[News] IAEA's "Soviet Nuclear Scientist" Never Worked on Weapons
Anti-Imperialist News
news at freedomarchives.org
Thu Nov 10 12:11:06 EST 2011
IAEA's "Soviet Nuclear Scientist" Never Worked on Weapons
By Gareth Porter*
http://ipsnews.net/news.asp?idnews=105776
WASHINGTON, Nov 9, 2011 (IPS) - The report of the
International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA)
published by a Washington think tank Tuesday
repeated the sensational claim previously
reported by news media all over the world that a
former Soviet nuclear weapons scientist had
helped Iran construct a detonation system that
could be used for a nuclear weapon.
But it turns out that the foreign expert, who is
not named in the
<http://isis-online.org/uploads/isis-reports/documents/IAEA_Iran_8Nov2011.pdf>IAEA
report but was identified in news reports as
Vyacheslav Danilenko, is not a nuclear weapons
scientist but one of the top specialists in the
world in the production of nanodiamonds by explosives.
In fact, Danilenko, a Ukrainian, has worked
solely on nanodiamonds from the beginning of his
research career and is considered one of the
pioneers in the development of nanodiamond
technology, as published scientific papers confirm.
It now appears that the IAEA and David Albright,
the director of the International Institute for
Science and Security in Washington, who was the
source of the news reports about Danilenko, never
bothered to check the accuracy of the original
claim by an unnamed "Member State" on which the
IAEA based its assertion about his nuclear weapons background.
Albright gave a "private briefing" for
"intelligence professionals" last week, in which
he named Danilenko as the foreign expert who had
been contracted by Iran's Physics Research Centre
in the mid-1990s and identified him as a "former
Soviet nuclear scientist", according to a story
by Joby Warrick of the Washington Post on Nov. 5.
The Danilenko story then went worldwide.
The IAEA report says the agency has "strong
indications" that Iran's development of a "high
explosions initiation system", which it has
described as an "implosion system" for a nuclear
weapon, was "assisted by the work of a foreign
expert who was not only knowledgeable on these
technologies, but who, a Member State has
informed the Agency, worked for much of his
career in the nuclear weapon program of the country of his origin."
The report offers no other evidence of
Danilenko's involvement in the development of an initiation system.
The member state obviously learned that Danilenko
had worked during the Soviet period at the
All-Russian Scientific Research Institute of
Technical Physics in Snezhinsk, Russia, which was
well known for its work on development of nuclear
warheads and simply assumed that he had been involved in that work.
However, further research would have revealed
that Danilenko worked from the beginning of his
career in a part of the Institute that
specialised in the synthesis of diamonds.
Danilenko wrote in an account of the early work
in the field published in 2006 that he was among
the scientists in the "gas dynamics group" at the
Institute who were "the first to start studies on diamond synthesis in 1960".
Danilenko's recollections of the early period of
his career are in a chapter of the book,
"Ultrananocrystalline Diamond: Synthesis,
Properties and Applications" edited by Olga A.
Shenderova and Dieter M. Gruen, published in 2006.
Another chapter in the book covering the history
of Russian patents related to nanodiamonds
documents the fact that Danilenko's centre at the
Institute developed key processes as early as
1963-66 that were later used at major "detonaton
nanodiamond" production centres.
Danilenko left the Institute in 1989 and joined
the Institute of Materials Science Problems in
Ukraine, according to the authors of that chapter.
Danilenko's major accomplishment, according to
the authors, has been the development of a
large-scale technology for producing
ultradispersed diamonds, a particular application
of nanodiamonds. The technology, which was later
implemented by the "ALIT" company in Zhitomir,
Ukraine, is based on an explosion chamber 100
cubic metres in volume, which Danilenko designed.
Beginning in 1993, Danilenko was a principal in a
company called "Nanogroup" which was established
initially in the Ukraine but is now based in
Prague. The company's website boasts that it has
"the strongest team of scientists" which had been
involved in the "introduction of nanodiamonds in
1960 and the first commercial applications of nanodiamonds in 2000".
The declared aim of the company is to supply
worldwide demand for nanodiamonds.
Iran has an aggressive programme to develop its
nanotechnology sector, and it includes as one
major focus nanodiamonds, as blogger Moon of
Alabama has pointed out. That blog was the first
source to call attention to Danilenko's nanodiamond background.
Danilenko clearly explained that the purpose of
his work in Iran was to help the development of a
nanodiamond industry in the country.
The report states that the "foreign expert" was
in Iran from 1996 to about 2002, "ostensibly to
assist in the development of a facility and
techniques for making ultra dispersed diamonds
(UDDs) or nanodiamonds
" That wording suggests
that nanodiamonds were merely a cover for his real purpose in Iran.
The report says the expert "also lectured on
explosive physics and its applications", without
providing any further detail about what applications were involved.
The fact that the IAEA and Albright were made
aware of Danilenko's nanodiamond work in Iran
before embracing the "former Soviet nuclear
weapons specialist" story makes their failure to
make any independent inquiry into his background even more revealing.
The tale of a Russian nuclear weapons scientist
helping construct an "implosion system" for a
nuclear weapon is the most recent iteration of a
theme that the IAEA introduced in its May 2008
report, which mentioned a five-page document
describing experimentation with a "complex
multipoint initiation system to detonate a
substantial amount of high explosives in
hemispherical geometry" and to monitor the detonation.
Iran acknowledged using "exploding bridge wire"
detonators such as those mentioned in that
document for conventional military and civilian
applications. But it denounced the document,
along with the others in the "alleged studies"
collection purporting to be from an Iranian
nuclear weapons research programme, as fakes.
Careful examination of the "alleged studies"
documents has revealed inconsistencies and other
anomalies that give evidence of fraud. But the
IAEA, the United States and its allies in the
IAEA continue to treat the documents as though
there were no question about their authenticity.
The unnamed member state that informed the agency
about Danilenko's alleged experience as a Soviet
nuclear weapons scientist is almost certainly
Israel, which has been the source of virtually
all the purported intelligence on Iranian work on
nuclear weapons over the past decade.
Israel has made no secret of its determination to
influence world opinion on the Iranian nuclear
programme by disseminating information to
governments and news media, including purported
Iran government documents. Israeli foreign
ministry and intelligence officials told
journalists Douglas Frantz and Catherine Collins
about the special unit of Mossad dedicated to
that task at the very time the fraudulent documents were being produced.
In an interview in September 2008, Albright said
Olli Heinonen, then deputy director for
safeguards at the IAEA, had told him that a
document from a member state had convinced him
that the "alleged studies" documents were
genuine. Albright said the state was "probably Israel".
The Jerusalem Post's Yaakov Katz reported
Wednesday that Israeli intelligence agencies had
"provided critical information used in the
report", the purpose of which was to "push
through a new regime of sanctions against Tehran
."
*Gareth Porter is an investigative historian and
journalist specialising in U.S. national security
policy. The paperback edition of his latest book,
"Perils of Dominance: Imbalance of Power and the
Road to War in Vietnam", was published in 2006.
(END)
Freedom Archives
522 Valencia Street
San Francisco, CA 94110
415 863-9977
www.Freedomarchives.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20111110/b0e2e099/attachment.htm>
More information about the News
mailing list