[News] Wikileaks Haiti: The Aristide Files
Anti-Imperialist News
news at freedomarchives.org
Sun Aug 7 19:38:36 EDT 2011
Wikileaks Haiti: The Aristide Files
Kim Ives and Ansel Herz | August 5, 2011 - Nation Magazine
US officials led a far-reaching international
campaign aimed at keeping former Haitian
President Jean-Bertrand Aristide exiled in South
Africa, rendering him a virtual prisoner there
for the last seven years, according to secret US State Department cables.
The cables show that high-level US and UN
officials even discussed a politically motivated
prosecution of Aristide to prevent him from
gaining more traction with the Haitian population and returning to Haiti.
The secret cables, made available to the Haitian
weekly newspaper Haïti Liberté by WikiLeaks, show
how the political defeat of Aristide and his
Lavalas movement has been the central pillar of
US policy toward the Caribbean nation over the
last two US administrations, even thoughor
perhaps becauseUS officials understood that he
was the most popular political figure in Haiti.
They also reveal how US officials and their
diplomatic counterparts from France, Canada, the
UN and the Vatican tried to vilify and ostracize the Haitian political leader.
For the Vatican, Aristide was an active
proponent of voodoo. For Washington, he was
dangerous to Haitis democratic consolidation,
according to the secret US cables.
Aristide was overthrown in a bloody February 2004
coup supported by Washington and fomented by
right-wing paramilitary forces and the Haitian
elite. In the aftermath of the coup, more than
3,000 people were killed and thousands of
supporters of Aristide and his Fanmi Lavalas political party were jailed.
The United States maintained publicly that
Aristide resigned in the face of a ragtag force
of former Haitian army soldiers rampaging in
Haitis north. But Aristide called his escort by
a US Navy SEAL team on his flight into exile a modern-day kidnapping.
Two months later, the UN Stabilization Mission in
Haiti (MINUSTAH) was established, a 9,000-strong
UN occupation force that still oversees Latin
Americas first independent nation.
Aristide has spoken forcefully against the UN
occupation, particularly in his 2010 year-end
letter to the Haitian people. We cannot forget
the $5 billion which has already been spent for
MINUSTAH over these past six years, he wrote.
Anybody can see how many houses, hospitals, and
schools that wasted money could have built for
the victims of the January 12, 2010, earthquake
that destroyed much of Port-au-Prince and surrounding regions.
Such positions are major reasons Washington
fought to get and keep Aristide out of Haiti, the
cables make clear. A premature departure of
MINUSTAH would leave the [Haitian]
government...vulnerable to...resurgent populist
and anti-market economy political
forcesreversing gains of the last two years,
wrote US Ambassador Janet Sanderson in an October
1, 2008, cable. MINUSTAH is an indispensable
tool in realizing core USG [US government] policy interests in Haiti.
At a high-level meeting five years ago, top US
and UN officials discussed how the Aristide
Movement Must Be Stopped, according to an August
2, 2006, cable. It described how former
Guatemalan diplomat Edmond Mulet, then chief of
MINUSTAH, urged US legal action against Aristide
to prevent the former president from gaining more
traction with the Haitian population and returning to Haiti.
At Mulets request, UN Secretary General Kofi
Annan urged South Africas President Thabo Mbeki
to ensure that Aristide remained in South Africa.
President Obama and Kofi Annans successor, Ban
Ki-moon, also intervened to urge Pretoria to keep
Aristide in South Africa. The secret cables
report that Aristides return to Haiti would be a
disaster, according to the Vatican, and
catastrophic, according to the French.
But the regional and Haitian view was quite
different. US Ambassador James Foley admitted in
a confidential March 22, 2005, cable that an
August 2004 poll showed that Aristide was still
the only figure in Haiti with a favorability rating above 50%.
The Bahamian Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell,
apparently referring to Haitis revolutionary
leader Toussaint Louvertures kidnapping and
imprisonment in the Jura mountains in 1802,
warned that a perceived Banishing Policy has
racial and historical overtones in the Caribbean
that reminds inhabitants of the region of slavery and past abuse.
Keeping the Pressure On
After Aristide left Jamaica for exile in South
Africa on May 30, 2004, the US government worked
overtime to keep him out of Haiti and even the
hemisphere, even though the Haitian constitution
and international law stipulate that every
Haitian citizen has the right to be in his homeland.
When Dominican President Leonel Fernández
suggested at a hemispheric conference eight
months after the coup that Aristide should return
and play a role in Haitis political future, the
United States reacted angrily, saying in a cable
that Fernández had been wrong in advocating the
inclusion in the process of former president Jean Bertrand Aristide.
The US Ambassador to the Dominican Republic
admonished Fernández during a pull-aside at a social event.
Aristide had led a violent gang involved in
narcotics trafficking and had squandered any
credibility he formerly may have had, US
Ambassador Hertell told him, according to a November 16, 2004, cable.
Nobody has given me any information about that, Fernández replied.
The embassy followed up with a series of
aggressive meetings insisting that the Dominican
government renounce its support for Aristide. The
meetings included a sit-down with the Dominican
president specifically on the subject of Haiti
with the British, Canadian, French, Spanish and US ambassadors.
No charges were ever filed against Aristide for
drug trafficking, although the United States
spent, literally, tens of millions of taxpayer
dollars
trying to pin something, anything on
President Aristide, Ira Kurzban, Aristides
lawyer, told Pacifica Radios Flashpoints in
July. Theyve had an ATF investigation, a tax
investigation, a drug investigation, and now
apparently some kind of corruption
investigation.... The reality is theyve come up
with nothing because there is nothing.
According to a report in Haïti Liberté, other
sources say that a US legal team is still angling to prosecute Aristide.
In 2005, the Fanmi Lavalas political party
planned large demonstrations to mark Aristides
July 15 birthday and call for his return. The US
Ambassador to France, Craig Stapleton, met with
the French diplomatic official Gilles Bienvenu in Paris to discuss the issue.
Bienvenu stated that the GOF [Government of
France] shared our analysis of the implications
of an Aristide return to Haiti, terming the
likely repercussions catastrophic, Stapleton
wrote in a July 1, 2005, cable. Initially
expressing caution when asked about France
demarching the SARG [conveying the message to the
South African government], Bienvenu noted that
Aristide was not a prisoner in South Africa and
that such an action could create difficulties.
Stapleton swiftly overcame Bienvenus reluctance.
Bienvenu agreed to relay US and French shared
concerns to the South African government, saying
that as a country desiring to secure a seat on
the UN Security Council, South Africa could not
afford to be involved in any way with the destabilization of another country.
The Ambassador went even further: Bienvenu
speculated on exactly how Aristide might return,
seeing a possible opportunity to hinder him in
the logistics of reaching Haiti, Stapleton
wrote. If Aristide traveled commercially,
Bienvenu reasoned, he would likely need to
transit certain countries in order to reach
Haiti. Bienvenu suggested a demarche to Caricom
[Caribbean Community] countries by the US and EU
to warn them against facilitating any travel or
other plans Aristide might have. He specifically
recommended speaking to the Dominican Republic,
which could be directly implicated in a return attempt.
Five days later in Ottawa, two Canadian
diplomatic officials met with the US Embassy
personnel. We are on the same sheet with
regards to Aristide, one Canadian affirmed,
according to a July 6, 2005, cable. Even before
these recent rumors, she said, Canada had a clear
position in opposition to the return of Aristide.
Canada shared the message with all
parties...especially the Caricom countries, as well with South Africa.
Vatican Blocks Post-Quake Return of Aristide
The earthquake that killed tens of thousands and
destroyed many parts of the city also threatened
to upend the established political order, worrying diplomats.
US Embassys Deputy Chief of Mission (DCM) met
with a Vatican official in the days after the
earthquake to discuss Church losses and responses.
A January 20, 2010, cable reports, In
discussions with DCM over the past few days,
senior Vatican officials said they were dismayed
about media reports that deposed Haitian
leaderand former priestJean Bertrand Aristide
wished to return to Haiti.... The Vatican's
Assesor (deputy chief of staff equivalent), Msgr.
Peter Wells, said Aristide's presence would
distract from the relief efforts and could become destabilizing.
Then the Vaticans Undersecretary for Relations
with States, Msgr. Ettore Balestrero, conferred
with Archbishop Bernardito Auza in Haiti, who
agreed emphatically that Aristide's return would
be a disaster. Balestrero then conveyed Auza's
views to Archbishop Greene in South Africa, and
asked him also to look for ways to get this
message convincingly to Aristide. DCM suggested
that Greene also convey this message to the SAG [South African government].
The Vaticans position on Aristides return was
augured in earlier cables. In November 2003,
three months before the bloody February 2004 coup
against Aristide, a US political officer met with
the Vaticans MFA Caribbean Affairs Office
Director Giorgio Lingua. He said that effecting
change in Haiti should be easier than in Cuba,
reported US Chargé d'Affaires Brent Hardt in a
November 14, 2003, cable. Unlike Castro, Lingua
observed, Aristide is not ideologically
motivated. This is one personnot a system, he added.
Shortly after the coup, on March 5, 2004, US
Ambassador to the Vatican James Nicholson wrote a
cable reporting that the Holy Sees Deputy
Foreign Minister had no regret at Aristide's
departure, noting that the former priest had been
an active proponent of voodoo.
A Heros Welcome
Aristide ultimately returned to Haiti on March
18, 2011, despite personal calls by President
Obama and UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon to
South Africas President Jacob Zuma to stop him.
They argued he would disrupt Haitis imminent elections.
The problem is exclusion, and the solution is
inclusion, Aristide said during a brief return
speech at the airport after landing. Then he made
his only reference, however oblique, to that
weeks elections from which his party was barred:
The exclusion of Fanmi Lavalas is the exclusion of the majority.
Two days later, the second round of Haitis
elections went off relatively smoothly, but with
historically low voter participation. Some
polling stations in Port-au-Prince were empty,
with stacks of ballot sheets piled high, hours
before they closed. Less than 24 percent of
registered voters went to their polls, according
to official statistics. Other observers say the turnout was much less.
On the morning of Aristides return in
Port-au-Prince, thousands massed outside the
airport in an exuberant, spontaneous
demonstration. They jogged alongside his
motorcade waving Haitian flags and placards
bearing Aristides visage, then scaled the fence
surrounding Aristides home and poured into its
yard until there was no room left to move. The
crowd even climbed the walls and covered the roof.
Sitting in an SUV just twenty feet from the door
to his hastily repaired but mostly empty house,
Aristide and his family waited until a crew of
Haitian policeman managed to clear what resembled
a pathway through the crowd. First his wife and
two daughters emerged from the car and dashed inside the home.
Finally Aristide, diminutive in a sharp blue
suit, stood up in the car doorway and waved. The
crowd roared in excitement and surged around him.
The path to the door vanished. His security
grabbed him and shouldered their way through the
sea of humanity until they got him to the houses
door, through which he popped like a cork, clutching his glasses in his hands.
After a coup, kidnapping, exile, diplomatic
intrigue and his rapturous welcome, Aristide was finally home.
----------
Source URL:
<http://www.thenation.com/article/162598/wikileaks-haiti-aristide-files>http://www.thenation.com/article/162598/wikileaks-haiti-aristide-files
Freedom Archives
522 Valencia Street
San Francisco, CA 94110
415 863-9977
www.Freedomarchives.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://freedomarchives.org/pipermail/news_freedomarchives.org/attachments/20110807/e5586ecb/attachment.htm>
More information about the News
mailing list