front to subvert a foreign government risked 
casting suspicion on USAID's legitimate public health mission, including 
a more than $3 billion annual HIV program that the agency says has 
helped some 50 million people in nearly 100 countries. The CIA recently 
pledged to stop using vaccine programs to gather intelligence, such as 
one in Pakistan that targeted Osama bin Laden.

An evaluation prepared for USAID by Creative Associates cited the 
workshop as a "success story." The group's final report said the 
workshop would be used as a blueprint across the island.

"These programs are in desperate need of adult supervision," said Sen. 
Jeff Flake, a Republican from Arizona and longtime critic of USAID's 
Cuba programs. "If you are using an AIDS workshop as a front for 
something else, that's ... I don't know what to say ... it's just wrong."



While Murillo and the Costa Rican travelers focused on the HIV workshop 
and other programs, teams of Venezuelans and Peruvians were deployed to 
Cuba's college campuses. Their mission, documents and interviews show, 
was to recruit university students with the long-term goal of turning 
them against their government.

In late 2009, Creative Associates contracted with Venezuelan lawyer 
Zaimar Castillo, then 22, who ran an organization called Renova. 
Castillo declined to comment, but her former administrator, Yajaira 
Andrade, said she was flown to San Jose for training.

"They gave us a week of classes, teaching us what we were going to do 
and how we were going to do it," said Andrade, who called herself the 
"mom" of the young activists.

At the time, Venezuela's president, the late Hugo Chavez, was the 
closest ally of brothers Fidel and Raul Castro --- doubling the risk for 
Renova. They set up a bank account for their contract dollars in Panama, 
a haven for anonymous banking.

"We worked it so that the government here didn't know we were traveling 
to Cuba and helping these groups," Andrade said. "Because that was when 
Chavez was in power, and if he had known about us --- that some 
Venezuelans were working to stir rebellion --- we would have been thrown 
in jail."

On April 24, 2010, three Renova colleagues landed in Havana for a 
monthlong visit. Their "cover story," according to an internal document, 
was that they were visiting Cuban friends.

"It's fundamental that they don't get obsessed," said Creative 
Associates manager Xavier Utset, who now works at USAID, in a Skype 
chat. "Otherwise on the ground, they will freeze ... or they will betray 
themselves ... and both things are fatal."

The Venezuelans visited the dorms on campus at the university in Santa 
Clara and took weekend trips to meet the families of the students. A 
separate team of young Peruvians also targeted the university in Santa 

In a trip account that reads like an intelligence report, the 
Venezuelans describe the students and their facilities in great detail, 
noting complaints and fairness issues that might be exploited. Potential 
recruits were listed by name, and then profiled, their leadership 
qualities assessed in a spreadsheet.

The report went on to describe the political culture of the university, 
including the role of the Union of Communist Youth, which sought to 
groom the best and brightest for party posts after graduation. Student 
gripes also were detailed: bad food, intermittent water and electricity, 
leaks in the ceilings. The students feared the state and were 
dissatisfied with their economic reality, according to the report, but 
were politically apathetic just the same.

The fact that the students were constantly criticizing the regime, they 
reported, "assures us of having beneficiaries with a clear mind as to 
the objectives that we are pursuing."

After visiting two universities in two cities, the Venezuelan 
consultants identified a "target group" of students they thought both 
opposed the government and had organizational skills, having put 
together on their own activities like "camping" and "a university 
festival," documents show.

"They established one group of 30 people, young people studying science, 
to rebel against the government," said Andrade, the Renova administrator.

There's no evidence the political objectives were ever realized. In 
fact, their Cuban contacts in recent interviews with the AP said they 
were astonished to discover that the foreigners were acting on behalf of 
the U.S. government.

"They were our friends," said Cuban Hector Baranda, who topped the 
Venezuelans' list of potential converts.

He thinks the visitors may have mistaken typical Cuban griping as 
dissident tendencies. Cuban authorities have little tolerance for 
counterrevolutionary opposition, but letters to the Communist Party 
newspaper Granma complain about unfilled potholes, uncollected garbage 
and Cuba's impenetrable bureaucracy.

"A Cuban always says 'aggggh,' whether (the problems are) big or small," 
Baranda said.



Cuba considers all of USAID's democracy promotion work to be subversive, 
punishable by up to 10 years behind bars. It was a risky business for 
the travelers.

Over time, Creative Associates adjusted its security strategy. It warned 
against the use of encrypted flash drives stamped conspicuously with the 
word "IronKey," --- that was a giveaway at airport security. Travelers 
were encouraged to bring in laptops packed with photos and personal data 
to mask their mission material.

In case of arrest, Creative Associates was not to be mentioned, a report 
said, travelers were told to contact their home country's embassy.

Under questioning, Creative Associates advised the travelers to keep 
their cool. They should remember that "nothing that you have done during 
your trip is illegal, in any way, in any open and democratic society. In 
this way, you can maintain a calm demeanor during the interrogation."

But despite efforts to hide their intentions, by late 2010, there were 
signs the Cubans were catching on.

A security officer asked who was funding Murillo's project. Creative 
Associates concluded that the questioning left "no room for doubt about 
the interest they brought to themselves by the state police."

Worse yet, a December security report suggested the Cubans had figured 
out that the United States was targeting young people instead of the 
aging ranks of well-known Castro opponents.

When one Cuban asked a traveler why he was interested in Cuba, he 
responded that his organization worked with many countries.

"Of course, this is not accurate" said the report. If the Cubans checked 
out the story, they would have known it was a lie.

On Sept. 3, 2010, Irving Perez, a manager at Creative Associates' office 
in San Jose, called a meeting via Skype to announce a change in strategy.

"Our program will no longer rely on trips to the island, at least not as 
the backbone of the operation," Perez told two Peruvian travelers. 
Several of the grants would be terminated, including the Venezuelans'.

Instead of traveling to Cuba, they would try to help certain "star 
contacts" get exit visas to train in a third country. The Cuban 
"beneficiaries" left on the island would receive cash payments to run 
the recruitment efforts. Creative Associates' subcontractors would bring 
cash to the islanders using "mules," a term borrowed from drug smuggling.

They would "try to manage the project by remote control," Perez explained.

But that strategy had its own perils.



For a month, Perez had been asking for a report from a pair of Cuban 
college students, anxious to file his paperwork for USAID.

The students had been using encrypted Hushmail. That might have raised a 
red flag to Cuban authorities who monitor Internet activity.

"We have reasons to believe that they have been under great pressure 
from university authorities," a Creative Associates report says. "It is 
not recommended at this time to try to reach them again."

The Costa Rican grant fell apart on Murillo's third trip to the island 
in June, 2011. Creative Associates wanted him to deliver money, collect 
reports and help arrange exit visas. Managers worried that Murillo was 
indiscreet. "Why are these guys not using Hushmail?" lamented a Creative 
Associates manager.

To deliver the money, contractors discussed sending it with Murillo's 
relatives. One manager in San Jose wrote, "It should be remembered that 
the 'mule' doesn't know exactly what the money is for nor where it comes 

In the end, the "mule" was Murillo's childhood friend, who recounted the 
experience in an interview with the AP on condition of anonymity. The 
friend, who lives in San Jose, said being associated with USAID's 
political agenda in Cuba would jeopardize his employment.

He said his security training took about a half hour over Skype. "It was 
made clear to me that I must be careful because the money we carried was 

After arriving in Havana, the pair headed to Santa Clara to meet with 
Revolution, the arts group. One member, not Barbosa, told them to hand 
over the money he knew they were carrying, he said.

"He threatened us directly that if we didn't give him the money, he 
would go to the authorities and denounce us," said Murillo's friend.

Murillo declined to comment.

Unsettled, the travelers hurried back to Havana, and invoking one of the 
security codes from a hotel, abandoned the project. The friend was 

"If they had detained or even just interrogated me," he said, "I would 
have died of a heart attack from fright."


Arce reported from San Jose, Costa Rica, and Rodriguez from Santa Clara, 
Cuba. Associated Press writers Hannah Dreier in Caracas, Venezuela; 
Peter Orsi in Havana; Frank Bajak in Lima, Peru; Raphael Satter in 
Dublin and Monika Mathur in Washington contributed to this report.


Contact the AP's Washington investigative team atDCinvestigations at ap.org 
<mailto:DCinvestigations at ap.org>. On Twitter, follow Butler 
athttps://twitter.com/desmondbutler; Gillum 
athttps://twitter.com/jackgillum; Arce at 
https://twitter.com/alberarce and Rodriguez at 


Online: View documents about the program at http://apne.ws/UxJ05x.

Another in a series of stories detailing secret American political 
activity in Cuba under the Obama administration, including the creation 
of a covert U.S.-backed "Cuban Twitter" program.
Freedom Archives 522 Valencia Street San Francisco, CA 94110 415 
863.9977 www.freedomarchives.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20140804/5ee49ae8/attachment.html>

More information about the News mailing list